{"title": "Comparison of automatability measures across occupations", "xAxis": {"label": "Autor et al.", "lim": [-3.4465900025433047, 3.0697599100120265], "scaleType": "linear"}, "yAxis": {"label": "Duckworth et al.", "lim": [-2.9856589171715076, 2.5766186694793247], "scaleType": "linear"}, "showFrame": true, "objects": [{"type": "scatter", "alpha": 0.3, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -1.3879757172393794, "y": -0.703264111404103, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hydrologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.8738669794255672, "y": 1.0468865595777583, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Inspectors, Testers, Sorters, Samplers, and Weighers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.1666628024119154, "y": -0.2468448983342714, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fine Artists, Including Painters, Sculptors, and Illustrators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.7804981301768894, "y": 1.4128131492590628, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.8795861299816146, "y": -0.39293887141217, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Construction Trades and Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.7687729425831287, "y": 1.273219440448491, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Interviewers and Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.6629131000636508, "y": -1.2988886285450896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marketing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.12378193496383, "y": -0.1346048095820586, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.9277204053432249, "y": -2.6262371076123125, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": -1.398356520939802, "y": -0.6168533309111613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manufactured Building and Mobile Home Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9061688817454226, "y": -2.037588440839733, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Child, Family, and School Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -1.229972685882886, "y": 0.373901442432928, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.7812259575544531, "y": -1.5659064094734048, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chief Executives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -0.0039331134124508, "y": -0.16763154147112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Pipelayers, Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.859323689241689, "y": 1.3803298101336252, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Change Persons and Booth Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.557483831077505, "y": 1.7558837173113977, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -0.1412240429044082, "y": -0.5527694572451863, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graphic Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9563260208308996, "y": -0.2441234706415258, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Family Medicine Physicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1029408398799553, "y": 0.644503347059094, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Opticians, Dispensing", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.4607253338358603, "y": -1.3482477770903285, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "General and Operations Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.112529210646494, "y": -0.8387034031209629, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer and Information Research Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.207129400606792, "y": 0.3481723680214542, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.3411191413364209, "y": 0.0415246816136742, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Pilots", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 1.7633323806856949, "y": 0.3921460972859452, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Subway and Streetcar Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.7317018320835897, "y": -0.2745422755559366, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security Guards", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2438311053934494, "y": 0.586010661477966, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crane and Tower Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.1090292074789271, "y": 0.0404929045074988, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sailors and Marine Oilers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.1597849936475773, "y": 0.3516237433050262, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locomotive Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.9465509258889518, "y": 1.3710831047565135, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coating, Painting, and Spraying Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.4002584839064506, "y": -0.3677346047444751, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.5337725316665024, "y": 0.3029469438659889, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brickmasons and Blockmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2162911735904329, "y": -0.9321808127022048, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.2775952412045133, "y": -1.5087778064233417, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.4105844317226746, "y": 1.560700829857162, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool Grinders, Filers, and Sharpeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.996340114497679, "y": -2.130134449337492, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Healthcare Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": -1.0353559581581828, "y": -2.2378004708678847, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Preschool Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 0.2406121254605465, "y": 0.3371275039604576, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Painters, Paperhangers, Plasterers, and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.8204565641037875, "y": 1.801428006066988, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Sorters, Processors, and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 1.067303770014071, "y": 0.955222790604522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Procurement Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.2588012909362202, "y": -0.216866940362569, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roustabouts, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.2291720398343169, "y": 1.120628475823059, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hotel, Motel, and Resort Desk Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.2592578673812185, "y": -2.104802067846961, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": 1.272530239671472, "y": 0.2040221768988926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.9906848123176468, "y": -1.4118080185502786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Community Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.6730993274418786, "y": -0.054885507302651, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bicycle Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.7660536591214124, "y": -0.4700422776848855, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interior Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.9199418254306408, "y": -2.668711397468404, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Business Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 0.1984900413932157, "y": 1.8719578092751863, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painting, Coating, and Decorating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -0.9651727034022022, "y": -0.8987178135620543, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.8678163958494096, "y": 0.7136489612896567, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling and Sports Book Writers and Runners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.4775046840042845, "y": 1.3791359439209143, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Bleaching and Dyeing Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.4376365754218905, "y": -1.16264327951069, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Museum Technicians and Conservators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.0188198127948211, "y": -2.33120055935641, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemistry Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": 0.4865439553846576, "y": 1.1929440390040476, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Forming Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Synthetic and Glass Fibers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.3192931547383277, "y": 0.6071392311565762, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Production and Operating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.0949537063416281, "y": 0.0286146759473043, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Respiratory Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.4480116316352364, "y": 0.2684435566458819, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Civil Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.458285251111881, "y": -1.148911827350502, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.8988100277128837, "y": 0.2942308019941453, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shampooers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6273322601296695, "y": -0.1854848863177358, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Door Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.170231823568934, "y": -0.9453610782707408, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Programmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.2097198306705703, "y": 1.5129216490218562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Billing and Posting Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.3180282187359726, "y": 0.4686798627869696, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Demonstrators and Product Promoters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8718361075941772, "y": -1.5027066113571017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education and Childcare Administrators, Preschool and Daycare", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.4527867458282585, "y": 0.2902584518293734, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpet Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.1743689098151666, "y": 1.5565751695599128, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Builders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.35719352361029, "y": -0.6473230711421564, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Correctional Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.3878560374962543, "y": -2.643282335004278, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": 1.6176510641006632, "y": 0.5239006998500237, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Slaughterers and Meat Packers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.5428749853667544, "y": -0.1920887362305082, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "General Internal Medicine Physicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.8794611907585571, "y": -1.399588836405913, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer and Information Systems Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.118774713664243, "y": 0.1439327971392235, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0028291672137524, "y": 0.6844563614224998, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stationary Engineers and Boiler Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.9905780385848506, "y": -0.171614762894824, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.7406839953693914, "y": 0.2223620918172356, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tree Trimmers and Pruners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.9380037429031493, "y": -0.8323402544298715, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judicial Law Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.8778901879268389, "y": 0.975936305910642, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meter Readers, Utilities", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.5116881785612835, "y": -0.162600338185487, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Earth Drillers, Except Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.146188611016774, "y": 0.1627160111007565, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dishwashers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8317415685275095, "y": -0.11086498616951, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Glass Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.8454763822267284, "y": -0.1447877612628614, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatric Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.1745555230932532, "y": 0.4790755270549238, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pesticide Handlers, Sprayers, and Applicators, Vegetation", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -2.651248398474005, "y": -2.608923856792725, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forestry and Conservation Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": 0.6647895434714719, "y": 0.8568638720508708, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveying and Mapping Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.0558322850299701, "y": 0.2366386184918601, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Glaziers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4950131724181174, "y": 0.2360885305822549, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Craft Artists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.26970421220172, "y": -2.6293716755261967, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Clergy", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": -1.036151212776815, "y": -2.732828117778288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "History Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 0.7819185045085033, "y": 0.2777248192014639, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Air Traffic Controllers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6262646108388754, "y": -0.0403126539131557, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pest Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.6170505642570706, "y": -0.2480800809665278, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.5201602731015502, "y": 0.0744443269178712, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -2.1096742408509983, "y": -1.3228912447938022, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.6366551142657275, "y": -1.3884652963593178, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Community Health Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.5470181213201686, "y": 0.8212605872153034, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meat, Poultry, and Fish Cutters and Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.9388818956190284, "y": 0.2369794470727298, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floral Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0066758757353878, "y": -0.8414084191278177, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Software Quality Assurance Analysts and Testers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.8801617726657183, "y": -2.541761637287628, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematical Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": 0.2491564480854882, "y": 1.7622536496490635, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Layout Workers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 1.136975723495231, "y": 1.2980169911833424, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Production Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.6790061859797019, "y": -0.1652631437762826, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refractory Materials Repairers, Except Brickmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7819356456226125, "y": -0.946527158098239, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paralegals and Legal Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.2894094336903337, "y": -0.0329482528203985, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Acupuncturists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.5563316338766712, "y": -0.9418435732181752, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Solar Photovoltaic Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.5764248510627038, "y": 0.3536406966720705, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hoist and Winch Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.4951107921040945, "y": -0.1513996247075982, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Servers, Nonrestaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.096748042827857, "y": 1.8427586256792496, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foundry Mold and Coremakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 0.3169447298842093, "y": -0.0479711877823379, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Licensed Practical and Licensed Vocational Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.8427647104734115, "y": -1.0047428715367277, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.7979287796407275, "y": -2.7172264040478185, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 1.4174885121922616, "y": 1.361792335852495, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding, Forming, Pressing, and Compacting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.6001567912318234, "y": -0.3111930460454263, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Surveillance Officers and Gambling Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.332257858369244, "y": -0.2028872212087956, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8628367773058664, "y": 0.7746008246257917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Safety Telecommunicators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.9253881581355786, "y": -2.344539000191097, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adult Basic Education, Adult Secondary Education, and English as a Second Language Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -1.115542120743649, "y": 0.009364624326135, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security and Fire Alarm Systems Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.8478630448741451, "y": 1.5015067550940344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plating Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.6955245225744036, "y": -0.655823973118674, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Police and Detectives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -2.107337904574303, "y": -1.532814095730903, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Emergency Management Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -1.459045469791104, "y": -2.256893018825412, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -0.7923693052017245, "y": -0.6744430225845489, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heating, Air Conditioning, and Refrigeration Mechanics and Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.5133653075622094, "y": 0.4174315200255791, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hairdressers, Hairstylists, and Cosmetologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.899884285005504, "y": -2.5323608835489293, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engineering Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": 1.9096847130366288, "y": 1.520447461405228, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Woodworking Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Except Sawing", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.9450373452170504, "y": -2.574408626833438, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nursing Instructors and Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": 1.260815125874153, "y": 0.1694948798295365, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Diagnostic Medical Sonographers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.6058133203748001, "y": -0.1604891393506641, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Outdoor Power Equipment and Other Small Engine Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1802755546079249, "y": -0.1244658308357811, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer, Automated Teller, and Office Machine Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 2.308011656461644, "y": 1.9413459882682331, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "2.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -0.7917310476663457, "y": -1.1033513439531422, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.2119979095391702, "y": 0.1680053488323742, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surgical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.1845001167699116, "y": 0.0903826535834356, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Gambling Services Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.8851386916400845, "y": 0.2270209994466562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8311679997784562, "y": 0.9351172929478712, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.1859608627599854, "y": 2.1779342284244967, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fabric and Apparel Patternmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.2"}}, {"x": -0.6235878556784445, "y": 0.3348088161636844, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Yard Engineers, Dinkey Operators, and Hostlers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.6608103499457694, "y": -1.7678616136078094, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -1.1576690232763411, "y": -0.7029852413785092, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Zoologists and Wildlife Biologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.2758731672301599, "y": 0.2401071260235256, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sound Engineering Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3103914296664506, "y": -0.4673492459563933, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chefs and Head Cooks", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.1052002908318708, "y": -0.273521999751212, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorcycle Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.3456587931753214, "y": 0.2153808180767137, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiation Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1662019129923107, "y": -0.7390983953330813, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.4470366621020035, "y": -0.0341683322074101, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronic Equipment Installers and Repairers, Motor Vehicles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.6354002347736443, "y": -2.0301446386389803, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Arbitrators, Mediators, and Conciliators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -2.330784055904513, "y": -2.1767159539730945, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Educational, Guidance, and Career Counselors and Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -0.793744986464031, "y": -0.3922193656811593, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Home Appliance Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.49820798587486, "y": 1.7863003995872202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographic Process Workers and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 0.8579685140459804, "y": 1.1891247919986858, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packers and Packagers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.0183809588051669, "y": 1.887106686042624, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutters and Trimmers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -1.2795218700990303, "y": -0.0974683708909521, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2623391526162582, "y": 0.900993163118933, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statistical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.003670446762344, "y": 1.409203674469517, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fiberglass Laminators and Fabricators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.0628692390837011, "y": 0.3723065544255295, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscaping and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.3089559447421135, "y": 1.0235867970376489, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.360155271736588, "y": 1.492699458087622, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding, Lapping, Polishing, and Buffing Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.5396079321446071, "y": -0.5518129749396737, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Examiners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.454425854241453, "y": -0.9628467291744296, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Systems Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.9669829948160152, "y": 1.2956656757359215, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rolling Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.5710404730541805, "y": -0.0992771637029905, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Equipment Installers and Repairers, Except Line Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.184724227600342, "y": -0.1631361056165061, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radio, Cellular, and Tower Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.0806273539194895, "y": -0.1227204020776113, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Neurologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.1645226637058472, "y": 2.2039702539503323, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe and Leather Workers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.2"}}, {"x": 0.7711931576309774, "y": 0.225039264897638, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Assistants and Laboratory Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.3926167440556287, "y": -0.4819744010628344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architects, Except Landscape and Naval", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.6267937654755713, "y": 1.147552146230877, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Clerks, General", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.1586119749940411, "y": -2.277064713235202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -1.504803091190655, "y": -0.7406830716048846, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.7281594872419926, "y": 1.7873960081536429, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Jewelers and Precious Stone and Metal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 1.4459361806357918, "y": 1.6445870970627177, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molders, Shapers, and Casters, Except Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.008514111373503, "y": -0.4429036073973532, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Physiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -2.5673369967257145, "y": -1.1699556894135414, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Urban and Regional Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.5481013322748092, "y": 0.6073499519443853, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Excavating and Loading Machine and Dragline Operators, Surface Mining", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.4838150007725963, "y": 1.4411239202290629, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coil Winders, Tapers, and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.3646337058614783, "y": -0.1812189303463847, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pile Driver Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.413652326235589, "y": 0.1143381488429239, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineering and Operations Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.7115386799945627, "y": 0.1828910216048654, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cost Estimators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5943329550635068, "y": -0.3360795750912868, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Septic Tank Servicers and Sewer Pipe Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.5199121450668008, "y": -0.0655319425515262, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Claims Adjusters, Examiners, and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.5305181232195075, "y": 1.4603533033796143, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tellers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.4865023643391553, "y": -1.3317923857960092, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising and Promotions Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.9498596825735608, "y": -1.7833572722261763, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Kindergarten through Secondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -1.349270017361749, "y": -0.96504009798446, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.2870916936583988, "y": 1.1818004823308954, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logging Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.3979925945108996, "y": -0.348087243638465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Microbiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.9289446585442722, "y": -1.2589299565956769, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation, Storage, and Distribution Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.261215927667404, "y": -1.7408200474382716, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Labor Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -1.2959256040461369, "y": -0.6073445863659294, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.2173345606272563, "y": -0.1848561383487699, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Midwives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3419903257028654, "y": -0.4617316588496061, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3116158920602814, "y": -0.583167413121328, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Information Security Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2322879970452644, "y": -0.061706650784504, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Costume Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0367234606969555, "y": 1.5209936330821148, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.096593567122127, "y": -0.0651222108483786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Iron and Steel Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -2.2426924043436363, "y": -2.616885242852558, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art, Drama, and Music Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": -0.0893882922911258, "y": -1.1661590396937955, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Writers and Authors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1027259585525155, "y": -0.4085660374368387, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.255497013586391, "y": -0.2994560124669799, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Service Unit Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.1435896306415737, "y": 0.0642342953041333, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airline Pilots, Copilots, and Flight Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5207884919746754, "y": 0.0720559190126742, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0421236179435285, "y": -1.177366000143982, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Scientists and Specialists, Including Health", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.228247972750638, "y": -2.409703904962014, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "School Psychologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.4"}}, {"x": 1.855060775139609, "y": 1.6625597546324866, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Carriers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 1.7172717451093302, "y": 1.4181395747339234, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Word Processors and Typists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.427905954618115, "y": -0.4943430449631734, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elevator and Escalator Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3883263612610775, "y": 0.2485157395365199, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.1326045094331685, "y": -0.3791970736271638, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscape Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.3331083471176046, "y": -0.4797806591274116, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transit and Railroad Police", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.5689573020554451, "y": -0.1239395143197442, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3988620055019044, "y": -0.5098825880808053, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Labor Contractors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.878637112989117, "y": 0.6269956525558877, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Eligibility Interviewers, Government Programs", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.716245025559664, "y": 1.1527328310774192, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Metal-Refining Furnace Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1153503650067896, "y": -1.1556775094581393, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Scientists, Except Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.7545121597708432, "y": 1.2422895564771297, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engine and Other Machine Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.1649855703243135, "y": -0.0420106626690999, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dermatologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.2055050168889151, "y": -0.4836202557061854, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Umpires, Referees, and Other Sports Officials", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.8269838306805912, "y": -0.093692338467903, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Short Order", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.4563566688638634, "y": -1.1617731512934864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Librarians and Media Collections Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.3355795054575677, "y": 1.3466121754914704, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pourers and Casters, Metal", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.6896623194547988, "y": 2.2987739897349497, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tailors, Dressmakers, and Custom Sewers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": 0.9269442287740294, "y": 1.565961621418977, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drilling and Boring Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.2503349809478545, "y": 0.9286634920001388, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Separating, Filtering, Clarifying, Precipitating, and Still Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.805608689891823, "y": 1.429052367735809, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forging Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.0452772118071618, "y": -0.9063660622523873, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operations Research Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.7843564994601844, "y": -0.6099370457054695, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fundraisers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0931249019367593, "y": 1.7052715669735865, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding and Polishing Workers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -0.5220682912726096, "y": -1.3472465105242164, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Administrative Services Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.3974472910211182, "y": 1.505018502741447, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lathe and Turning Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.275127175318862, "y": -0.6651682107500729, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Scientists and Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.6245158458438212, "y": 0.0326712023699116, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmologists, Except Pediatric", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.1035045259606848, "y": -2.7225711963132886, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Philosophy and Religion Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 0.6177573881765728, "y": 0.7882043315988058, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Driver/Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.860101367472801, "y": 0.3548373473085439, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.7016666738235096, "y": -0.7020121684394975, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Firefighting and Prevention Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2536031979677634, "y": 0.6503514694257053, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loading and Moving Machine Operators, Underground Mining", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.5952167662256497, "y": -0.1872948975572711, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail-Track Laying and Maintenance Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.4106782716026849, "y": 1.3181482728807226, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correspondence Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3718634252361831, "y": -1.3023433033111529, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.5514297625619868, "y": -0.2650298339398956, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marine Engineers and Naval Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.9979158190254164, "y": -0.7905491547110118, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.168257496434765, "y": -0.1908360562358057, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Control and Valve Installers and Repairers, Except Mechanical Door", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.3887831446158225, "y": -0.587643689307551, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0183989055691776, "y": -0.368918026723411, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.1291664571641664, "y": -2.2412458966992697, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Middle School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 0.8167005964033244, "y": 0.1695354610987684, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiologic Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3756481511626501, "y": -0.1817054183550576, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Avionics Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.601366659204723, "y": 0.2409215936334452, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ambulance Drivers and Attendants, Except Emergency Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.0651753538796804, "y": 1.3420251508452046, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welders, Cutters, Solderers, and Brazers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.8997798001241091, "y": -1.9242465390964, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Historians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 1.2864419155115894, "y": 1.3946033438568823, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adhesive Bonding Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.8575731168305705, "y": 1.2798238028284763, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laundry and Dry-Cleaning Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.3439734260570267, "y": -0.0033063416134053, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.043337764227231, "y": 0.24030288527786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -2.1191467593298605, "y": -2.5338622567240234, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "English Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": -0.1456937718268784, "y": 0.1724766590864146, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Underwriters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.302936056976872, "y": 0.3420696689066105, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -2.2678319184750424, "y": -2.653244603099937, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -1.260550163321611, "y": -0.2058562199341601, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Obstetricians and Gynecologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.961096082230804, "y": -0.511314805213771, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Waiters and Waitresses", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3626576043666109, "y": 1.318346390052436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Order Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3409863554482197, "y": 0.2350760170975867, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paperhangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.543237498245881, "y": 1.775894525214811, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pressers, Textile, Garment, and Related Materials", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -0.7579204616488344, "y": -0.0039737005200961, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronics Engineers, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.9822806035794333, "y": 1.622345182175969, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Prepress Technicians and Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 1.4989676451123788, "y": 1.157798036146149, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brokerage Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -2.00606003700463, "y": -2.67816093181928, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foreign Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.0654027329048016, "y": 0.1909323682370788, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fence Erectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5333638512536465, "y": -0.4168141050055866, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Divers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.5597607197091468, "y": 0.0789697885283841, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.1702958363252753, "y": -0.0530173909039781, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chiropractors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.3104585936143174, "y": -0.3575749900676316, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.275963820611964, "y": 0.8175593606035257, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest and Conservation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.6229718502009335, "y": 0.1798296252449561, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drywall and Ceiling Tile Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.5084109052552163, "y": 0.9420320518151852, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Butchers and Meat Cutters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.5791583819927179, "y": -0.0301736206021941, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance Workers, Machinery", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -1.7576292009047862, "y": -2.048504374423446, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial-Organizational Psychologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -1.873748106549436, "y": -2.4096722369038948, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Instructional Coordinators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.4"}}, {"x": 0.6283372102046054, "y": 1.5692512950702353, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Metal Fabricators and Fitters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 1.1113836504282495, "y": 1.1424885873388584, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bill and Account Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.1226380568499008, "y": -0.1054403554296852, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anesthesiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3625311479896964, "y": 1.607089861069479, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Couriers and Messengers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.8611705519922842, "y": 0.4845507504345065, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bridge and Lock Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2038056414528196, "y": 1.7037371555840484, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cabinetmakers and Bench Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -0.4180262180863729, "y": -1.0137543579788193, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "News Analysts, Reporters, and Journalists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5173509320945054, "y": 0.2138198991103129, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surgical Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.2121641423044445, "y": 1.1668832916626033, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crushing, Grinding, and Polishing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.3532651305851383, "y": 1.4567698277364611, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stockers and Order Fillers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.3808401820098453, "y": -2.1973074295516635, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Preschool", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -0.4287701686383378, "y": -0.1882996330761322, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Signal and Track Switch Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.6814896517281743, "y": -2.678043052247481, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropology and Archeology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -1.173473636669783, "y": -0.6284146529175972, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietitians and Nutritionists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.3942567266559647, "y": 0.1449935856638015, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4391685872432179, "y": 1.122053898003729, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fallers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.2415292771712032, "y": -0.2006300736652895, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4476966830581191, "y": 1.4436314059819304, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welding, Soldering, and Brazing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.2733249177323729, "y": 1.1278383693052152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaning, Washing, and Metal Pickling Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.5249279594054749, "y": -0.3778462498280805, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Car Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.3776478305970298, "y": -2.1916749066981374, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 0.7206932847569244, "y": 1.296698571108416, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furnace, Kiln, Oven, Drier, and Kettle Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.5596459401413999, "y": 0.1671578337793612, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audio and Video Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.842045453577487, "y": 0.1573230344851855, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Examiners and Collectors, and Revenue Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.3938952542378198, "y": -0.6749912044561487, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.517268926304522, "y": -0.6703019897005987, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correctional Officers and Jailers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.0319613075533194, "y": 0.0789976584300912, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plasterers and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.7285894926632013, "y": -0.5375808481437458, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geoscientists, Except Hydrologists and Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.564049581303414, "y": -0.224750512462694, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.6736007874983986, "y": -0.2357350142406782, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance and Repair Workers, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.979860085336681, "y": 0.6477413017014126, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.6481511697313108, "y": -0.4170901505059415, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Science and Protection Technicians, Including Health", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.6033952757796771, "y": -0.9696197679012744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Database Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.3561213822478264, "y": -1.080705035950846, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actuaries", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.0744809961151065, "y": 0.5674793985091129, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Brokers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9527003673193264, "y": -0.5732530508282707, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7477243545871888, "y": -1.1082097926900292, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Purchasing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.6000761800414834, "y": -0.2368697348737455, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Genetic Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.4258112577101307, "y": 1.2868250719940093, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Drawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.941582977348845, "y": -0.063603007346989, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physician Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9175406008240258, "y": 0.4156730071465573, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Court, Municipal, and License Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.9648326392566368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telephone Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.2105395982479372, "y": 1.4944749258992505, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting and Slicing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 2.113268072214425, "y": 0.6088210704439724, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Dealers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1356029499591191, "y": 0.0544638808907855, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Institution and Cafeteria", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.3487615050458227, "y": -1.5698461478187382, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Probation Officers and Correctional Treatment Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -1.270680593235209, "y": -0.5227517808048713, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.3911799612513187, "y": -0.1120048346310218, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Landscaping, Lawn Service, and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.5494797868144166, "y": -0.2838007226561892, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wind Turbine Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.472712350022055, "y": 0.7873494888731263, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.7761718702554996, "y": 0.5432782618324024, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refuse and Recyclable Material Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.7769366037314608, "y": 0.9876383819259246, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5194640396300716, "y": 0.4968517150190133, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manicurists and Pedicurists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3842542364284055, "y": 0.0257971916548012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera and Photographic Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -2.092558237933194, "y": -2.0429762380992504, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -1.7413174128753748, "y": -2.5995567005637263, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geography Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": 0.5816629934821564, "y": 0.3474812011467645, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Skincare Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.1071197858238884, "y": -0.1754609527810028, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.2758565602456502, "y": -0.0526944637607085, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4599543797063599, "y": 0.8571361904186984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Pump System Operators, Refinery Operators, and Gaugers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.4797733577769951, "y": 0.2345619850291924, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Railroad Brake, Signal, and Switch Operators and Locomotive Firers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0582176742081917, "y": -0.2457903655302724, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Boilermakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.764086569407202, "y": -1.844303305266324, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 0.6043578751229657, "y": -0.1260889466911172, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Budget Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2744437195026044, "y": 0.2537889101602624, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Brickmasons, Blockmasons, Stonemasons, and Tile and Marble Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.1623899316545318, "y": 0.808740204622335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Truck and Tractor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.8146553091301973, "y": 0.0520040199750981, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction and Building Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.8964587515708811, "y": -0.3711124076315791, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest and Conservation Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.7877720885971908, "y": 1.5237718807119005, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting, Punching, and Press Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.5678870145431338, "y": -0.6174693193341871, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.8333851587986286, "y": -1.2030330140812149, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric and Space Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.917086462550661, "y": -2.5083700753920217, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": -0.870607815023757, "y": -0.7627317800520613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -2.298149445515067, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Directors, Religious Activities and Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-3.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -0.9100470331741998, "y": 0.0051004306838344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthotists and Prosthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.549582894022315, "y": 0.6606012357167904, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0691995314368749, "y": 0.3581966381529175, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bus Drivers, Transit and Intercity", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.6563552980344222, "y": -0.099092448645622, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Farming, Fishing, and Forestry Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3922974939376122, "y": 1.2911533154558028, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Structure, Surfaces, Rigging, and Systems Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.1956972048805025, "y": 0.6225937214772261, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pump Operators, Except Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.7188723580944468, "y": 1.125185949742516, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Receptionists and Information Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.6559732566198974, "y": -0.4230033336470683, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compliance Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.9731805213137112, "y": 0.2587917883637263, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.4115537158778558, "y": 0.4988286834907223, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Barbers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2762382986028072, "y": -0.070292272589261, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Anesthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2801289932939732, "y": -0.2559700437728052, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Network and Computer Systems Administrators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5306687829631038, "y": -0.116606103763896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Machinery Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.0169977620024206, "y": -0.5972586966591582, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Technical Writers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.894622309351864, "y": -0.2576003139314876, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.2155165824501373, "y": -0.4416143440693185, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meeting, Convention, and Event Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0464369491938291, "y": -0.0492848157200664, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hazardous Materials Removal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.7218942602992406, "y": 1.560602845272098, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -0.6023736472329735, "y": 0.0080754223642107, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Laborers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.0038309389872154, "y": -0.0866683460247287, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Installers and Repairers, Transportation Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.5990875575807667, "y": -0.1705728751798026, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geological Technicians, Except Hydrologic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.9537474241394196, "y": -0.4695803771373444, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Health and Safety Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.1514179239536149, "y": -1.3650349396344752, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.438563742232027, "y": 0.1595452472778691, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Merchandise Displayers and Window Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.7211382988891573, "y": -2.1287863077952545, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marriage and Family Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": 0.6741424531705897, "y": 0.5870702804299744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0400367106015421, "y": 1.3581428982909962, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Desktop Publishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.5306538276477482, "y": -1.3809781425997854, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Management Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.0482384515239916, "y": -0.1797835636212159, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electric Motor, Power Tool, and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.2959987074785453, "y": -0.2556886459549692, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mobile Heavy Equipment Mechanics, Except Engines", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.3111711767115684, "y": -1.0487510009390903, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Trainers and Group Fitness Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5097164017692816, "y": 0.6965858881825896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.065549841268239, "y": -0.1718972931391926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Makeup Artists, Theatrical and Performance", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8260723631505726, "y": 0.8637993315744092, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dispatchers, Except Police, Fire, and Ambulance", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.1464368897532982, "y": 1.5355923226973918, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Print Binding and Finishing Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.7699093916046311, "y": -1.6600603910000598, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Music Directors and Composers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.0236777409365872, "y": 0.2258995609051106, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.2273720488599744, "y": 0.3267894098957402, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.2612872430164695, "y": 1.72463420762643, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -1.0402418835199054, "y": 0.2620153821171809, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Massage Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4516868248810886, "y": -0.1060314374146394, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletic Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.1054502388754892, "y": -0.3538578335734947, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.314238342840608, "y": -0.4341561179977524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bartenders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.0876278336010032, "y": 0.4801970194085776, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telemarketers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.6774524291926896, "y": 1.316520428518349, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Data Entry Keyers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.2124474289143454, "y": -2.688644038440529, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 0.0277980723573438, "y": -1.1236658608653378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.2548064624972122, "y": -0.5746377873236459, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fire Inspectors and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.6368033312319524, "y": 1.0082236452209374, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooling and Freezing Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.0184082093377855, "y": -0.0887372080194467, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dining Room and Cafeteria Attendants and Bartender Helpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4357097431058516, "y": 0.1501108887472947, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.045496651541581, "y": -1.1113614499336677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health and Safety Engineers, Except Mining Safety Engineers and Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.4025694848468618, "y": 0.0645656627439272, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Floor, Ceiling, and Wall", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.6841921599322112, "y": 0.3267690607129359, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2695348951313973, "y": 0.9492348782529744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Assistants, Clerical", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.0422660961428759, "y": 0.0615743057244599, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Watch and Clock Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.3540124704030162, "y": -0.2003963631226069, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forensic Science Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5777200704469947, "y": -0.1112813791686588, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hearing Aid Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.7048764560791582, "y": 0.5692671316299338, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rock Splitters, Quarry", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.1637615899672478, "y": -1.0269771718045064, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Property, Real Estate, and Community Association Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.8338399312873329, "y": -1.018275313626945, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.4282417280018922, "y": 0.6461099309865285, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 2.3664798768120976, "y": 0.5573198731795456, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Proofreaders and Copy Markers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.6156410841929586, "y": 0.514763818096608, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.5041814617212416, "y": 1.632352658323323, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 1.4246315496926814, "y": -0.0068831250513402, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orderlies", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.2747895742280462, "y": -1.292031744233323, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Human Service Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.4239930589522561, "y": -0.3227550962315627, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Film and Video Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.2798001700417336, "y": 1.1445916937000815, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cargo and Freight Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.574501587778538, "y": -1.493247769751932, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical and Health Services Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -1.7290811173566742, "y": -2.6449241353147617, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Communications Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": -1.0455712529, "y": -0.7490959038593289, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Producers and Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.1842021869879643, "y": 0.9174497967651492, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Counter and Rental Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 2.5187493896221773, "y": 1.171126463083087, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Cage Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.0276743659096343, "y": -0.8942702015683808, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Title Examiners, Abstractors, and Searchers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.863599975464569, "y": -0.6342625584980368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fish and Game Wardens", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.8802520756486636, "y": 0.5652800761572494, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers, Farm, Ranch, and Aquacultural Animals", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.001681428901726, "y": 1.7285711405480202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Timing Device Assemblers and Adjusters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.2048261572016251, "y": 0.547670200932374, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4210110569352954, "y": 0.2475721438040315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painters, Construction and Maintenance", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0932713927568725, "y": 0.2239599236095198, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ship Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.8235694729289396, "y": 0.2802350995882681, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.17353522050073, "y": -0.176304879505349, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0796191480762997, "y": 0.5266330739566093, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Light Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.6529288275583993, "y": 0.3292530068626986, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Traffic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.3864681686870737, "y": -0.1299147782969472, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electro-Mechanical and Mechatronics Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.5980359105672828, "y": -2.041401742974442, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Administrative Law Judges, Adjudicators, and Hearing Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -0.6794706237786028, "y": -0.1085833910473886, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operating Engineers and Other Construction Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.5141610416358646, "y": 1.1303084801685592, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "New Accounts Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.1873026308664851, "y": 0.0120132310379012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiovisual Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.816648081382791, "y": 0.4801909601549012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2544325896028706, "y": -0.0459941329299251, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Hygienists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.0967578935314926, "y": 0.1666970403450055, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cardiovascular Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.5831949185341108, "y": 1.2622247112602716, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machinists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.2477792555226949, "y": 0.2393192126268669, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Cargo Handling Supervisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1309808706579929, "y": -0.1020536542191781, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Enforcement Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.5616692176061004, "y": -0.2006143371252591, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fast Food and Counter Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.2902226819176425, "y": 0.9841193288261854, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parts Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.085384831815483, "y": -2.6552829380353216, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 1.4668247961780096, "y": -0.1766677373015863, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roof Bolters, Mining", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.6635636563599853, "y": -1.7848479563582245, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation and Benefits Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -0.2913852991570329, "y": 0.0143352821557936, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.7476282021598943, "y": -1.3908082194129945, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropologists and Archeologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.059243035120383, "y": 1.1724090113545582, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food and Tobacco Roasting, Baking, and Drying Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.051413068811212, "y": 1.949131511062806, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Upholsterers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 2.006967028695426, "y": 1.381540513537896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machine Feeders and Offbearers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.5665656501121378, "y": -0.3408140358296199, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Service Technicians and Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.1460597364692063, "y": 1.647598314963139, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furniture Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.7453540126887297, "y": -0.4270094292994817, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Set and Exhibit Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.3370913112158744, "y": -2.2101240344559305, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Choreographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 0.2071361577794199, "y": 0.2719471067841131, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tile and Stone Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.239376988667188, "y": 1.3618987960982238, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Semiconductor Processing Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.3591321741120774, "y": 1.621582500896366, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Milling and Planing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -0.0586105006816206, "y": -0.5411154359535115, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.5617164997234505, "y": -2.195998097173527, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Secondary School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -1.8245011596794236, "y": -2.04550256521286, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 0.73048476896969, "y": 1.0702985181922842, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.300758157626939, "y": 0.3957731906355917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Passenger Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.9081771274176852, "y": -0.2551387083003237, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Registered Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.8791403433824152, "y": -0.3697698747565776, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatric Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.8515657525789402, "y": 0.0410367154226354, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Podiatrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.1327084593718657, "y": 0.4854689916985475, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.1750027166854198, "y": 1.492220708118864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.2968565731359099, "y": 0.0810902616263389, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Network Support Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.4994005675931286, "y": 0.1300774547234769, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Private Household", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.3436469011677024, "y": -1.4997030647542, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dancers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.7336096555311683, "y": 1.0690877883366476, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.7596882588378406, "y": -0.409770603151762, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mining and Geological Engineers, Including Mining Safety Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.9271927119522156, "y": -0.3088473078642967, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pediatricians, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.8178909153404988, "y": -0.1224342010910847, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2979090631898951, "y": -0.015447657450331, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Body and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.018218168909433, "y": 0.180596735769221, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Riggers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.9062866927436664, "y": -2.698655254601816, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Law Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -1.4188227109715064, "y": -1.1917058624793486, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Natural Sciences Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.3042871214464526, "y": -1.1327248980797748, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.290878095326021, "y": -0.4497029891534363, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.4063919049471256, "y": 1.028990704130639, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5933234946090281, "y": -0.3908402485447847, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hosts and Hostesses, Restaurant, Lounge, and Coffee Shop", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.3611622417453817, "y": 1.6323207594989937, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.1764881636946277, "y": -0.0642997585748182, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locker Room, Coatroom, and Dressing Room Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.1420791956188615, "y": 0.8257327289408259, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cartographers and Photogrammetrists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -2.211084482938715, "y": -2.658488563305613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -2.1624961778599108, "y": -1.0402216521849754, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coaches and Scouts", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.241868951622614, "y": -0.4931632511131985, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bioengineers and Biomedical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.823949326841795, "y": 0.6730354555433129, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveyors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.9243229638670988, "y": -1.250563477288417, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Musicians and Singers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.0059177475619447, "y": 0.3743405837221412, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Concierges", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.3104448357507248, "y": -2.52346534123174, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric, Earth, Marine, and Space Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": -0.3329546031290148, "y": 0.1603009623436161, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Optometrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.26618186397543, "y": 1.9766521371103685, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": 0.4730577743534532, "y": 0.8739946726062857, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Distributors and Dispatchers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.6915885036748526, "y": -0.4443285654657969, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Speech-Language Pathologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0455510273001787, "y": -0.1402187606525747, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crossing Guards and Flaggers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2632569270088317, "y": 0.8196898409011085, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Water and Wastewater Treatment Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.8681469156656431, "y": -0.1525808491208962, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coin, Vending, and Amusement Machine Servicers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.7141046559031947, "y": -2.7153684094286428, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.167345290078491, "y": 0.032387304151781, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Embalmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.3794237378925805, "y": -0.1573566141052211, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Repairers and Changers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.9276862719301904, "y": 0.0833021379927335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Assistants, Except Payroll and Timekeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.3021435467775782, "y": 0.188532838887712, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.0831057227114354, "y": -0.1796600645692894, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Power-Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.248092729062218, "y": 0.0242520239459307, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Science Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.6333753946233884, "y": -2.455565680816603, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": -2.158900354808966, "y": -0.4406129244878773, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.309662260928632, "y": -0.6187768198452663, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Residential Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.605246646367264, "y": -0.8349064042361455, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Soil and Plant Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.4923189420113432, "y": -0.7416661452913977, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -2.515496216126499, "y": -1.943067603995008, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm and Home Management Educators", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -1.7061652594245325, "y": -2.2109381179940977, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -1.966928402936567, "y": -2.294972004843148, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Self-Enrichment Teachers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": 0.0330405899918561, "y": 0.0512438918398403, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Highway Maintenance Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.035633531816979, "y": 0.2466860255851118, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera Operators, Television, Video, and Film", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5040729445567841, "y": -0.1581680415803156, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Private Detectives and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.3579826451892696, "y": 1.4229100973811717, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "File Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.8251601318462432, "y": -0.2392939581135727, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Derrick Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.495263346651427, "y": -2.190891682347474, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Middle School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -0.4041972330190037, "y": -0.6363992595659799, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietetic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.2027900279704455, "y": 1.537507692089058, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packaging and Filling Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.8344455712588192, "y": 0.2992421358904156, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cement Masons and Concrete Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6456907883484053, "y": -0.2572895990077236, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2328873233547155, "y": -0.8016755524959888, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Database Administrators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.1525472155047861, "y": -1.2731184966194524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Science Research Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.357833001150752, "y": 1.8237738016349605, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mail Clerks and Mail Machine Operators, Except Postal Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -1.831305637051771, "y": 0.6366989165343029, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.903586148685048, "y": -2.7217821659110744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architecture Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.6829849255522995, "y": -0.7342820259877562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biochemists and Biophysicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.6957585989448415, "y": -0.2182086259531105, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rotary Drill Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.039521600990234, "y": 0.2196007296977279, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Railroad Conductors and Yardmasters", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.6279977976317257, "y": 0.9932934321436616, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.6336178723651176, "y": -1.207490414209174, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletes and Sports Competitors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.5156404877988283, "y": 0.4801907198238464, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stonemasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.784849124549827, "y": -1.0036040766173568, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lodging Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.0645099809696479, "y": -1.5264971897676811, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postmasters and Mail Superintendents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.3490846221331796, "y": 0.2953148963754944, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.7329707418306268, "y": 1.295524472949808, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Cutting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.431197868553953, "y": -0.5378604275355288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Vehicle Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.258792145634027, "y": -2.2379724870991056, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Kindergarten Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -0.3522010999809421, "y": 0.549301362377528, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.1682534016042961, "y": -0.1180196172731057, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Commercial and Industrial Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.8065883038219844, "y": -0.2755515595842337, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.216428145739605, "y": -0.9823255708517404, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3575349868723051, "y": 1.5843609715200302, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool and Die Makers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -0.7167729479827766, "y": -0.3476064197791247, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.708627745846133, "y": -1.9622772853576589, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Curators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 1.3902994349745692, "y": -0.2022904413115994, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.4926879046390026, "y": -0.111840979781209, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Hardware Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.1318236588890729, "y": 1.30587160127319, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paper Goods Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.7393331967145719, "y": -0.6854232065019058, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Announcers and Radio Disc Jockeys", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2832544616050947, "y": 2.146207020472267, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": -0.3397962075450541, "y": 0.3222252108517719, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Non-Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.1294365802493735, "y": -2.1570866838406118, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Teaching Assistants, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 0.8470263264749203, "y": 0.1711504060671389, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Phlebotomists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.2814149167083635, "y": 0.0206205271385765, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Morticians, Undertakers, and Funeral Arrangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.950720864558097, "y": 0.5287835278108917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Except Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.0235324327245148, "y": 1.7341326998833562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Machine Operators, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -1.5492638748310614, "y": -2.653555455724355, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Specialties Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.9272564865352176, "y": -0.0856477182156677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Practitioners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2412894411645986, "y": 0.1672626125933138, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airfield Operations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.3578058544745672, "y": 0.4811646319317064, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.1102215023516521, "y": 0.6257883707166783, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive and Watercraft Service Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.6023929549744818, "y": 1.2595014883779994, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Numerically Controlled Tool Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.91533608373423, "y": -0.1208264475707241, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Personal Financial Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.3397262877396302, "y": -0.4249927969622826, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer User Support Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.9078337914407992, "y": -1.4399081184608706, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Survey Researchers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.4353281092151733, "y": -1.534058658837606, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Astronomers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.6926076287342153, "y": 0.8677636570295552, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers and Laborers, Crop, Nursery, and Greenhouse", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.4414645719719343, "y": -2.712476843145654, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.3181805863619124, "y": -1.8296176923505545, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Archivists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -2.1178775623218278, "y": -1.9694365175029596, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 0.339031438255265, "y": 1.1358774486024177, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Cooking Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.1547620111165768, "y": 0.1109839312257623, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9029821968790444, "y": 1.5342934072836427, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graders and Sorters, Agricultural Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 1.530252107768302, "y": 0.6401704998014467, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Power Reactor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7112473977081836, "y": 0.3398316004054284, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Breeders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.1416328619647181, "y": 0.4579636838742383, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Amusement and Recreation Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2403621511881639, "y": 0.6199375810109201, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Appraisers, Auto Damage", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.4962195828573534, "y": -0.5199360905059254, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.6297127898630417, "y": -0.9436931028724568, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Agricultural Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -2.041821159923535, "y": 0.5382438738833343, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Door-to-Door Sales Workers, News and Street Vendors, and Related Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.1563745313464453, "y": 0.7737825188077933, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Transcriptionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.7657936659810389, "y": -0.2636740035652427, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Mechanics, Installers, and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.8170171917173217, "y": -0.6024695399980646, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest Fire Inspectors and Prevention Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9845043242388511, "y": -0.3342299861207768, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Network Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.825603154659069, "y": -2.6692673775231843, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Family and Consumer Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -1.8581905937163647, "y": -2.1910451044692367, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Clinical and Counseling Psychologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -1.1012183996439375, "y": -0.3771844121009571, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Police and Sheriff's Patrol Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -2.0315493692647943, "y": -2.7156995324893605, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Work Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.9500126070376148, "y": -0.937268163452609, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Firefighters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5133841737460411, "y": -1.266613669556694, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Production Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.494836599819376, "y": -0.8613643430785572, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Health and Safety Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5397937420842506, "y": 0.0566979724526409, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.3499771418862327, "y": 0.1873295933402955, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronic Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.1751133363204995, "y": -1.3317427478601582, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -2.234502859592556, "y": -2.71206037132613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Area, Ethnic, and Cultural Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.0307483544837543, "y": 0.808251520455963, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Travel Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.4170348398794407, "y": -0.641145566103357, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lifeguards, Ski Patrol, and Other Recreational Protective Service Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.2511846601847043, "y": 1.072838156155622, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Switchboard Operators, Including Answering Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.7616809491938787, "y": 1.2815458049399298, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Printing Press Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.829393248096743, "y": 1.0200591972489583, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.2244066537133469, "y": 1.8473197766321812, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Etchers and Engravers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -1.542494518996816, "y": -2.2582165402215613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Middle School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -0.303422390546166, "y": -0.1792793089430829, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Effects Artists and Animators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7750716406799285, "y": -0.0796499827046655, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nursing Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.7434467452373493, "y": 0.8600847892381729, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Legal Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.7795118833857506, "y": -0.1914831441896326, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.490619356336956, "y": -0.8598623519017903, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.007965920450863, "y": 0.1351207080097694, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.510313007451929, "y": 1.1453403734744754, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mixing and Blending Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.9693925638889028, "y": 0.2536811426581061, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Baggage Porters and Bellhops", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.542157981149319, "y": 0.8287584539693339, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Conveyor Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2115773924288305, "y": -0.1949689205505353, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4119883293005517, "y": -0.0717565561143773, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Restaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9637436001218708, "y": -1.135678804078759, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interpreters and Translators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.0213769400310525, "y": -0.160702128925338, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Accountants and Auditors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.8018162111536116, "y": -2.289547205998386, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Secondary School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -1.0025978082411178, "y": 0.1914294205903579, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Janitors and Cleaners, Except Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5878393486504528, "y": 0.0250720896225173, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.3342983652234294, "y": 0.8083802056663606, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Retail Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.4781211160618974, "y": 0.5117012446433264, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.0094680857194339, "y": -1.135738731317477, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation, Benefits, and Job Analysis Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.8340320024989751, "y": 0.8597549989967077, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Court Reporters and Simultaneous Captioners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.017261433832303, "y": -1.0727837265276845, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.0261785206045886, "y": 1.4512845580046112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Weighers, Measurers, Checkers, and Samplers, Recordkeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.491212452903623, "y": 0.1341659761448692, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Funeral Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 2.104487740229535, "y": 0.6929142076474919, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reservation and Transportation Ticket Agents and Travel Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.6551441048891751, "y": 0.4691168111291826, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interviewers, Except Eligibility and Loan", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.24460537513979, "y": 1.441951995835993, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heat Treating Equipment Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.9787249217406624, "y": -2.3296648025973496, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tutors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": 0.7060166036241945, "y": 0.8921993218172863, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laborers and Freight, Stock, and Material Movers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.312553366016794, "y": -0.3014986149619814, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Millwrights", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.0604357096249049, "y": 0.0463473009839235, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reinforcing Iron and Rebar Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.0211954425738956, "y": 0.0661291350012066, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paving, Surfacing, and Tamping Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4046408042333749, "y": -0.1582545709135305, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Musical Instrument Repairers and Tuners", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.7012998338833971, "y": -1.0032607338095747, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Conservation Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.843344597993704, "y": -2.0511059645046275, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": -0.4317398425565781, "y": 0.7215527314103923, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Securities, Commodities, and Financial Services Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2142074841063902, "y": 1.505934010626386, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Appliance Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.8127455370190103, "y": 0.0543049030842833, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Mechanical", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0839652436131624, "y": -0.3597429547020088, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Detectives and Criminal Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0208154562729605, "y": -0.0832282873943979, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Explosives Workers, Ordnance Handling Experts, and Blasters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.085513320787938, "y": 0.4313993308109117, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.4038921072774675, "y": -0.8367397413766838, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Web Developers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.4688778344204163, "y": -0.7506348666287722, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foresters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -2.0652880244734684, "y": -0.4646332281025087, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fashion Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.6097348416943514, "y": -0.0751576168516184, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Housekeeping and Janitorial Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.3022061518374382, "y": 1.3663795789036184, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Knitting and Weaving Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.7769990599516138, "y": 0.4267676706460143, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Layers, Except Carpet, Wood, and Hard Tiles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.5151390195019657, "y": -0.4646598702193824, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.112458745665784, "y": 1.1848275997205315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Customer Service Representatives", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.4577354992478977, "y": -0.9074573269508376, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Engineering Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.2624386301361847, "y": -0.5752793528442666, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agents and Business Managers of Artists, Performers, and Athletes", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.6046577252228963, "y": 0.2383334577410021, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Medicine Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.6050495892236429, "y": 0.5071834580095581, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dredge Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8225645682725966, "y": -1.931461621383752, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rehabilitation Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 1.3277182155559406, "y": 0.3197301682238728, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ushers, Lobby Attendants, and Ticket Takers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4359828423867974, "y": -0.1776207450170219, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinarians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4179236921718974, "y": -0.3960541929608344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Models", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.824249414799414, "y": 0.0187366849896784, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Preparation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.0863152633726389, "y": -2.04762487657263, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lawyers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 1.5945431108364287, "y": -0.3320863466154622, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Security Screeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.7461634106624586, "y": -2.5623510734379, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation and Fitness Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": 0.3378245445497652, "y": -0.6183025972694061, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial and Industrial Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.463389018131386, "y": -0.6483162103146823, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bailiffs", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.1047929570056536, "y": 0.3615147282740324, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tapers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.4288688329142143, "y": 0.7080044452911818, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaners of Vehicles and Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0639994512486199, "y": 0.4529005505024242, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Sanders and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.4099916757187356, "y": 0.4930528103842468, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tank Car, Truck, and Ship Loaders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3748166553039408, "y": 1.709207940535841, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Log Graders and Scalers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.1948068060793332, "y": -2.3324701185851784, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judges, Magistrate Judges, and Magistrates", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": 1.838514124045148, "y": 1.3835226451242812, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Winding, Twisting, and Drawing Out Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.7266747538855354, "y": -0.3060669592651097, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pipelayers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.4850646824522794, "y": -0.187078568510474, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Continuous Mining Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1267081165122968, "y": 0.0420572379360535, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dentists, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.4539405695217607, "y": -0.3450907977795636, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.5458909643294669, "y": 6.160915157569427e-05, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Powerhouse, Substation, and Relay", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 1.0805537759406174, "y": 1.476626772744194, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molding, Coremaking, and Casting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.6949802864896719, "y": 1.3296776418126035, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Numerically Controlled Tool Programmers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.5047140219008556, "y": -0.8979540779133061, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.2651908544659347, "y": -0.0253788328734603, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locksmiths and Safe Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.0549010878820693, "y": 0.6334727488081348, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Compressor and Gas Pumping Station Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -2.063559437558738, "y": -2.7083119038226457, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 1.428029598703468, "y": 1.2771535526275293, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Claims and Policy Processing Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.5091934507281161, "y": 1.647735534668826, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shipping, Receiving, and Inventory Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -0.3095442043451213, "y": -0.1908965105612448, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Equipment Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5594525776157964, "y": 0.2838855007470629, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.1458552216044873, "y": -0.1532671322033863, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Fast Food", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.5530655594833603, "y": 0.3587539915155396, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Terrazzo Workers and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.0428719798894976, "y": -1.0678197242429397, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Funeral Home Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.874106654568681, "y": 0.9456546926998648, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Batchmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.6092431932935146, "y": -0.2393032121913365, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Personal Service Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0275386377194975, "y": 0.7268823878446856, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.3315311988631069, "y": 1.382467207794323, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Multiple Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.5610795632558542, "y": -0.0963584643715331, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physicians, Pathologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0076408288069665, "y": -0.1018042458074484, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Captains, Mates, and Pilots of Water Vessels", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.4745016803652506, "y": -0.1721632324401335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthodontists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8305821343472589, "y": 0.8384954852792355, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Authorizers, Checkers, and Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.8207444276144482, "y": 1.7045740656512904, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.8917267046875949, "y": 0.0928617244549243, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Flight Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.399555731390285, "y": 0.8147872277053464, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motion Picture Projectionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.4012180288777832, "y": -0.257660029030264, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sheet Metal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.7777302446432449, "y": -0.9847511111849584, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Childcare Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.2601007592254225, "y": -0.0631557527655099, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Installation, Maintenance, and Repair Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.989866693707687, "y": -1.5214613251980469, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Education Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5"}}], "size": 8.333333333333332, "fillColor": "rgb(2.0, 118.0, 124.0)", "strokeColor": "rgb(255.0, 255.0, 255.0)", "fillAlpha": 0.3, "strokeAlpha": 0.3, "marker": "M 0.0,-0.5 C 0.13260155,-0.5 0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C 0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 0.5,-0.13260155 0.5,0.0 C 0.5,0.13260155 0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C 0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 0.13260155,0.5 0.0,0.5 C -0.13260155,0.5 -0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 -0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C -0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 -0.5,0.13260155 -0.5,0.0 C -0.5,-0.13260155 -0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 -0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C -0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 -0.13260155,-0.5 0.0,-0.5 Z 0.0,-0.5", "isFilled": true}, {"type": "line", "color": "#034752", "zOrder": 2, "strokeWidth": 2.25, "lineStyle": "-", "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -2.4225245085933538}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": -2.376385387246423}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": -2.330246265899492}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": -2.284107144552561}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": -2.2379680232056307}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": -2.1918289018587003}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": -2.1456897805117694}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": -2.0995506591648385}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": -2.0534115378179076}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": -2.007272416470977}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": -1.9611332951240465}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": -1.9149941737771157}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": -1.8688550524301852}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": -1.8227159310832546}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": -1.7765768097363237}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": -1.730437688389393}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": -1.6842985670424622}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": -1.6381594456955317}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": -1.592020324348601}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": -1.5458812030016702}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": -1.4997420816547393}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": -1.4536029603078087}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": -1.4074638389608778}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": -1.3613247176139471}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": -1.3151855962670165}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": -1.2690464749200858}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": -1.222907353573155}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": -1.1767682322262243}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": -1.1306291108792936}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": -1.0844899895323628}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": -1.038350868185432}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": -0.9922117468385013}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": -0.9460726254915706}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": -0.8999335041446398}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": -0.8537943827977091}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": -0.8076552614507784}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": -0.7615161401038476}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": -0.7153770187569168}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": -0.6692378974099861}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": -0.6230987760630553}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": -0.5769596547161249}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": -0.5308205333691941}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": -0.48468141202226334}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": -0.43854229067533257}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": -0.3924031693284018}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": -0.34626404798147103}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": -0.30012492663454027}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.25398580528760983}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.207846683940679}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.16170756259374824}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.11556844124681746}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.06942931989988668}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.02329019855295591}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": 0.022848922793974866}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": 0.0689880441409053}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": 0.11512716548783608}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": 0.16126628683476685}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": 0.20740540818169761}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": 0.2535445295286284}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": 0.29968365087555915}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": 0.3458227722224899}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": 0.39196189356942035}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": 0.4381010149163511}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": 0.4842401362632819}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": 0.5303792576102128}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": 0.5765183789571435}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": 0.6226575003040743}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": 0.6687966216510047}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": 0.7149357429979355}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": 0.7610748643448663}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": 0.807213985691797}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.8533531070387278}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.8994922283856586}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 0.9456313497325893}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 0.9917704710795201}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 1.0379095924264508}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 1.0840487137733816}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 1.1301878351203123}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 1.1763269564672432}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 1.2224660778141732}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 1.268605199161104}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 1.3147443205080347}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 1.3608834418549656}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 1.4070225632018962}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 1.453161684548827}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 1.499300805895758}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 1.5454399272426886}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 1.5915790485896195}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 1.6377181699365502}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 1.683857291283481}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 1.7299964126304117}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 1.7761355339773426}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 1.8222746553242732}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 1.8684137766712035}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 1.914552898018134}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 1.960692019365065}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 2.006831140711996}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 2.0529702620589267}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 2.0991093834058576}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 2.145248504752788}]}, {"type": "polygon", "color": "rgb(3.0, 71.0, 82.0)", "alpha": 0.15, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -2.2179434638980733}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -2.619738511518555}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": -2.5699574991159255}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": -2.520263854338067}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": -2.471310584484527}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": -2.422614119086584}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": -2.37391765368864}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": -2.3252211882906964}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": -2.2765247228927525}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": -2.227828257494809}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": -2.178373882617594}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": -2.128866035758177}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": -2.079347273185229}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": -2.0298285106122824}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": -1.9801287514556258}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": -1.9299793148281945}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": -1.8804773338765486}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": -1.8306362970250032}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": -1.780790410182209}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": -1.7309445233394143}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": -1.6815411240717606}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": -1.632339697088615}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": -1.5831382701054695}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": -1.533919950182881}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": -1.4847244402221569}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": -1.4355339891560328}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": -1.3856899205158564}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": -1.3363383423773967}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": -1.2871764602163458}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": -1.2377945115214122}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": -1.1887669762155586}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": -1.1390160339715587}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": -1.0908608775837034}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": -1.0414749943308172}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": -0.9914749605281132}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": -0.9419687913115163}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": -0.8936911779663166}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": -0.8455463634000218}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": -0.7964805370457}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": -0.748147887594405}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": -0.6977130460879136}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": -0.649617495166503}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": -0.6020017740717913}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": -0.5531168875093846}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": -0.5044387336117425}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": -0.4577662414537216}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": -0.4099641043929459}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": -0.3621553790412702}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.31532596131065715}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.2673170379718061}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.22035418121812866}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.1737769203072941}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.12749307033316107}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.08039067464536079}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": -0.034345426680716135}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": 0.01229775712387628}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": 0.057327991291356545}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": 0.10360637069275655}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": 0.1493985659155238}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": 0.1940225602299417}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": 0.2383771845253561}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": 0.2826939666125195}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": 0.32744538373710874}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": 0.37196782252890576}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": 0.41707209333683654}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": 0.4611311903364683}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": 0.5043723617262558}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": 0.5475237723247883}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": 0.5914677106123185}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": 0.6333067276626507}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": 0.6765778053274638}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": 0.7198048779467842}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.7626034005913878}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.805764814671375}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 0.8502662183000322}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 0.893739858142613}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 0.9369907913015174}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 0.9813467445557471}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 1.0257026978099766}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 1.0700076932182045}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 1.1138647179441934}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 1.1567230349700355}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 1.199616220351445}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 1.2425299274388553}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 1.2865929703103904}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 1.3308546482703647}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 1.3723648062607154}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 1.4140399160251902}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 1.4573918264017416}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 1.500756871731752}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 1.5428881187857615}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 1.585534140839182}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 1.6283913645756383}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 1.671248588312094}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 1.714105812048549}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 1.7564849553074149}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 1.7982659088666628}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 1.8413306719821947}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 1.883350041848916}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 1.9245850548858994}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 1.9670339350514345}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 2.323787870086105}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 2.323787870086105}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 2.2744678306523314}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 2.2257423341592153}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 2.1763760222690975}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 2.1266721541699147}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 2.076968286070732}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 2.027264417971549}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 1.9775548291285847}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 1.9290543946903678}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 1.8805999668215911}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 1.8318130078616002}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 1.7816996643137488}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 1.7315531724320155}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 1.681383605728479}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 1.6318562089494169}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 1.5820520877013862}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 1.531433174952975}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 1.4820091519898217}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 1.4331422229417188}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 1.3835969239393155}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 1.3347634402159438}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 1.2859069233644478}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 1.2370322269998675}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 1.1871369501080535}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 1.1371986336179274}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 1.0888743212000371}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 1.040548504730117}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.9923048571189723}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.943901383946366}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": 0.8946918321686275}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": 0.8451059273621132}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": 0.7950123765729545}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": 0.7451925056921727}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": 0.6968972581149092}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": 0.6467064418223831}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": 0.5993368973719275}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": 0.5499500037378876}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": 0.5006205606724431}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": 0.45380946032655195}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": 0.4047330784883735}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": 0.3563532262437179}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": 0.30850908409044303}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": 0.2603919203672301}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": 0.21426609039284922}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": 0.16805560170618114}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": 0.12239573230615321}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": 0.07674771554026313}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": 0.031137961839615508}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.014437639796707482}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.05975639869338287}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.10507572736184392}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.1501648653871822}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.19389542344873512}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": -0.2383210225891784}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": -0.2824080518121537}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": -0.3275561112219392}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": -0.3709524202519349}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": -0.4153924090064005}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": -0.4600556832645751}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": -0.5040545316449375}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": -0.5476067815167519}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": -0.5918490388853354}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": -0.6354505382120331}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": -0.6789361190317825}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": -0.7228464075044851}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": -0.7658743136979731}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": -0.8098999889980839}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": -0.8528629371466541}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": -0.8963371690134105}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": -0.9402902840422499}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": -0.9845479809095048}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": -1.026777656900319}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": -1.0685905801750055}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": -1.1101717970473641}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": -1.1522698365654338}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": -1.194379151079818}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": -1.2385731275349203}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": -1.2807236414310335}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": -1.3229789168085344}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": -1.366683186984256}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": -1.4104273779249337}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": -1.453170565045888}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": -1.4952033058637295}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": -1.5390244102953101}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": -1.5828455147268907}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": -1.6266666191584715}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": -1.6699186139171922}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": -1.7120660148527742}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": -1.754213415788356}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": -1.7963608167239382}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": -1.8385082176595204}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": -1.8806556185951024}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": -1.9228030195306844}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": -1.9649504204662667}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": -2.007101250347281}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": -2.0492666560468757}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": -2.0914320617464703}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": -2.1335974674460654}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": -2.175769606733674}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -2.2179434638980733}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -2.2179434638980733}], "closed": true}, {"type": "text", "color": "grey", "zOrder": 3, "text": "R\u00b2=0.50", "x": 0.08, "y": 0.87, "ha": "left", "va": "baseline", "rotation": 0.0, "rotationMode": "default", "background": true, "fontSizeScaling": 1, "textCoords": "paper-normalized"}], "hud": [], "originalDataAspectRatio": 0.7451612903225805, "additionalLegendItems": []} {"downloadButtonPosition": "none"}

{"title": "Comparison of automatability measures across occupations", "xAxis": {"label": "Autor et al.", "lim": [-3.4465900025433047, 3.0697599100120265], "scaleType": "linear"}, "yAxis": {"label": "Brynjolfsson et al.", "lim": [-6.605960182364668, 4.540423397112864], "scaleType": "linear"}, "showFrame": true, "objects": [{"type": "scatter", "alpha": 0.3, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -1.3879757172393794, "y": 0.4769711051991231, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hydrologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.8738669794255672, "y": 0.6002959916387471, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Inspectors, Testers, Sorters, Samplers, and Weighers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1666628024119154, "y": 0.3503508935278656, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fine Artists, Including Painters, Sculptors, and Illustrators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.7804981301768894, "y": 2.048419428893597, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.8795861299816146, "y": -1.4948196173603618, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Construction Trades and Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.7687729425831287, "y": 0.3169670181672088, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Interviewers and Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.6629131000636508, "y": 0.419478600047538, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marketing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.12378193496383, "y": 0.2999575131849606, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.9277204053432249, "y": -0.7734924221872527, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.398356520939802, "y": -0.708077925478146, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manufactured Building and Mobile Home Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.9061688817454226, "y": 0.205938862226246, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Child, Family, and School Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.229972685882886, "y": 1.073130196872775, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.7812259575544531, "y": -0.1081433289367911, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chief Executives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.0039331134124508, "y": -0.5247438767273171, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Pipelayers, Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.859323689241689, "y": -0.980106765993274, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Change Persons and Booth Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.557483831077505, "y": 0.1786043698706594, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1412240429044082, "y": 0.6582027003599631, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graphic Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.1029408398799553, "y": -0.8472891367713816, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Opticians, Dispensing", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.4607253338358603, "y": -0.1365285670212466, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "General and Operations Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.207129400606792, "y": -0.3806811504820563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.3411191413364209, "y": -0.3996659364701214, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Pilots", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.7633323806856949, "y": -0.6488380220454107, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Subway and Streetcar Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7317018320835897, "y": -0.6694539092520878, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security Guards", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2438311053934494, "y": -1.1174411689034, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crane and Tower Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.1090292074789271, "y": -0.0799622025006361, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sailors and Marine Oilers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.1597849936475773, "y": 0.2481914609519789, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locomotive Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.4002584839064506, "y": -1.6260864011944445, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -0.5337725316665024, "y": -2.765864778809956, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brickmasons and Blockmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.8"}}, {"x": 0.2162911735904329, "y": 0.2022427040678404, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.2775952412045133, "y": -2.182758224845109, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 1.4105844317226746, "y": 1.333120023673216, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool Grinders, Filers, and Sharpeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.996340114497679, "y": 0.1800622957904606, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Healthcare Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.0353559581581828, "y": -0.2577136352740637, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Preschool Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2406121254605465, "y": -0.9583212333304538, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Painters, Paperhangers, Plasterers, and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.8204565641037875, "y": -0.3320974016808825, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Sorters, Processors, and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.067303770014071, "y": 0.833862730967702, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Procurement Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.2588012909362202, "y": -1.0930483352659708, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roustabouts, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.2291720398343169, "y": 0.6312327162117289, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hotel, Motel, and Resort Desk Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.2592578673812185, "y": 0.7218860270045234, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.272530239671472, "y": 0.3125720022969839, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.9906848123176468, "y": 0.4171294499441015, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Community Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.6730993274418786, "y": -0.2707460970648521, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bicycle Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.7660536591214124, "y": -0.8106360681489818, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interior Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.9199418254306408, "y": -1.105314726853424, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Business Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.1984900413932157, "y": 0.1693295520170917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painting, Coating, and Decorating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.9651727034022022, "y": 0.6407266407555143, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.8678163958494096, "y": 0.8464709504403307, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling and Sports Book Writers and Runners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 1.4775046840042845, "y": -0.3328460314787462, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Bleaching and Dyeing Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4376365754218905, "y": 0.0910687710052158, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Museum Technicians and Conservators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0188198127948211, "y": -0.2977921710627904, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemistry Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.4865439553846576, "y": -0.0175960455513431, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Forming Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Synthetic and Glass Fibers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.3192931547383277, "y": -0.5676158410115849, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Production and Operating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.0949537063416281, "y": 0.1675086582753459, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Respiratory Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4480116316352364, "y": -0.3240096810961091, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Civil Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.458285251111881, "y": -3.857950669159469, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-3.9"}}, {"x": 0.8988100277128837, "y": -1.2386736889181775, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shampooers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.6273322601296695, "y": -0.4330349137248466, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Door Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.2097198306705703, "y": 1.4866815098688857, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Billing and Posting Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.3180282187359726, "y": 1.219639415880222, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Demonstrators and Product Promoters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.8718361075941772, "y": 1.953450421565292, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education and Childcare Administrators, Preschool and Daycare", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.4527867458282585, "y": -0.5686706779409081, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpet Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.1743689098151666, "y": -1.524978657439433, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Builders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -1.35719352361029, "y": -0.424372536626843, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Correctional Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.3878560374962543, "y": -0.9066167263398508, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.6176510641006632, "y": -3.2681575770793327, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Slaughterers and Meat Packers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-3.3"}}, {"x": -0.8794611907585571, "y": 0.6744854598459931, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer and Information Systems Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0028291672137524, "y": -0.1056779169868726, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stationary Engineers and Boiler Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.9905780385848506, "y": 0.6363179373138383, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7406839953693914, "y": -1.400150208270122, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tree Trimmers and Pruners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.9380037429031493, "y": -0.3703558267374037, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judicial Law Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.8778901879268389, "y": 0.4961679533919128, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meter Readers, Utilities", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.146188611016774, "y": 0.263039459123326, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dishwashers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.8317415685275095, "y": -1.373198730883059, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Glass Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.1745555230932532, "y": 0.0485173123152232, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pesticide Handlers, Sprayers, and Applicators, Vegetation", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -2.651248398474005, "y": -1.002740545568998, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forestry and Conservation Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.6647895434714719, "y": 0.0487628841658836, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveying and Mapping Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.0558322850299701, "y": -0.9083421078678836, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Glaziers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.4950131724181174, "y": -0.4608690967131597, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Craft Artists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.26970421220172, "y": 1.3858970264800332, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Clergy", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.036151212776815, "y": -1.335468548817916, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "History Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.7819185045085033, "y": 0.0336624170164735, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Air Traffic Controllers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.6262646108388754, "y": -0.3486280900212931, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pest Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6170505642570706, "y": -1.4000565440339932, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.5201602731015502, "y": 0.3531884350562047, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -2.1096742408509983, "y": 1.1196180672263345, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.6366551142657275, "y": 1.6045756205609396, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Community Health Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 1.5470181213201686, "y": -1.5412712416516698, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meat, Poultry, and Fish Cutters and Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.9388818956190284, "y": -0.0770571011585671, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floral Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.8801617726657183, "y": -0.6270792796452572, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematical Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.2491564480854882, "y": -0.410511295121719, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Layout Workers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.136975723495231, "y": -0.6803717381184463, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Production Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.6790061859797019, "y": -1.5144996708081906, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refractory Materials Repairers, Except Brickmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.7819356456226125, "y": -0.3033251024313882, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paralegals and Legal Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5563316338766712, "y": 0.0853914506299896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Solar Photovoltaic Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.5764248510627038, "y": -2.606400116764571, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hoist and Winch Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": 0.4951107921040945, "y": -0.670881201359333, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Servers, Nonrestaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.096748042827857, "y": 1.7058716655456987, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foundry Mold and Coremakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.3169447298842093, "y": -0.5893222392034155, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Licensed Practical and Licensed Vocational Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.8427647104734115, "y": -0.1459443009024977, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.7979287796407275, "y": -0.7117029875683633, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.4174885121922616, "y": -0.0869934074501729, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding, Forming, Pressing, and Compacting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.6001567912318234, "y": -1.1378733716665386, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Surveillance Officers and Gambling Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.332257858369244, "y": 0.0476917975543104, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.8628367773058664, "y": 0.9106439753600808, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Safety Telecommunicators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.9253881581355786, "y": -0.2900542661936051, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adult Basic Education, Adult Secondary Education, and English as a Second Language Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.115542120743649, "y": 0.4258678725952405, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security and Fire Alarm Systems Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.8478630448741451, "y": -0.0602916163669964, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plating Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.6955245225744036, "y": -0.2079507327110573, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Police and Detectives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.107337904574303, "y": 0.1277806395989128, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Emergency Management Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.459045469791104, "y": 0.0565541041296804, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.7923693052017245, "y": -0.2733057164882733, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heating, Air Conditioning, and Refrigeration Mechanics and Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5133653075622094, "y": -1.5440548297799648, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hairdressers, Hairstylists, and Cosmetologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -1.899884285005504, "y": -0.648599411731927, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engineering Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.9096847130366288, "y": -0.4849107164164453, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Woodworking Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Except Sawing", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.9450373452170504, "y": -0.3650400064853785, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nursing Instructors and Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.260815125874153, "y": 0.3876622493625464, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Diagnostic Medical Sonographers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.6058133203748001, "y": -0.2998776208323292, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Outdoor Power Equipment and Other Small Engine Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.1802755546079249, "y": -1.4074002965819197, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer, Automated Teller, and Office Machine Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 2.308011656461644, "y": -0.071516449648114, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "2.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.7917310476663457, "y": 0.8324323844194813, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.8311679997784562, "y": 1.6901721695314436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.1859608627599854, "y": 2.035238586794311, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fabric and Apparel Patternmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.6235878556784445, "y": -1.3933104091993436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Yard Engineers, Dinkey Operators, and Hostlers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.6608103499457694, "y": 0.8389454911266861, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.1576690232763411, "y": -0.5887028291901215, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Zoologists and Wildlife Biologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2758731672301599, "y": -1.3645343685371931, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sound Engineering Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.3103914296664506, "y": -0.8758365805701696, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chefs and Head Cooks", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1052002908318708, "y": -1.830437366829721, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorcycle Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 1.3456587931753214, "y": 0.1922354413325714, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiation Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1662019129923107, "y": 1.4520432305061122, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.4470366621020035, "y": 0.2093152269016492, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronic Equipment Installers and Repairers, Motor Vehicles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.6354002347736443, "y": -1.2583915394891998, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Arbitrators, Mediators, and Conciliators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -2.330784055904513, "y": 0.0465348407687864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Educational, Guidance, and Career Counselors and Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.793744986464031, "y": -1.9013659784018493, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Home Appliance Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 0.49820798587486, "y": 0.942263407131359, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographic Process Workers and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.8579685140459804, "y": -1.7566237233405664, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packers and Packagers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 1.0183809588051669, "y": 0.7906390872100985, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutters and Trimmers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.2795218700990303, "y": -2.482345264553829, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": 0.2623391526162582, "y": 0.4700939667744939, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statistical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.0628692390837011, "y": -0.5909031203273529, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscaping and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.3089559447421135, "y": 0.9504434826197669, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.360155271736588, "y": 0.077417550454689, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding, Lapping, Polishing, and Buffing Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5396079321446071, "y": -1.530369973052269, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Examiners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.9669829948160152, "y": -0.6652287100540738, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rolling Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.5710404730541805, "y": -0.7550767782799744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Equipment Installers and Repairers, Except Line Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.184724227600342, "y": -0.9529116510581996, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radio, Cellular, and Tower Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.1645226637058472, "y": -0.0006211840577027, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe and Leather Workers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.7711931576309774, "y": 0.7552710693780313, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Assistants and Laboratory Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.3926167440556287, "y": -0.4945641340873837, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architects, Except Landscape and Naval", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.6267937654755713, "y": 1.199875613205241, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Clerks, General", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.1586119749940411, "y": 0.3025813391445957, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.504803091190655, "y": 0.4282894682414789, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.7281594872419926, "y": 0.920263587433434, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Jewelers and Precious Stone and Metal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.4459361806357918, "y": -0.1382404829151258, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molders, Shapers, and Casters, Except Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.008514111373503, "y": -0.8992369770126294, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Physiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -2.5673369967257145, "y": 0.0180695866016999, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Urban and Regional Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 1.4838150007725963, "y": -0.2677274029791819, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coil Winders, Tapers, and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.3646337058614783, "y": -2.4998214877839344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pile Driver Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": 0.413652326235589, "y": -0.130748498533391, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineering and Operations Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.7115386799945627, "y": -1.3589139688073593, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cost Estimators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.5943329550635068, "y": -0.8814799124092804, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Septic Tank Servicers and Sewer Pipe Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.5199121450668008, "y": -0.8876009057115901, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Claims Adjusters, Examiners, and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.5305181232195075, "y": 1.9632473948536675, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tellers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.4865023643391553, "y": 1.113452396250364, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising and Promotions Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.9498596825735608, "y": 0.6074270576996895, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Kindergarten through Secondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.349270017361749, "y": -0.6496406823092399, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.2870916936583988, "y": -3.239146610560545, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logging Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-3.2"}}, {"x": 0.3979925945108996, "y": 0.7325615835266756, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Microbiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.9289446585442722, "y": 0.732583683544524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation, Storage, and Distribution Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.261215927667404, "y": 0.6116079712114408, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Labor Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.2959256040461369, "y": -0.5669025823733916, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.2173345606272563, "y": -0.5037609568318515, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Midwives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3419903257028654, "y": -0.8030251680707169, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.2322879970452644, "y": -0.0479054023555202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Costume Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.0367234606969555, "y": 1.0299127953254137, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.096593567122127, "y": -1.5725710024214563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Iron and Steel Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -2.2426924043436363, "y": -0.6731736808843648, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art, Drama, and Music Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.0893882922911258, "y": -0.3852236376507577, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Writers and Authors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.1027259585525155, "y": -1.5166172830064606, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.255497013586391, "y": -1.679307339937229, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Service Unit Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.1435896306415737, "y": -0.4217739011893406, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airline Pilots, Copilots, and Flight Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.5207884919746754, "y": 0.925017044623035, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.0421236179435285, "y": 0.0805218571909154, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Scientists and Specialists, Including Health", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.855060775139609, "y": 1.2847538806593113, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Carriers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.7172717451093302, "y": 1.167563613101772, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Word Processors and Typists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.427905954618115, "y": -0.7613693721083433, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elevator and Escalator Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.3883263612610775, "y": -1.123871549793198, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.1326045094331685, "y": -1.2795150344485782, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscape Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.3331083471176046, "y": -0.541386277888882, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transit and Railroad Police", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.5689573020554451, "y": -2.2253652376962334, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 0.3988620055019044, "y": 0.048160906996637, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Labor Contractors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.878637112989117, "y": 0.0235207678895383, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Eligibility Interviewers, Government Programs", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.716245025559664, "y": 0.6521297039035562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Metal-Refining Furnace Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.1153503650067896, "y": -1.3882728662766548, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Scientists, Except Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.7545121597708432, "y": 0.3416126757173328, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engine and Other Machine Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2055050168889151, "y": -1.4454581511399236, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Umpires, Referees, and Other Sports Officials", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.8269838306805912, "y": -0.699764055359394, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Short Order", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.3355795054575677, "y": 0.7027700971535095, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pourers and Casters, Metal", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.6896623194547988, "y": 0.0872342581074651, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tailors, Dressmakers, and Custom Sewers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9269442287740294, "y": 0.4849608325677809, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drilling and Boring Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2503349809478545, "y": -0.331351698547896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Separating, Filtering, Clarifying, Precipitating, and Still Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.805608689891823, "y": 0.1648031845519616, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forging Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.0452772118071618, "y": 0.6739556563246988, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operations Research Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.7843564994601844, "y": 0.1954850653320669, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fundraisers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.0931249019367593, "y": 0.7202554018402112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding and Polishing Workers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.3974472910211182, "y": 0.0044856812596642, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lathe and Turning Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.275127175318862, "y": -1.0894555718600818, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Scientists and Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.1035045259606848, "y": -1.1898695379317936, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Philosophy and Religion Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.6177573881765728, "y": 0.2528094822294696, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Driver/Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.860101367472801, "y": 0.8905010109620344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.7016666738235096, "y": -0.8992967053555281, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Firefighting and Prevention Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5952167662256497, "y": -2.4200715923254066, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail-Track Laying and Maintenance Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.4"}}, {"x": 1.4106782716026849, "y": 0.5111418585711418, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correspondence Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3718634252361831, "y": 0.7778868355022738, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.5514297625619868, "y": -0.6590859606791315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marine Engineers and Naval Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.9979158190254164, "y": 0.6868050171478273, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.168257496434765, "y": -0.957941786086224, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Control and Valve Installers and Repairers, Except Mechanical Door", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -2.3887831446158225, "y": -2.123428930036231, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": -0.0183989055691776, "y": -1.0122401209173617, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.8167005964033244, "y": 0.8507096196187764, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiologic Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.3756481511626501, "y": 0.4085047242978426, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Avionics Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.601366659204723, "y": 0.222469496995226, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ambulance Drivers and Attendants, Except Emergency Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.0651753538796804, "y": -0.9720797077706832, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welders, Cutters, Solderers, and Brazers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.8997798001241091, "y": -2.5127829883897066, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Historians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": 1.2864419155115894, "y": -0.2137227015874454, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adhesive Bonding Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.8575731168305705, "y": -1.4519476870019958, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laundry and Dry-Cleaning Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.3439734260570267, "y": 1.0869065606371413, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.043337764227231, "y": 0.1271541726875888, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -2.1191467593298605, "y": -0.9008067260488312, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "English Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1456937718268784, "y": 1.2416819039273648, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Underwriters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.302936056976872, "y": 1.2477215263170165, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -2.2678319184750424, "y": -0.7183192364743056, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.961096082230804, "y": -0.3330970591338541, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Waiters and Waitresses", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.3626576043666109, "y": 0.4660297841450201, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Order Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3409863554482197, "y": -1.6501848608570315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paperhangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 1.543237498245881, "y": -1.70424864628896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pressers, Textile, Garment, and Related Materials", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.7579204616488344, "y": 1.1407331727701755, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronics Engineers, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.9822806035794333, "y": 1.3920509573649056, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Prepress Technicians and Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.4989676451123788, "y": 2.887296204129436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brokerage Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.9"}}, {"x": -2.00606003700463, "y": -0.9496435006455324, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foreign Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.0654027329048016, "y": -0.1492461384500763, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fence Erectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5333638512536465, "y": -1.4356044869704454, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Divers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.5597607197091468, "y": 4.033769598045703, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "4.0"}}, {"x": -0.1702958363252753, "y": -0.8924247605088044, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chiropractors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.275963820611964, "y": 0.3927168691116599, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest and Conservation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.6229718502009335, "y": -1.4434920505779998, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drywall and Ceiling Tile Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.5084109052552163, "y": 0.1857327806279873, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Butchers and Meat Cutters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.5791583819927179, "y": -1.8547812316945165, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance Workers, Machinery", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -1.7576292009047862, "y": -0.2024781563353515, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial-Organizational Psychologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.873748106549436, "y": -0.1908269968058613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Instructional Coordinators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.6283372102046054, "y": 0.1739162687813239, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Metal Fabricators and Fitters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.1113836504282495, "y": 0.5973853750438208, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bill and Account Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.3625311479896964, "y": 1.935829353510797, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Couriers and Messengers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 0.8611705519922842, "y": -0.3486345172192941, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bridge and Lock Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2038056414528196, "y": -0.5859252337658044, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cabinetmakers and Bench Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.5173509320945054, "y": 0.4029151006641654, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surgical Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2121641423044445, "y": -0.5096744163293003, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crushing, Grinding, and Polishing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.3808401820098453, "y": -0.4262826465138501, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Preschool", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.4287701686383378, "y": -0.3227364294120688, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Signal and Track Switch Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.6814896517281743, "y": -1.1119293186062733, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropology and Archeology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.173473636669783, "y": -0.3791760326548031, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietitians and Nutritionists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.3942567266559647, "y": 0.0193812085527256, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.4391685872432179, "y": -1.2388593463137647, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fallers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.4476966830581191, "y": 0.2656904265618343, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welding, Soldering, and Brazing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2733249177323729, "y": 0.58538149947842, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaning, Washing, and Metal Pickling Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.5249279594054749, "y": -1.8227308484973528, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Car Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 0.7206932847569244, "y": -0.3023681865304483, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furnace, Kiln, Oven, Drier, and Kettle Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.5596459401413999, "y": 0.0680112305248244, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audio and Video Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.842045453577487, "y": 0.988489431764331, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Examiners and Collectors, and Revenue Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.3938952542378198, "y": -0.3878034023646444, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.517268926304522, "y": -0.0953765487186844, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correctional Officers and Jailers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.0319613075533194, "y": -3.2902860518140318, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plasterers and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-3.3"}}, {"x": -1.7285894926632013, "y": 0.1736460699051581, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geoscientists, Except Hydrologists and Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.564049581303414, "y": -0.0072194597874134, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.6736007874983986, "y": -0.1175872801080984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance and Repair Workers, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.979860085336681, "y": 0.6104065328227839, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.3561213822478264, "y": 0.406597419391185, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actuaries", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.0744809961151065, "y": 0.7782636965635146, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Brokers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.9527003673193264, "y": 0.1120566489395345, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.7477243545871888, "y": -0.2535363002750591, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Purchasing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6000761800414834, "y": -0.8094955932785153, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Genetic Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.4258112577101307, "y": -1.6928847687623017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Drawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.941582977348845, "y": -0.3733243137580128, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physician Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.9175406008240258, "y": 1.325368448233277, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Court, Municipal, and License Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 1.4241136552326663, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telephone Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.2105395982479372, "y": -0.806943520957648, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting and Slicing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 2.113268072214425, "y": 0.6142528615638354, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Dealers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1356029499591191, "y": -1.2134840100273865, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Institution and Cafeteria", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.3487615050458227, "y": -0.6581262347955837, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Probation Officers and Correctional Treatment Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.270680593235209, "y": 0.6750073933185257, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.3911799612513187, "y": 0.3395530444563152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Landscaping, Lawn Service, and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.5494797868144166, "y": -1.9691078163535976, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wind Turbine Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 0.472712350022055, "y": -0.7740312626582152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.7761718702554996, "y": -0.3533880863524574, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refuse and Recyclable Material Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.7769366037314608, "y": 1.3045584914983157, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.5194640396300716, "y": -0.7911775683602268, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manicurists and Pedicurists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.3842542364284055, "y": -0.7778964338878661, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera and Photographic Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -2.092558237933194, "y": 0.3424564322274069, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.7413174128753748, "y": -0.6421929243775794, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geography Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.5816629934821564, "y": -1.2561143016168197, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Skincare Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.1071197858238884, "y": -0.4426846778855715, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.2758565602456502, "y": -0.1329604229975952, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4599543797063599, "y": -0.5821981749511812, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Pump System Operators, Refinery Operators, and Gaugers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.0582176742081917, "y": 0.1226475310821288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Boilermakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.764086569407202, "y": -0.5570690855330798, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.6043578751229657, "y": -0.8696080514268233, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Budget Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.2744437195026044, "y": -0.4583627211724683, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Brickmasons, Blockmasons, Stonemasons, and Tile and Marble Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.1623899316545318, "y": -1.682162856725102, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Truck and Tractor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.8146553091301973, "y": 0.1041769109471902, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction and Building Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.7877720885971908, "y": -0.4081572799599763, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting, Punching, and Press Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.5678870145431338, "y": -0.2676466061329841, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.8333851587986286, "y": -0.4887582129137088, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric and Space Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.917086462550661, "y": -0.7215919144416044, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.870607815023757, "y": -1.754905409510624, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 1.4299104896821464, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Directors, Religious Activities and Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-3.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.9100470331741998, "y": -1.3435325628962091, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthotists and Prosthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.549582894022315, "y": 1.0643804210424168, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.6563552980344222, "y": 0.1633065623283303, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Farming, Fishing, and Forestry Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.3922974939376122, "y": 0.7543694400501751, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Structure, Surfaces, Rigging, and Systems Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.1956972048805025, "y": -0.6213560547555679, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pump Operators, Except Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.7188723580944468, "y": 1.141070950715691, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Receptionists and Information Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.6559732566198974, "y": 0.2575980294094475, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compliance Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.9731805213137112, "y": -0.7378907969335814, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.4115537158778558, "y": -0.9548260868370428, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Barbers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.2762382986028072, "y": -0.0439787707957752, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Anesthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.5306687829631038, "y": -1.3159743682425329, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Machinery Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.0169977620024206, "y": 0.7727379072118687, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Technical Writers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.894622309351864, "y": -2.8425497728577573, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.8"}}, {"x": -1.2155165824501373, "y": -0.6500466327611386, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meeting, Convention, and Event Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0464369491938291, "y": 1.9270719428832304, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hazardous Materials Removal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 1.7218942602992406, "y": -0.4646430780448083, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.6023736472329735, "y": -0.2596774867107814, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Laborers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.0038309389872154, "y": -0.1876725982808235, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Installers and Repairers, Transportation Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.1514179239536149, "y": 0.3893829595732726, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.438563742232027, "y": 0.2700983789716736, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Merchandise Displayers and Window Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.7211382988891573, "y": 0.1288750653068821, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marriage and Family Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.6741424531705897, "y": 0.1022139816720098, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.0400367106015421, "y": 2.238785240845187, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Desktop Publishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.2"}}, {"x": -1.5306538276477482, "y": -1.478817302322723, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Management Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.0482384515239916, "y": -1.4664689006523766, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electric Motor, Power Tool, and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.2959987074785453, "y": -1.1385825646807262, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mobile Heavy Equipment Mechanics, Except Engines", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.3111711767115684, "y": -1.0127346722703685, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Trainers and Group Fitness Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5097164017692816, "y": -0.5736602723499991, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.065549841268239, "y": -1.991214186171452, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Makeup Artists, Theatrical and Performance", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 0.8260723631505726, "y": 1.914543345687984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dispatchers, Except Police, Fire, and Ambulance", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 1.1464368897532982, "y": -0.3077223750222043, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Print Binding and Finishing Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.7699093916046311, "y": 1.045199315415118, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Music Directors and Composers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.0236777409365872, "y": 0.5309933930304397, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2273720488599744, "y": -0.0467035308403053, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.2612872430164695, "y": 0.8815705290018319, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.0402418835199054, "y": -6.099306383297507, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Massage Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-6.1"}}, {"x": -0.4516868248810886, "y": -0.6141383665649158, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletic Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.1054502388754892, "y": 0.2929915961155637, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.314238342840608, "y": -0.1017334947263774, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bartenders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.0876278336010032, "y": -0.3124252987539309, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telemarketers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.6774524291926896, "y": 1.740471976712923, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Data Entry Keyers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -1.2124474289143454, "y": -0.6952839737075438, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0277980723573438, "y": 0.9340011971279278, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.2548064624972122, "y": -0.5478912458393774, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fire Inspectors and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.6368033312319524, "y": -1.0495015689803706, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooling and Freezing Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.0184082093377855, "y": 0.5772438557982723, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dining Room and Cafeteria Attendants and Bartender Helpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.4357097431058516, "y": 0.7049238987092119, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.045496651541581, "y": 0.6440792517419299, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health and Safety Engineers, Except Mining Safety Engineers and Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.4025694848468618, "y": 0.1981552476688287, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Floor, Ceiling, and Wall", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.6841921599322112, "y": 0.7289172930425262, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2695348951313973, "y": 0.9791513542167968, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Assistants, Clerical", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.0422660961428759, "y": -0.882117452736912, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Watch and Clock Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.3540124704030162, "y": -0.1066084291790563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forensic Science Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5777200704469947, "y": 0.2463667886025458, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hearing Aid Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7048764560791582, "y": -3.654191947518135, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rock Splitters, Quarry", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-3.7"}}, {"x": -1.1637615899672478, "y": -0.6156908901333077, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Property, Real Estate, and Community Association Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.8338399312873329, "y": -0.1897281079733586, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.4282417280018922, "y": -0.0394014481266701, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 2.3664798768120976, "y": 0.3580082149550557, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Proofreaders and Copy Markers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.6156410841929586, "y": -0.7250652401027713, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.5041814617212416, "y": 0.1678572202068118, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.2747895742280462, "y": 0.3402197263235392, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Human Service Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4239930589522561, "y": -0.4840445046813735, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Film and Video Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2798001700417336, "y": 1.0793475339489185, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cargo and Freight Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.574501587778538, "y": 0.3681597210393484, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical and Health Services Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.7290811173566742, "y": -0.6964697646613227, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Communications Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.0455712529, "y": 0.8133072814626602, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Producers and Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.1842021869879643, "y": 2.1190710775497847, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Counter and Rental Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": 2.5187493896221773, "y": 2.468799971836489, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Cage Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.5"}}, {"x": 1.0276743659096343, "y": 0.1044951625433873, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Title Examiners, Abstractors, and Searchers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.863599975464569, "y": 0.3896784596578806, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fish and Game Wardens", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.8802520756486636, "y": -0.6633514841066912, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers, Farm, Ranch, and Aquacultural Animals", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2048261572016251, "y": -0.7805817361525428, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.4210110569352954, "y": -1.7440362542334682, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painters, Construction and Maintenance", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.0932713927568725, "y": -0.8620608766986597, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ship Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.8235694729289396, "y": 0.0343191261991832, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.17353522050073, "y": -1.2252769283440597, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.0796191480762997, "y": -0.2546579889216007, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Light Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.6529288275583993, "y": -0.5221598174750427, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Traffic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3864681686870737, "y": -1.0729216234524257, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electro-Mechanical and Mechatronics Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.5980359105672828, "y": -1.707874366221447, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Administrative Law Judges, Adjudicators, and Hearing Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.6794706237786028, "y": -0.5753303838632354, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operating Engineers and Other Construction Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.5141610416358646, "y": 1.5713343632155328, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "New Accounts Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.1873026308664851, "y": -1.0725151883127433, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiovisual Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.816648081382791, "y": -1.50667535614925, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.0967578935314926, "y": 0.5027184499633244, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cardiovascular Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.5831949185341108, "y": 0.3838846338695105, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machinists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.1309808706579929, "y": -0.7789862321338379, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Enforcement Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.2902226819176425, "y": 1.7905306476246012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parts Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -1.085384831815483, "y": -0.893650041213772, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.6635636563599853, "y": -0.517577089567993, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation and Benefits Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2913852991570329, "y": -1.057826379700708, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.7476282021598943, "y": -2.9066354353137718, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropologists and Archeologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.9"}}, {"x": 1.059243035120383, "y": 0.0737810112770786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food and Tobacco Roasting, Baking, and Drying Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.051413068811212, "y": -1.0285964836898145, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Upholsterers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 2.006967028695426, "y": -0.8915817661932963, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machine Feeders and Offbearers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5665656501121378, "y": -1.1203569620429734, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Service Technicians and Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.1460597364692063, "y": -2.4771716354370685, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furniture Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.5"}}, {"x": -1.7453540126887297, "y": -0.77576860367588, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Set and Exhibit Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.3370913112158744, "y": -1.44749765025019, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Choreographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.2071361577794199, "y": -1.5579211387157152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tile and Stone Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 1.239376988667188, "y": 0.4976494333044594, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Semiconductor Processing Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.3591321741120774, "y": -0.4751940555361829, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Milling and Planing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.0586105006816206, "y": 0.6509431247147095, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.8245011596794236, "y": 0.1663298721161238, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.73048476896969, "y": -0.0535092300226739, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.300758157626939, "y": -1.1093739903333966, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Passenger Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.9081771274176852, "y": -0.4787247902161308, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Registered Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8791403433824152, "y": -1.7728988730629602, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatric Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -0.8515657525789402, "y": -0.6502357085429152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Podiatrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.1327084593718657, "y": 0.1394715647387175, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.1750027166854198, "y": 1.7041880740025093, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -0.4994005675931286, "y": -1.0502504136134214, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Private Household", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.7336096555311683, "y": 0.5144363292079172, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.7596882588378406, "y": -0.4437687966693198, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mining and Geological Engineers, Including Mining Safety Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.8178909153404988, "y": -0.0256398800449984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.2979090631898951, "y": -0.3460778129657543, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Body and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.018218168909433, "y": -1.0767850465719897, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Riggers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.9062866927436664, "y": -0.7366014075367833, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Law Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.4188227109715064, "y": -0.4334832560556246, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Natural Sciences Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.3042871214464526, "y": -0.4127765106429133, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.290878095326021, "y": 0.5243594073831042, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.4063919049471256, "y": -0.9731614431004038, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5933234946090281, "y": -1.4048317000840786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hosts and Hostesses, Restaurant, Lounge, and Coffee Shop", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.3611622417453817, "y": 0.211206969318395, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.1764881636946277, "y": -0.6395247783115056, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locker Room, Coatroom, and Dressing Room Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.1420791956188615, "y": 0.5346037830648032, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cartographers and Photogrammetrists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -2.211084482938715, "y": -0.709757283313619, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -2.1624961778599108, "y": -2.0173136298356398, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coaches and Scouts", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -1.241868951622614, "y": -1.3708151143698095, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bioengineers and Biomedical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.823949326841795, "y": -1.0270896199281814, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveyors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.0059177475619447, "y": 3.7043646544335274, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Concierges", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "3.7"}}, {"x": -1.3104448357507248, "y": -1.111783623977346, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric, Earth, Marine, and Space Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.3329546031290148, "y": 1.3744025846132055, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Optometrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.26618186397543, "y": 0.914205001216102, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.4730577743534532, "y": 0.3760893116623983, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Distributors and Dispatchers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.6915885036748526, "y": -0.7752681566238422, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Speech-Language Pathologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.0455510273001787, "y": -0.7402282296627737, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crossing Guards and Flaggers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.2632569270088317, "y": 1.1429822355931951, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Water and Wastewater Treatment Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.8681469156656431, "y": -1.1062476141622295, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coin, Vending, and Amusement Machine Servicers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.7141046559031947, "y": -0.7225214263041517, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.167345290078491, "y": 1.3664924235032745, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Embalmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.3794237378925805, "y": -2.361084266709794, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Repairers and Changers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.4"}}, {"x": 0.9276862719301904, "y": 0.0017395563327743, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Assistants, Except Payroll and Timekeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.3021435467775782, "y": -1.2648939765225475, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.0831057227114354, "y": -0.2241199179426637, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Power-Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.6333753946233884, "y": -0.9111767593481992, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -2.158900354808966, "y": -1.1262720486951407, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.309662260928632, "y": 0.8808913234612983, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Residential Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.605246646367264, "y": -1.1598669863607447, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Soil and Plant Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.4923189420113432, "y": -1.1703375604745607, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -2.515496216126499, "y": 0.3237912982100076, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm and Home Management Educators", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.7061652594245325, "y": 0.1958587163172265, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.966928402936567, "y": -0.2033077855746403, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Self-Enrichment Teachers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0330405899918561, "y": 0.2399038304603144, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Highway Maintenance Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.035633531816979, "y": 0.2089975144336134, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera Operators, Television, Video, and Film", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5040729445567841, "y": -0.5842954642840812, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Private Detectives and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.3579826451892696, "y": 2.419009972130526, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "File Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.4"}}, {"x": 0.8251601318462432, "y": -0.9632404347183472, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Derrick Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.495263346651427, "y": 0.0023044075435958, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Middle School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.4041972330190037, "y": -0.3354644936702345, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietetic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.2027900279704455, "y": -0.6012073957798574, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packaging and Filling Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.8344455712588192, "y": -1.978465399519027, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cement Masons and Concrete Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -0.6456907883484053, "y": -0.1475276650864558, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.1525472155047861, "y": 1.2920261650851446, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Science Research Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.357833001150752, "y": 0.975254239466522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mail Clerks and Mail Machine Operators, Except Postal Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.831305637051771, "y": 0.7502547767337759, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.903586148685048, "y": -1.0658341617319715, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architecture Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.6829849255522995, "y": -0.2752733948580203, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biochemists and Biophysicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.6957585989448415, "y": -0.954752322560622, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rotary Drill Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.039521600990234, "y": -1.3876273416941067, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Railroad Conductors and Yardmasters", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.6279977976317257, "y": 0.8892141894913392, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.6336178723651176, "y": -2.6153357071609427, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletes and Sports Competitors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": -1.5156404877988283, "y": -2.958871018660389, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stonemasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-3.0"}}, {"x": -0.784849124549827, "y": -1.0545629163137369, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lodging Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.0645099809696479, "y": -1.1018389072004544, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postmasters and Mail Superintendents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.3490846221331796, "y": 1.062791546896957, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.7329707418306268, "y": 0.7900870229358354, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Cutting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.431197868553953, "y": -0.7691566706310858, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Vehicle Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.258792145634027, "y": -0.245732089332037, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Kindergarten Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3522010999809421, "y": -0.0947886552125531, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.1682534016042961, "y": -0.6279982940808546, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Commercial and Industrial Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.8065883038219844, "y": -1.0744283640833578, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.216428145739605, "y": -0.5550424968702864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.3575349868723051, "y": 0.9648651177004428, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool and Die Makers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.7167729479827766, "y": -0.1272687909665877, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.708627745846133, "y": -1.6824395220264798, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Curators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 1.3902994349745692, "y": 0.5174169407790125, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4926879046390026, "y": 0.4155387868293238, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Hardware Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.1318236588890729, "y": -0.3006473403438942, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paper Goods Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.7393331967145719, "y": -2.1976547608477057, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Announcers and Radio Disc Jockeys", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": 0.2832544616050947, "y": -0.7981142524191331, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.3397962075450541, "y": -0.0347868283923834, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Non-Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.8470263264749203, "y": 1.7995029144497094, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Phlebotomists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -1.2814149167083635, "y": 3.796748862544197, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Morticians, Undertakers, and Funeral Arrangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "3.8"}}, {"x": -0.950720864558097, "y": 1.1872475981619235, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Except Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.0235324327245148, "y": 2.50925092919116, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Machine Operators, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.5"}}, {"x": -1.5492638748310614, "y": -0.7193214437327661, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Specialties Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.9272564865352176, "y": 0.7169069559281591, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Practitioners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.2412894411645986, "y": -0.4791882147723722, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airfield Operations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3578058544745672, "y": -0.7366694301195331, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.1102215023516521, "y": -1.0028490129060488, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive and Watercraft Service Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.91533608373423, "y": -0.882058314369166, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Personal Financial Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.9078337914407992, "y": 0.0524613706419612, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Survey Researchers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.4353281092151733, "y": -0.5175225710636797, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Astronomers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.6926076287342153, "y": -0.5873854049798818, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers and Laborers, Crop, Nursery, and Greenhouse", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.4414645719719343, "y": -0.3778448444649378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.3181805863619124, "y": -0.9130846097706532, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Archivists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -2.1178775623218278, "y": 0.5495809394381478, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.339031438255265, "y": -0.4601979305254861, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Cooking Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.1547620111165768, "y": -0.6390915082321152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.9029821968790444, "y": -0.7613500059293368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graders and Sorters, Agricultural Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.530252107768302, "y": 0.2378331674059574, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Power Reactor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.7112473977081836, "y": -1.992372553135093, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Breeders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -0.1416328619647181, "y": 1.7061473048502498, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Amusement and Recreation Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -0.2403621511881639, "y": -0.6121090749869562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Appraisers, Auto Damage", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.4962195828573534, "y": -0.9745726815166204, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.6297127898630417, "y": -0.8320252273035819, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Agricultural Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -2.041821159923535, "y": 2.0639749722640057, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Door-to-Door Sales Workers, News and Street Vendors, and Related Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": 1.1563745313464453, "y": 2.1395065408468112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Transcriptionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": -0.7657936659810389, "y": 0.6945726162846511, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Mechanics, Installers, and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.8170171917173217, "y": -0.8444798475631302, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest Fire Inspectors and Prevention Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.825603154659069, "y": -0.550337391694847, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Family and Consumer Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.1012183996439375, "y": -0.5103828504588377, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Police and Sheriff's Patrol Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -2.0315493692647943, "y": -0.474729708961195, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Work Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.9500126070376148, "y": -1.6416938963217464, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Firefighters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -0.5133841737460411, "y": 0.0132763347060465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Production Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.5397937420842506, "y": 0.2634243068765265, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.3499771418862327, "y": -0.7319471508196693, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronic Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.1751133363204995, "y": -1.4365800495189696, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -2.234502859592556, "y": -1.1655375014904834, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Area, Ethnic, and Cultural Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.0307483544837543, "y": 2.26432962837209, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Travel Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": -0.4170348398794407, "y": -1.280074480051539, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lifeguards, Ski Patrol, and Other Recreational Protective Service Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.2511846601847043, "y": 1.6358232005664342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Switchboard Operators, Including Answering Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.7616809491938787, "y": 0.2852624143415886, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Printing Press Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.829393248096743, "y": 0.8601238820083051, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.2244066537133469, "y": -0.5336459088677338, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Etchers and Engravers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.542494518996816, "y": 0.2328123019988204, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Middle School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.303422390546166, "y": 2.2807189338560443, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Effects Artists and Animators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": 0.7434467452373493, "y": 1.771009158670548, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Legal Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -0.7795118833857506, "y": -1.1261295043434916, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.490619356336956, "y": -1.29389265231857, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.007965920450863, "y": -1.8834939056633964, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 1.510313007451929, "y": -1.935649308643498, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mixing and Blending Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.9693925638889028, "y": 1.7931903461515155, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Baggage Porters and Bellhops", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 0.542157981149319, "y": -0.825613968902602, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Conveyor Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2115773924288305, "y": -0.634704625459034, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.4119883293005517, "y": -1.2853321104783662, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Restaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.9637436001218708, "y": 0.3096761010629546, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interpreters and Translators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.0213769400310525, "y": 0.1291156451706752, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Accountants and Auditors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.8018162111536116, "y": 0.1544226900718833, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Secondary School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.0025978082411178, "y": -0.9496559694226024, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Janitors and Cleaners, Except Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5878393486504528, "y": -1.4483090047238558, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.3342983652234294, "y": -0.2547898826981801, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Retail Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.4781211160618974, "y": 2.0636789921251077, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": -0.0094680857194339, "y": 1.5219101935956785, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation, Benefits, and Job Analysis Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.017261433832303, "y": 0.3074270888289206, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.0261785206045886, "y": 1.8937872567089251, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Weighers, Measurers, Checkers, and Samplers, Recordkeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -0.491212452903623, "y": 1.3318396205366123, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Funeral Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 2.104487740229535, "y": 1.185318896355261, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reservation and Transportation Ticket Agents and Travel Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.6551441048891751, "y": -1.5758516483980722, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interviewers, Except Eligibility and Loan", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 1.24460537513979, "y": -1.2647133366046146, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heat Treating Equipment Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.7060166036241945, "y": -1.2927946144385711, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laborers and Freight, Stock, and Material Movers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.312553366016794, "y": -0.5975461217901368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Millwrights", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0604357096249049, "y": 0.9534778255169062, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reinforcing Iron and Rebar Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.0211954425738956, "y": -1.347086344662525, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paving, Surfacing, and Tamping Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.4046408042333749, "y": -1.4335129676444225, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Musical Instrument Repairers and Tuners", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.7012998338833971, "y": -0.7903937209143775, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Conservation Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.843344597993704, "y": -0.2058790118248618, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.4317398425565781, "y": 1.2148794325803645, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Securities, Commodities, and Financial Services Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.2142074841063902, "y": 0.3892259720964299, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Appliance Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.8127455370190103, "y": 0.2339778844189485, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Mechanical", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.0839652436131624, "y": -0.1332859232137924, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Detectives and Criminal Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.085513320787938, "y": 0.9064744804561012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.4688778344204163, "y": -0.1337145194229927, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foresters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -2.0652880244734684, "y": -1.876104244579476, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fashion Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.6097348416943514, "y": 0.1449979137603952, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Housekeeping and Janitorial Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.3022061518374382, "y": 0.5305520882824647, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Knitting and Weaving Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.7769990599516138, "y": -0.5904635399121327, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Layers, Except Carpet, Wood, and Hard Tiles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.5151390195019657, "y": 0.5331751445784586, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.112458745665784, "y": 1.0475591692540984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Customer Service Representatives", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.4577354992478977, "y": -0.0247019911970387, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Engineering Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.2624386301361847, "y": -0.3145863631903288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agents and Business Managers of Artists, Performers, and Athletes", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.6046577252228963, "y": -1.3793540249993144, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Medicine Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.6050495892236429, "y": -1.6209915058402684, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dredge Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -0.8225645682725966, "y": -1.2484381352530338, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rehabilitation Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.3277182155559406, "y": 1.840934716841677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ushers, Lobby Attendants, and Ticket Takers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -0.4359828423867974, "y": -0.0130695079498478, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinarians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.4179236921718974, "y": -0.919678838358521, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Models", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.824249414799414, "y": -0.8508326172540968, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Preparation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.0863152633726389, "y": -0.0989483757313579, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lawyers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.5945431108364287, "y": 0.0456507754355534, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Security Screeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.7461634106624586, "y": -0.8569467807555065, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation and Fitness Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.3378245445497652, "y": -1.0956663422754522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial and Industrial Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.463389018131386, "y": -1.40353725913628, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bailiffs", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.1047929570056536, "y": -0.8728005171049674, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tapers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.4288688329142143, "y": -1.1481557535015512, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaners of Vehicles and Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.0639994512486199, "y": -2.4071802126292536, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Sanders and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.4"}}, {"x": 0.4099916757187356, "y": -0.6833283712442799, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tank Car, Truck, and Ship Loaders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.3748166553039408, "y": -0.8704885416470663, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Log Graders and Scalers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.1948068060793332, "y": -0.7246401134524477, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judges, Magistrate Judges, and Magistrates", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.838514124045148, "y": 0.8228498905622924, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Winding, Twisting, and Drawing Out Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.7266747538855354, "y": -4.094023124406283, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pipelayers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-4.1"}}, {"x": 0.4850646824522794, "y": -1.1675578706996457, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Continuous Mining Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1267081165122968, "y": -0.3830067605235416, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dentists, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.4539405695217607, "y": -0.3444061226946274, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.5458909643294669, "y": 0.482807670241222, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Powerhouse, Substation, and Relay", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.0805537759406174, "y": -0.3287984039622622, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molding, Coremaking, and Casting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5047140219008556, "y": -0.0740401623254842, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2651908544659347, "y": -4.776680371595578, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locksmiths and Safe Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-4.8"}}, {"x": 0.0549010878820693, "y": -1.6537595554662483, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Compressor and Gas Pumping Station Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -2.063559437558738, "y": -1.085154062756742, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.428029598703468, "y": 1.5714764975621824, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Claims and Policy Processing Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.5091934507281161, "y": 1.936422756247491, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shipping, Receiving, and Inventory Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -0.3095442043451213, "y": -0.0868022583826735, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Equipment Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5594525776157964, "y": -0.5964076397320454, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.1458552216044873, "y": -0.7408039161999105, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Fast Food", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.5530655594833603, "y": -1.5097886303951311, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Terrazzo Workers and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.874106654568681, "y": 0.174152968513809, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Batchmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0275386377194975, "y": 1.953279391222628, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": 0.3315311988631069, "y": 0.3327402022898864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Multiple Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.0076408288069665, "y": -0.3554334135771774, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Captains, Mates, and Pilots of Water Vessels", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.8305821343472589, "y": 0.7852209618989445, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Authorizers, Checkers, and Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.8207444276144482, "y": 1.961442416786782, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": 0.8917267046875949, "y": 0.8777560790069405, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Flight Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.399555731390285, "y": -2.151129508185706, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motion Picture Projectionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -0.4012180288777832, "y": 0.4708392102612143, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sheet Metal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.7777302446432449, "y": 0.678091626737669, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Childcare Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.2601007592254225, "y": -0.6642795617652281, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Installation, Maintenance, and Repair Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.989866693707687, "y": 1.1617029867370685, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Education Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Brynjolfsson et al. rating": "1.2"}}], "size": 8.333333333333332, "fillColor": "rgb(2.0, 118.0, 124.0)", "strokeColor": "rgb(255.0, 255.0, 255.0)", "fillAlpha": 0.3, "strokeAlpha": 0.3, "marker": "M 0.0,-0.5 C 0.13260155,-0.5 0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C 0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 0.5,-0.13260155 0.5,0.0 C 0.5,0.13260155 0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C 0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 0.13260155,0.5 0.0,0.5 C -0.13260155,0.5 -0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 -0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C -0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 -0.5,0.13260155 -0.5,0.0 C -0.5,-0.13260155 -0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 -0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C -0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 -0.13260155,-0.5 0.0,-0.5 Z 0.0,-0.5", "isFilled": true}, {"type": "line", "color": "#034752", "zOrder": 2, "strokeWidth": 2.25, "lineStyle": "-", "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -0.8246989598129482}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": -0.8130233708902179}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": -0.8013477819674879}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": -0.7896721930447577}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": -0.7779966041220276}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": -0.7663210151992974}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": -0.7546454262765674}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": -0.7429698373538371}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": -0.7312942484311071}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": -0.7196186595083769}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": -0.7079430705856469}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": -0.6962674816629166}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": -0.6845918927401866}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": -0.6729163038174565}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": -0.6612407148947264}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": -0.6495651259719961}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": -0.6378895370492661}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": -0.626213948126536}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": -0.6145383592038058}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": -0.6028627702810757}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": -0.5911871813583456}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": -0.5795115924356155}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": -0.5678360035128853}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": -0.5561604145901551}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": -0.5444848256674251}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": -0.5328092367446949}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": -0.5211336478219648}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": -0.5094580588992347}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": -0.49778246997650455}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": -0.4861068810537744}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": -0.4744312921310443}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": -0.46275570320831416}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": -0.45108011428558403}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": -0.4394045253628539}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": -0.4277289364401238}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": -0.41605334751739365}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": -0.4043777585946635}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": -0.3927021696719334}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": -0.38102658074920326}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": -0.36935099182647313}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": -0.357675402903743}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": -0.34599981398101287}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": -0.33432422505828274}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": -0.3226486361355526}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": -0.3109730472128225}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": -0.29929745829009236}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": -0.2876218693673622}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.27594628044463215}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.264270691521902}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.2525951025991719}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.24091951367644174}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.22924392475371158}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.21756833583098145}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": -0.20589274690825132}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": -0.19421715798552125}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": -0.18254156906279112}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": -0.170865980140061}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": -0.15919039121733083}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": -0.1475148022946007}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": -0.13583921337187055}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": -0.12416362444914042}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": -0.11248803552641037}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": -0.10081244660368023}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": -0.08913685768095009}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": -0.07746126875821996}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": -0.0657856798354898}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": -0.05411009091275967}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": -0.04243450199002963}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": -0.03075891306729947}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": -0.01908332414456934}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": -0.0074077352218391845}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.0042678537008909445}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.015943442623621074}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 0.02761903154635123}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 0.03929462046908136}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 0.050970209391811516}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 0.06264579831454165}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 0.07432138723727177}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 0.0859969761600019}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 0.09767256508273187}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 0.10934815400546205}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 0.12102374292819218}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 0.1326993318509223}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 0.14437492077365244}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 0.15605050969638257}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 0.16772609861911275}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 0.17940168754184288}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 0.191077276464573}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 0.20275286538730314}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 0.21442845431003327}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 0.2261040432327634}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 0.23777963215549358}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 0.2494552210782237}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 0.2611308100009537}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 0.2728063989236838}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 0.28448198784641393}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 0.29615757676914406}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 0.3078331656918742}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 0.3195087546146043}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.33118434353733445}]}, {"type": "polygon", "color": "rgb(3.0, 71.0, 82.0)", "alpha": 0.15, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -0.5668812633543607}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -1.0847946175027523}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": -1.0673966806334976}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": -1.0499830399295347}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": -1.0325525096447161}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": -1.0151219793598976}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": -0.997070217775138}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": -0.9798377873883828}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": -0.9629121960021773}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": -0.9455415000730997}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": -0.9287165820599352}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": -0.9126913191529837}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": -0.8966539559011156}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": -0.8806014520539872}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": -0.8648833600125151}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": -0.8500092864367685}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": -0.8342809403978984}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": -0.8195075143069172}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": -0.8033944259873684}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": -0.7866941125021606}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": -0.7700079133686158}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": -0.7548269691657349}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": -0.7402209648157467}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": -0.7226717568225961}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": -0.7081927962680311}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": -0.6932307435296309}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": -0.6776656058328518}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": -0.6625215037440926}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": -0.6461190617868309}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": -0.6320454483167294}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": -0.6183382100870835}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": -0.5996214609506133}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": -0.584456480219671}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": -0.5697334048469083}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": -0.5550106106532068}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": -0.5401629115376643}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": -0.5255532163396682}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": -0.5108663677649109}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": -0.4987833950940004}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": -0.48478206942101393}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": -0.4694571597764424}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": -0.4564872334704281}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": -0.44398728359917256}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": -0.4303382059711324}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": -0.41660334389332454}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": -0.4022895851660427}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": -0.388164327913781}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": -0.3754339254254374}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.36188366095269325}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.3491985329418052}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.3374533632994642}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.32246351264480966}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.30932788962957314}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.29682127481330894}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": -0.2865688968822672}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": -0.27592636295157524}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": -0.26651004110800125}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": -0.25594720099503454}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": -0.24507640274642056}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": -0.23520129860355615}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": -0.22599103024000622}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": -0.2160338136032464}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": -0.2072271042978035}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": -0.1993037994043233}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": -0.19121002456215325}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": -0.18094445493920017}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": -0.17037396124146204}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": -0.1619981377180499}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": -0.15420062894180261}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": -0.14722706579756686}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": -0.13827424554768783}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": -0.12938787449146635}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": -0.12095747990667247}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": -0.11306187558650121}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": -0.1077502982195009}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": -0.10090640953824288}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": -0.0938034066233749}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": -0.08607193198392776}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": -0.07805228734686648}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": -0.07003264270980518}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": -0.06397203799082642}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": -0.053956318358276835}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": -0.04666079511495352}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": -0.04004151407519932}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": -0.030762494980391495}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": -0.022097798042751526}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": -0.014944406542471452}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": -0.008088197876506284}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": -0.0012885676545029542}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 0.006323812796525577}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 0.013619347655402935}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 0.020744315516358813}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 0.027900425803894704}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 0.03526700329190307}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 0.04346318371285918}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 0.051659364133815396}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 0.05986799344042443}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 0.06739941697425063}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 0.07439506929524843}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 0.08139072161624623}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.08929985308648303}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.5891185556729561}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.5891185556729561}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 0.5721503707433715}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 0.5551821858137865}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 0.5394550799183478}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 0.521851781729316}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 0.5043463164505197}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 0.4873750143808328}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 0.47132533346604694}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 0.454991611297149}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 0.4391442253088135}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 0.4232968393204779}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 0.4074494533321424}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 0.3916020673438068}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 0.37575468135547124}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 0.3604946360432428}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 0.345264913499731}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 0.33003519095621925}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 0.3147960778043389}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 0.2995183770250194}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 0.28424067624569993}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 0.26903449291950576}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 0.25596878656508804}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 0.24289576492627582}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 0.22723098282983067}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 0.209193134112548}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 0.19341953752913113}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 0.1773300581275418}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.16304281040447122}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.1480444976682498}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": 0.13286949972227677}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": 0.11626035472179223}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": 0.10099023821239174}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": 0.08562289047312417}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": 0.06934928925458994}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": 0.055172574569978504}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": 0.03968312816038478}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": 0.02475766426478345}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": 0.009904073845844451}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": -0.0055684216115896405}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": -0.020212393245837387}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": -0.03418167091485292}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": -0.04817017970245631}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": -0.06379077846116782}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": -0.07896169477980385}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": -0.09320640712035717}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": -0.10655458973109908}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": -0.12091023283768101}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.13471159558701165}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.14778027548924916}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.15962890963748594}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.17083541303742328}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.18104112847661322}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.19255507787234197}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": -0.20350561264595102}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": -0.21430433291859444}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": -0.2255337407760743}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": -0.23684824886712144}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": -0.24666352951059667}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": -0.2545848759504642}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": -0.2632108426634092}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": -0.27382983919956655}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": -0.28263266521038155}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": -0.29136547240298977}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": -0.29908690344251126}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": -0.3074635627950294}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": -0.31662076652524135}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": -0.32739280466296883}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": -0.335538422918631}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": -0.34253449614532805}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": -0.3493350202112627}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": -0.35717724346692004}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": -0.3641559529296146}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": -0.3707298235713523}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": -0.37879631796558416}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": -0.3872607150265722}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": -0.39525583570405}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": -0.4029830908067182}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": -0.41127546766430384}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": -0.4191134822673051}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": -0.42715202872990354}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": -0.43320533779642223}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": -0.44016734881812675}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": -0.449102926481542}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": -0.456821492998605}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": -0.4627113202273461}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": -0.4708298419401253}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": -0.4801614793426839}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": -0.48950244054271846}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": -0.4975445875398742}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": -0.5031195590116473}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": -0.5086945304834205}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": -0.5142695019551936}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": -0.5198444734269667}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": -0.5254194448987398}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": -0.5316683829869787}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": -0.538682128547897}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": -0.545695874108815}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": -0.5527312694671286}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": -0.5598062664107446}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -0.5668812633543607}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -0.5668812633543607}], "closed": true}, {"type": "text", "color": "grey", "zOrder": 3, "text": "R\u00b2=0.03", "x": 0.08, "y": 0.87, "ha": "left", "va": "baseline", "rotation": 0.0, "rotationMode": "default", "background": true, "fontSizeScaling": 1, "textCoords": "paper-normalized"}], "hud": [], "originalDataAspectRatio": 0.7451612903225805, "additionalLegendItems": []} {"downloadButtonPosition": "none"}

{"title": "Comparison of automatability measures across occupations", "xAxis": {"label": "Autor et al.", "lim": [-3.4465900025433047, 3.0697599100120265], "scaleType": "linear"}, "yAxis": {"label": "Felten et al.", "lim": [-2.863437899377844, 1.6806317320652884], "scaleType": "linear"}, "showFrame": true, "objects": [{"type": "scatter", "alpha": 0.3, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -1.3879757172393794, "y": 0.6012454488286882, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hydrologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.8738669794255672, "y": -0.0580569577430339, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Inspectors, Testers, Sorters, Samplers, and Weighers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.1666628024119154, "y": -0.5894350167709891, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fine Artists, Including Painters, Sculptors, and Illustrators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.7804981301768894, "y": 0.9938747924437884, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.8795861299816146, "y": -0.3296501879128777, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Construction Trades and Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.7687729425831287, "y": 1.3127016278605617, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Interviewers and Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.6629131000636508, "y": 1.2644839891709878, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marketing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.12378193496383, "y": -0.3020972515188356, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.9277204053432249, "y": 1.2831806245812307, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.398356520939802, "y": -1.4209432758054743, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manufactured Building and Mobile Home Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.9061688817454226, "y": 0.734089963585677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Child, Family, and School Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.229972685882886, "y": -0.1948376062706002, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.7812259575544531, "y": 1.2831806245812307, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chief Executives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.0039331134124508, "y": -1.6817121381062303, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Pipelayers, Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 1.859323689241689, "y": -0.0787216600385655, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Change Persons and Booth Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.557483831077505, "y": -0.6169879531650313, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1412240429044082, "y": 0.6750479570270153, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graphic Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.1029408398799553, "y": 0.069867389800733, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Opticians, Dispensing", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.4607253338358603, "y": 0.5362992416141603, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "General and Operations Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.207129400606792, "y": -0.7488484344793757, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.3411191413364209, "y": -0.2086140744676212, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Pilots", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.7633323806856949, "y": -0.6356845885752741, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Subway and Streetcar Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7317018320835897, "y": -0.4142770639802928, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security Guards", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2438311053934494, "y": -1.044058467272684, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crane and Tower Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.1090292074789271, "y": -1.161158446947363, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sailors and Marine Oilers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.1597849936475773, "y": -0.5195686423432395, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locomotive Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4002584839064506, "y": -0.9023576515318962, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5337725316665024, "y": -1.7555146463045574, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brickmasons and Blockmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 0.2162911735904329, "y": 1.2526755878592557, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.2775952412045133, "y": 1.3835520357309554, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.4105844317226746, "y": -0.8964534508760299, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool Grinders, Filers, and Sharpeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.996340114497679, "y": 0.8895672475234861, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Healthcare Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.0353559581581828, "y": 0.0009850488156277, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Preschool Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.2406121254605465, "y": -2.0418683781140663, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Painters, Paperhangers, Plasterers, and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 1.8204565641037875, "y": -1.195599617439916, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Sorters, Processors, and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.067303770014071, "y": 1.4347217747484624, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Procurement Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.2588012909362202, "y": -1.5242667872831324, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roustabouts, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.2291720398343169, "y": 0.5668042783361356, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hotel, Motel, and Resort Desk Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.2592578673812185, "y": 0.129893429802039, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.272530239671472, "y": 0.5668042783361356, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9906848123176468, "y": 1.1080226717905342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Community Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.6730993274418786, "y": -0.9377828554670932, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bicycle Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.7660536591214124, "y": 1.0745655347406262, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interior Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.9199418254306408, "y": 1.297941126220896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Business Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.1984900413932157, "y": -0.9850164607140224, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painting, Coating, and Decorating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.9651727034022022, "y": 1.3746957347471562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.8678163958494096, "y": 0.4280555629232805, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling and Sports Book Writers and Runners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.4775046840042845, "y": -0.8767727820231427, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Bleaching and Dyeing Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.4376365754218905, "y": -0.1190670311869843, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Museum Technicians and Conservators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0188198127948211, "y": 1.2831806245812307, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemistry Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.4865439553846576, "y": -0.8757887485804984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Forming Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Synthetic and Glass Fibers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.3192931547383277, "y": -0.1131628305311182, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Production and Operating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0949537063416281, "y": -0.2145182751234874, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Respiratory Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4480116316352364, "y": 0.8787428796543981, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Civil Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.458285251111881, "y": 0.9948588258864328, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.8988100277128837, "y": -0.9200702534994948, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shampooers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.6273322601296695, "y": -1.3904382390834995, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Door Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.2097198306705703, "y": 1.2821965911385862, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Billing and Posting Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3180282187359726, "y": 0.0925001589815533, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Demonstrators and Product Promoters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.8718361075941772, "y": 0.7951000370296274, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education and Childcare Administrators, Preschool and Daycare", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.4527867458282585, "y": -1.569532325644773, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpet Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 1.1743689098151666, "y": -1.6147978640064138, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Builders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -1.35719352361029, "y": -0.5786106489019013, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Correctional Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.3878560374962543, "y": 1.296957092778252, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.6176510641006632, "y": -1.8352213551587504, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Slaughterers and Meat Packers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -0.8794611907585571, "y": 1.0135554612966755, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer and Information Systems Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.0028291672137524, "y": -0.5244888095564613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stationary Engineers and Boiler Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.9905780385848506, "y": -0.6150198862797426, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7406839953693914, "y": -1.72894574335316, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tree Trimmers and Pruners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.9380037429031493, "y": 1.4101209386823534, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judicial Law Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.8778901879268389, "y": -0.9860004941566668, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meter Readers, Utilities", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.146188611016774, "y": -1.7407541446648922, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dishwashers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.8317415685275095, "y": -1.21232818596487, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Glass Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1745555230932532, "y": -0.9003895846466073, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pesticide Handlers, Sprayers, and Applicators, Vegetation", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -2.651248398474005, "y": 1.210362149825548, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forestry and Conservation Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.6647895434714719, "y": 0.0541228547184232, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveying and Mapping Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0558322850299701, "y": -1.3963424397393656, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Glaziers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.4950131724181174, "y": -0.9446710895656036, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Craft Artists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.26970421220172, "y": 1.232994919006368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Clergy", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.036151212776815, "y": 1.3845360691736, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "History Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.7819185045085033, "y": 1.1050705714626012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Air Traffic Controllers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.6262646108388754, "y": -0.7439282672661539, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pest Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.6170505642570706, "y": -0.6740618928384042, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.5201602731015502, "y": 0.2666740783296052, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -2.1096742408509983, "y": 1.2162663504814142, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.6366551142657275, "y": 0.0068892494714938, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Community Health Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 1.5470181213201686, "y": -1.1178609754710114, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meat, Poultry, and Fish Cutters and Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.9388818956190284, "y": -0.2971770843056138, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floral Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.8801617726657183, "y": 1.2881007917944525, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematical Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.2491564480854882, "y": -0.7399921334955765, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Layout Workers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.136975723495231, "y": -1.4179911754775416, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Production Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.6790061859797019, "y": -1.2467693564574227, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refractory Materials Repairers, Except Brickmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.7819356456226125, "y": 1.2418512199901677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paralegals and Legal Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.5563316338766712, "y": -0.9584475577626248, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Solar Photovoltaic Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5764248510627038, "y": -0.991904694812533, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hoist and Winch Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.4951107921040945, "y": -0.7449123007087982, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Servers, Nonrestaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.096748042827857, "y": -1.7417381781075365, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foundry Mold and Coremakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.3169447298842093, "y": -0.5353131774255493, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Licensed Practical and Licensed Vocational Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.8427647104734115, "y": -0.1485880344663152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.7979287796407275, "y": 1.316637761631139, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.4174885121922616, "y": -1.0548828351417725, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding, Forming, Pressing, and Compacting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.6001567912318234, "y": 0.6868563583387476, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Surveillance Officers and Gambling Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.332257858369244, "y": 1.0794857019538475, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.8628367773058664, "y": 0.8629983445720883, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Safety Telecommunicators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.9253881581355786, "y": 1.297941126220896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adult Basic Education, Adult Secondary Education, and English as a Second Language Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.115542120743649, "y": -0.7114551636588899, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security and Fire Alarm Systems Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.8478630448741451, "y": -0.9151500862862728, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plating Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.6955245225744036, "y": -0.2184544088940649, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Police and Detectives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.107337904574303, "y": 0.9850184914599892, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Emergency Management Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.459045469791104, "y": 0.8433176757192011, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.7923693052017245, "y": -0.8649643807114104, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heating, Air Conditioning, and Refrigeration Mechanics and Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5133653075622094, "y": -0.700630795789802, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hairdressers, Hairstylists, and Cosmetologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.899884285005504, "y": 1.2999091931061848, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engineering Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.9096847130366288, "y": -1.1414777780944758, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Woodworking Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Except Sawing", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.9450373452170504, "y": 0.4792253019407874, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nursing Instructors and Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.260815125874153, "y": -0.2893048167644589, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Diagnostic Medical Sonographers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6058133203748001, "y": -0.9092458856304066, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Outdoor Power Equipment and Other Small Engine Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1802755546079249, "y": -0.3699955590612965, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer, Automated Teller, and Office Machine Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 2.308011656461644, "y": -1.0430744338300395, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "2.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.7917310476663457, "y": 1.3313982632708043, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.8851386916400845, "y": -0.2647039806983499, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.8311679997784562, "y": 1.0519327655598056, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.1859608627599854, "y": -0.1111947636458295, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fabric and Apparel Patternmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.6235878556784445, "y": -0.8482358121864562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Yard Engineers, Dinkey Operators, and Hostlers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.6608103499457694, "y": 1.4081528717970646, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.1576690232763411, "y": 0.2834026468545594, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Zoologists and Wildlife Biologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.2758731672301599, "y": 0.4349437970217911, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sound Engineering Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.3103914296664506, "y": -0.2932409505350364, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chefs and Head Cooks", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.1052002908318708, "y": -0.7813215380866396, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorcycle Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.3456587931753214, "y": -0.2450233118454626, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiation Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1662019129923107, "y": 1.3087654940899842, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.4470366621020035, "y": -0.8088744744806818, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronic Equipment Installers and Repairers, Motor Vehicles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.6354002347736443, "y": 1.379615901960378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Arbitrators, Mediators, and Conciliators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -2.330784055904513, "y": 0.9289285852292604, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Educational, Guidance, and Career Counselors and Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.793744986464031, "y": -0.984032427271378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Home Appliance Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.49820798587486, "y": -0.3857400941436063, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographic Process Workers and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.8579685140459804, "y": -1.5193466200699108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packers and Packagers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.0183809588051669, "y": -0.962383691533202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutters and Trimmers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.2795218700990303, "y": -0.5520417459505035, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.2623391526162582, "y": 1.3382864973693147, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statistical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.0628692390837011, "y": -1.8243969872896628, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscaping and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 1.3089559447421135, "y": -0.2735602816821491, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.360155271736588, "y": -1.0037130961242653, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding, Lapping, Polishing, and Buffing Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.5396079321446071, "y": 1.472115045568948, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Examiners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.9669829948160152, "y": -1.101132406946057, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rolling Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.5710404730541805, "y": -0.8689005144819878, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Equipment Installers and Repairers, Except Line Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.184724227600342, "y": -0.6533971905428727, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radio, Cellular, and Tower Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.1645226637058472, "y": -1.0046971295669096, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe and Leather Workers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.7711931576309774, "y": -0.7911618725130833, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Assistants and Laboratory Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.3926167440556287, "y": 1.0007630265422989, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architects, Except Landscape and Naval", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.6267937654755713, "y": 0.943689086868926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Clerks, General", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.1586119749940411, "y": 1.0716134344126929, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.504803091190655, "y": -0.2696241479115717, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.7281594872419926, "y": -0.1830292049588678, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Jewelers and Precious Stone and Metal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.4459361806357918, "y": -1.193631550554627, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molders, Shapers, and Casters, Except Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.008514111373503, "y": -0.0619930915136114, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Physiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -2.5673369967257145, "y": 1.1788730796609284, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Urban and Regional Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.4838150007725963, "y": -0.8452837118585231, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coil Winders, Tapers, and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.3646337058614783, "y": -1.2300407879324684, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pile Driver Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.413652326235589, "y": 0.3552370881675978, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineering and Operations Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.7115386799945627, "y": 1.316637761631139, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cost Estimators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.5943329550635068, "y": -1.2211844869486692, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Septic Tank Servicers and Sewer Pipe Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.5199121450668008, "y": 1.224138618022569, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Claims Adjusters, Examiners, and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.5305181232195075, "y": 0.4359278304644354, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tellers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.4865023643391553, "y": 1.2438192868754565, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising and Promotions Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.9498596825735608, "y": 1.0027310934275877, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Kindergarten through Secondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.349270017361749, "y": 1.294989025892963, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.2870916936583988, "y": -1.0174895643212865, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logging Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3979925945108996, "y": 0.655367288174128, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Microbiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.9289446585442722, "y": 0.8472538094897786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation, Storage, and Distribution Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.261215927667404, "y": 1.284164658023875, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Labor Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.2959256040461369, "y": 1.1985537485138156, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.2173345606272563, "y": 0.1643346002945917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Midwives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3419903257028654, "y": -1.754530612861913, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -0.2322879970452644, "y": -0.4752871374242433, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Costume Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.0367234606969555, "y": -0.0285359544637031, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.096593567122127, "y": -1.781099515813311, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Iron and Steel Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -2.2426924043436363, "y": 0.7163773616180785, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art, Drama, and Music Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.0893882922911258, "y": 0.9427050534262816, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Writers and Authors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1027259585525155, "y": -1.0233937649771525, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.255497013586391, "y": -0.9860004941566668, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Service Unit Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.1435896306415737, "y": -0.2332149105337302, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airline Pilots, Copilots, and Flight Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5207884919746754, "y": -0.1466199675810265, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0421236179435285, "y": 0.968289922935035, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Scientists and Specialists, Including Health", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.855060775139609, "y": -1.0775156043225924, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Carriers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.7172717451093302, "y": 0.5825488134184453, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Word Processors and Typists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.427905954618115, "y": -0.8757887485804984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elevator and Escalator Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.3883263612610775, "y": -0.548105612179926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.1326045094331685, "y": 0.9879705917879222, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscape Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.3331083471176046, "y": -0.8374114443173682, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transit and Railroad Police", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.5689573020554451, "y": -0.3394905223393213, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.3988620055019044, "y": -0.4575745354566447, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Labor Contractors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.878637112989117, "y": 1.1769050127756395, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Eligibility Interviewers, Government Programs", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.716245025559664, "y": -1.1778870154723171, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Metal-Refining Furnace Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1153503650067896, "y": 1.2300428186784351, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Scientists, Except Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.7545121597708432, "y": -0.970255959074357, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engine and Other Machine Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.2055050168889151, "y": -0.0619930915136114, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Umpires, Referees, and Other Sports Officials", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.8269838306805912, "y": -0.6130518193944539, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Short Order", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.3355795054575677, "y": -1.0224097315345082, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pourers and Casters, Metal", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.6896623194547988, "y": -0.4536384016860673, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tailors, Dressmakers, and Custom Sewers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.9269442287740294, "y": -0.7773854043160622, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drilling and Boring Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2503349809478545, "y": -0.9525433571067584, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Separating, Filtering, Clarifying, Precipitating, and Still Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.805608689891823, "y": -0.8216669092350585, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forging Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.0452772118071618, "y": 1.3481268317957584, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operations Research Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.7843564994601844, "y": 1.1936335813005938, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fundraisers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.0931249019367593, "y": -1.15820634661943, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding and Polishing Workers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.3974472910211182, "y": -1.079483671207881, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lathe and Turning Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.275127175318862, "y": 0.7518025655532755, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Scientists and Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.1035045259606848, "y": 1.3127016278605617, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Philosophy and Religion Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.6177573881765728, "y": -0.7468803675940869, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Driver/Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.860101367472801, "y": 0.048218654062557, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.7016666738235096, "y": -0.6130518193944539, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Firefighting and Prevention Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.5952167662256497, "y": -1.4061827741658093, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail-Track Laying and Maintenance Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.4106782716026849, "y": 1.102118471134668, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correspondence Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.3718634252361831, "y": 1.3933923701573991, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.5514297625619868, "y": 0.5087463052201182, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marine Engineers and Naval Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.9979158190254164, "y": 0.9869865583452778, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.168257496434765, "y": -0.7783694377587066, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Control and Valve Installers and Repairers, Except Mechanical Door", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -2.3887831446158225, "y": 0.1859833360327676, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.0183989055691776, "y": 0.0137774835700044, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.8167005964033244, "y": -0.5766425820166126, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiologic Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.3756481511626501, "y": -0.199757773483822, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Avionics Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.601366659204723, "y": -0.8462677453011674, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ambulance Drivers and Attendants, Except Emergency Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.0651753538796804, "y": -1.2083920521942926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welders, Cutters, Solderers, and Brazers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.8997798001241091, "y": 1.0519327655598056, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Historians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.2864419155115894, "y": -1.3195878312131053, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adhesive Bonding Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.8575731168305705, "y": -1.0666912364535046, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laundry and Dry-Cleaning Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.3439734260570267, "y": 1.3333663301560932, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.043337764227231, "y": -0.1013544292193858, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -2.1191467593298605, "y": 1.365839433763357, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "English Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.1456937718268784, "y": 1.27629239048272, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Underwriters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.302936056976872, "y": -0.21058214135291, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.2678319184750424, "y": 0.9978109262143658, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.961096082230804, "y": -0.962383691533202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Waiters and Waitresses", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3626576043666109, "y": 0.7960840704722717, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Order Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.3409863554482197, "y": -1.7299297767958042, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paperhangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 1.543237498245881, "y": -1.948385201062852, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pressers, Textile, Garment, and Related Materials", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.7579204616488344, "y": 0.6248622514521529, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronics Engineers, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.9822806035794333, "y": 0.374917757020485, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Prepress Technicians and Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.4989676451123788, "y": 1.0971983039214463, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brokerage Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -2.00606003700463, "y": 1.2831806245812307, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foreign Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.0654027329048016, "y": -1.9011515958159229, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fence Erectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.5333638512536465, "y": -1.1149088751430782, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Divers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.5597607197091468, "y": 0.7980521373575604, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.1702958363252753, "y": -0.2174703754514205, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chiropractors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.275963820611964, "y": -1.076531570879948, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest and Conservation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.6229718502009335, "y": -1.651207101384255, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drywall and Ceiling Tile Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.5084109052552163, "y": -0.9850164607140224, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Butchers and Meat Cutters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5791583819927179, "y": -0.9879685610419556, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance Workers, Machinery", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.7576292009047862, "y": 1.3500948986810473, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial-Organizational Psychologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.873748106549436, "y": 1.2516915544166112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Instructional Coordinators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.6283372102046054, "y": -1.0883399721916804, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Metal Fabricators and Fitters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.1113836504282495, "y": 1.2221705511372802, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bill and Account Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.3625311479896964, "y": -0.97320805940229, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Couriers and Messengers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.8611705519922842, "y": -0.651429123657584, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bridge and Lock Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2038056414528196, "y": -1.335332366295415, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cabinetmakers and Bench Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.5173509320945054, "y": -0.504808140703574, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surgical Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2121641423044445, "y": -1.0558668685844164, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crushing, Grinding, and Polishing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.3808401820098453, "y": 0.339492553085288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Preschool", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4287701686383378, "y": -0.8738206816952097, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Signal and Track Switch Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.6814896517281743, "y": 1.2713722232694984, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropology and Archeology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.173473636669783, "y": 1.29203692556503, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietitians and Nutritionists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3942567266559647, "y": 1.3343503635987373, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.4391685872432179, "y": -1.7958600174529762, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fallers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 0.4476966830581191, "y": -1.0155214974359976, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welding, Soldering, and Brazing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.2733249177323729, "y": -1.153286179406208, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaning, Washing, and Metal Pickling Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.5249279594054749, "y": -1.454400412855383, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Car Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.3776478305970298, "y": 0.126941329474106, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.7206932847569244, "y": -0.9722240259596456, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furnace, Kiln, Oven, Drier, and Kettle Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.5596459401413999, "y": -0.0413283892180798, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audio and Video Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.842045453577487, "y": 1.3156537281884946, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Examiners and Collectors, and Revenue Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.3938952542378198, "y": 0.9909226921158552, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.517268926304522, "y": -0.9033416849745404, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correctional Officers and Jailers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.0319613075533194, "y": -1.7574827131898465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plasterers and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -1.7285894926632013, "y": 0.6730798901417265, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geoscientists, Except Hydrologists and Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.564049581303414, "y": -1.5124583859714, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.6736007874983986, "y": -1.02732989874773, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance and Repair Workers, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.979860085336681, "y": -0.4064047964391379, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.3561213822478264, "y": 1.4622747111425043, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actuaries", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.0744809961151065, "y": 1.102118471134668, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Brokers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.9527003673193264, "y": 1.2881007917944525, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.7477243545871888, "y": 1.3707596009765788, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Purchasing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.6000761800414834, "y": 1.4740831124542368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Genetic Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 1.4258112577101307, "y": -1.2438172561294896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Drawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.941582977348845, "y": 0.0747875570139548, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physician Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9175406008240258, "y": 1.117863006216978, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Court, Municipal, and License Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.9741941235909012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telephone Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.2105395982479372, "y": -1.0912920725196136, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting and Slicing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 2.113268072214425, "y": 0.0305060520949585, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Dealers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.1356029499591191, "y": -0.6553652574281614, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Institution and Cafeteria", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.3487615050458227, "y": 0.489065636367231, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Probation Officers and Correctional Treatment Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -1.270680593235209, "y": 0.8964554816219965, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.3911799612513187, "y": -0.5756585485739681, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Landscaping, Lawn Service, and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.5494797868144166, "y": -0.9850164607140224, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wind Turbine Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.472712350022055, "y": -0.3227619538143672, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.7761718702554996, "y": -1.2920348948190632, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refuse and Recyclable Material Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.7769366037314608, "y": 1.1690327452344846, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.5194640396300716, "y": 0.0039371491435607, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manicurists and Pedicurists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.3842542364284055, "y": 0.0246018514390923, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera and Photographic Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -2.092558237933194, "y": 1.1493520763815974, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.7413174128753748, "y": 1.2684201229415653, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geography Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.5816629934821564, "y": -0.2883207833218146, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Skincare Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.1071197858238884, "y": 0.5933731812875332, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2758565602456502, "y": -1.096212239732835, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.4599543797063599, "y": -0.3936123616847612, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Pump System Operators, Refinery Operators, and Gaugers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0582176742081917, "y": -1.1099887079298565, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Boilermakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.764086569407202, "y": 1.2694041563842096, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.6043578751229657, "y": 1.4494822763881277, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Budget Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.2744437195026044, "y": -1.9405129335216973, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Brickmasons, Blockmasons, Stonemasons, and Tile and Marble Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.1623899316545318, "y": -1.4061827741658093, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Truck and Tractor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.8146553091301973, "y": 0.2519135766899398, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction and Building Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.7877720885971908, "y": -1.0499626679285503, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting, Punching, and Press Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.5678870145431338, "y": 1.232994919006368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.8333851587986286, "y": 1.3225419622870052, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric and Space Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.917086462550661, "y": 1.1788730796609284, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.870607815023757, "y": 1.290068858679741, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 1.1621445111359745, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Directors, Religious Activities and Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-3.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.9100470331741998, "y": 0.0364102527508247, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthotists and Prosthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.549582894022315, "y": 1.290068858679741, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.6563552980344222, "y": -0.5008720069329966, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Farming, Fishing, and Forestry Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3922974939376122, "y": -0.8836610161216533, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Structure, Surfaces, Rigging, and Systems Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1956972048805025, "y": -0.8580761466128998, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pump Operators, Except Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.7188723580944468, "y": 0.9673058894923904, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Receptionists and Information Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.6559732566198974, "y": 0.6573353550594168, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compliance Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.9731805213137112, "y": -1.486873516462647, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.4115537158778558, "y": -0.7468803675940869, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Barbers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.2762382986028072, "y": 0.2076320717709436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Anesthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5306687829631038, "y": -1.144429878422409, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Machinery Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.0169977620024206, "y": 1.1355756081845765, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Technical Writers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.894622309351864, "y": -0.931878654811227, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.2155165824501373, "y": 0.3385085196426436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meeting, Convention, and Event Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.0464369491938291, "y": -0.7075190298883125, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hazardous Materials Removal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.7218942602992406, "y": -0.7596728023484637, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.6023736472329735, "y": -1.626606265318146, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Laborers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 0.0038309389872154, "y": -0.8462677453011674, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Installers and Repairers, Transportation Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.1514179239536149, "y": 1.352062965566336, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.438563742232027, "y": -1.014537463993353, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Merchandise Displayers and Window Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.7211382988891573, "y": 1.3156537281884946, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marriage and Family Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.6741424531705897, "y": 0.8659504449000215, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.0400367106015421, "y": 0.3089875163633128, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Desktop Publishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.5306538276477482, "y": 1.379615901960378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Management Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.0482384515239916, "y": -0.8275711098909247, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electric Motor, Power Tool, and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.2959987074785453, "y": -1.1808391158002502, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mobile Heavy Equipment Mechanics, Except Engines", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.3111711767115684, "y": -2.107798618771239, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Trainers and Group Fitness Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": 0.5097164017692816, "y": -0.1820451715162235, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.065549841268239, "y": -0.4821753715227538, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Makeup Artists, Theatrical and Performance", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.8260723631505726, "y": 1.185761313759439, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dispatchers, Except Police, Fire, and Ambulance", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.1464368897532982, "y": -0.921054286942139, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Print Binding and Finishing Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.7699093916046311, "y": 0.8393815419486237, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Music Directors and Composers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0236777409365872, "y": -0.3857400941436063, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2273720488599744, "y": 0.1180850284903067, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2612872430164695, "y": -0.7458963341514426, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.0402418835199054, "y": -1.417007142034897, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Massage Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.4516868248810886, "y": -0.3552350574216311, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletic Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.1054502388754892, "y": 0.5717244455493573, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.314238342840608, "y": -0.6356845885752741, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bartenders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.0876278336010032, "y": 1.0706294009700488, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telemarketers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.6774524291926896, "y": 0.2765144127560489, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Data Entry Keyers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.2124474289143454, "y": 1.3382864973693147, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.0277980723573438, "y": 1.080469735396492, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.2548064624972122, "y": 0.0324741189802472, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fire Inspectors and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.6368033312319524, "y": -0.9741920928449344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooling and Freezing Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.0184082093377855, "y": -1.925752431882032, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dining Room and Cafeteria Attendants and Bartender Helpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 0.4357097431058516, "y": 0.1377656973431939, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.045496651541581, "y": 0.949593287524792, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health and Safety Engineers, Except Mining Safety Engineers and Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.4025694848468618, "y": -1.622670131547569, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Floor, Ceiling, and Wall", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -0.6841921599322112, "y": 0.992890759001144, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.2695348951313973, "y": 0.1712228343931022, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Assistants, Clerical", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0422660961428759, "y": -0.2381350777469521, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Watch and Clock Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3540124704030162, "y": 0.2066480383282992, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forensic Science Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5777200704469947, "y": 0.5264589071877167, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hearing Aid Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.7048764560791582, "y": -1.7643709472883566, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rock Splitters, Quarry", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -1.1637615899672478, "y": 1.1660806449065515, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Property, Real Estate, and Community Association Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.8338399312873329, "y": 1.4189772396661524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.4282417280018922, "y": -0.0226317538078369, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 2.3664798768120976, "y": 1.23791508621959, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Proofreaders and Copy Markers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.6156410841929586, "y": -0.3719636259465853, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.5041814617212416, "y": -1.070627370224082, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.2747895742280462, "y": 0.4280555629232805, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Human Service Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.4239930589522561, "y": 0.9407369865409928, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Film and Video Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.2798001700417336, "y": 1.3530469990089804, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cargo and Freight Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.574501587778538, "y": 1.210362149825548, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical and Health Services Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.7290811173566742, "y": 1.2959730593356074, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Communications Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.0455712529, "y": 0.8944874147367078, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Producers and Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.1842021869879643, "y": 0.0472346206199126, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Counter and Rental Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 2.5187493896221773, "y": 0.3670454894793302, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Cage Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.0276743659096343, "y": 1.2300428186784351, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Title Examiners, Abstractors, and Searchers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.863599975464569, "y": -0.4811913380801094, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fish and Game Wardens", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8802520756486636, "y": -1.1198290423563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers, Farm, Ranch, and Aquacultural Animals", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.2048261572016251, "y": -1.1601744135047187, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.4210110569352954, "y": -1.5921650948255937, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painters, Construction and Maintenance", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 0.0932713927568725, "y": -0.5471215787372816, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ship Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8235694729289396, "y": 1.0971983039214463, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.17353522050073, "y": -0.3818039603730289, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0796191480762997, "y": -1.1326214771106766, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Light Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.6529288275583993, "y": 0.3640933891513971, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Traffic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.3864681686870737, "y": -0.3286661544702334, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electro-Mechanical and Mechatronics Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.5980359105672828, "y": 1.3235259957296497, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Administrative Law Judges, Adjudicators, and Hearing Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.6794706237786028, "y": -0.8974374843186743, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operating Engineers and Other Construction Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.5141610416358646, "y": 1.1267193072007773, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "New Accounts Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.1873026308664851, "y": -0.5914030836562778, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiovisual Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.816648081382791, "y": -1.103100473831346, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.0967578935314926, "y": -0.1190670311869843, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cardiovascular Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.5831949185341108, "y": -0.8836610161216533, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machinists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1309808706579929, "y": -0.6435568561164291, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Enforcement Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2902226819176425, "y": -0.1456359341383821, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parts Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.085384831815483, "y": 1.1444319091683757, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.6635636563599853, "y": 1.2477554206460335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation and Benefits Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.2913852991570329, "y": -1.3323802659674822, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.7476282021598943, "y": 0.6563513216167723, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropologists and Archeologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.059243035120383, "y": -0.7764013708734179, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food and Tobacco Roasting, Baking, and Drying Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.051413068811212, "y": -1.3225399315410384, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Upholsterers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 2.006967028695426, "y": -1.0499626679285503, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machine Feeders and Offbearers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.5665656501121378, "y": -0.9692719256317126, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Service Technicians and Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.1460597364692063, "y": -1.2083920521942926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furniture Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.7453540126887297, "y": -0.0806897269238543, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Set and Exhibit Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.3370913112158744, "y": -1.580356693513861, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Choreographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 0.2071361577794199, "y": -1.2349609551456904, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tile and Stone Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.239376988667188, "y": -0.6563492908708057, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Semiconductor Processing Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.3591321741120774, "y": -0.885629083006942, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Milling and Planing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.0586105006816206, "y": 0.9594336219512356, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.8245011596794236, "y": 1.3589511996648465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.73048476896969, "y": -0.4083728633244267, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.300758157626939, "y": -0.3985325288979831, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Passenger Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.9081771274176852, "y": 0.1958236704592112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Registered Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.8791403433824152, "y": -0.246007345288107, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatric Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.8515657525789402, "y": 0.5884530140743115, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Podiatrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.1327084593718657, "y": 1.114910905889045, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.1750027166854198, "y": -0.5402333446387712, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4994005675931286, "y": -0.80395430726746, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Private Household", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.3436469011677024, "y": -2.6568892797667925, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dancers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": -0.7336096555311683, "y": -1.1562382797341413, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.7596882588378406, "y": 1.2959730593356074, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mining and Geological Engineers, Including Mining Safety Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.8178909153404988, "y": -1.5478835899065972, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.2979090631898951, "y": -1.1916634836693385, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Body and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.018218168909433, "y": -1.2320088548177572, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Riggers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.9062866927436664, "y": 1.3048293603194068, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Law Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.4188227109715064, "y": 1.277276423925365, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Natural Sciences Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.3042871214464526, "y": 0.9830504245747004, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.290878095326021, "y": 1.0903100698229358, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.4063919049471256, "y": -0.5333451105402606, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.5933234946090281, "y": -0.0856098941370761, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hosts and Hostesses, Restaurant, Lounge, and Coffee Shop", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.3611622417453817, "y": -1.1759189485870287, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.1764881636946277, "y": -0.3690115256186522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locker Room, Coatroom, and Dressing Room Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.1420791956188615, "y": 0.7744353347340958, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cartographers and Photogrammetrists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -2.211084482938715, "y": 0.7134252612901454, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -2.1624961778599108, "y": 0.0856119248830428, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coaches and Scouts", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.241868951622614, "y": 0.9417210199836372, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bioengineers and Biomedical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.823949326841795, "y": 0.1141488947197292, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveyors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9243229638670988, "y": -0.0334561216769249, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Musicians and Singers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -1.0059177475619447, "y": 0.8128126389972259, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Concierges", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.3104448357507248, "y": 1.2556276881871886, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric, Earth, Marine, and Space Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3329546031290148, "y": 0.4664328671864106, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Optometrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.26618186397543, "y": -0.978128226615512, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.4730577743534532, "y": 0.4634807668584775, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Distributors and Dispatchers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -1.6915885036748526, "y": 1.0981823373640909, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Speech-Language Pathologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.0455510273001787, "y": -0.5904190502136335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crossing Guards and Flaggers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2632569270088317, "y": -0.4674148698830883, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Water and Wastewater Treatment Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.8681469156656431, "y": -0.7409761669382208, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coin, Vending, and Amusement Machine Servicers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.7141046559031947, "y": 1.2684201229415653, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.167345290078491, "y": -0.7488484344793757, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Embalmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.3794237378925805, "y": -1.555755857447752, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Repairers and Changers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 0.9276862719301904, "y": 1.3018772599914734, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Assistants, Except Payroll and Timekeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3021435467775782, "y": 0.8875991806381974, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.0831057227114354, "y": -1.0932601394049022, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Power-Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.6333753946233884, "y": 1.2280747517931463, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -2.158900354808966, "y": 0.083643857997754, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.309662260928632, "y": 0.4378958973497242, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Residential Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.605246646367264, "y": 0.5923891478448889, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Soil and Plant Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.4923189420113432, "y": -1.1326214771106766, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -2.515496216126499, "y": 0.8167487727678033, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm and Home Management Educators", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.7061652594245325, "y": 1.142463842283087, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.966928402936567, "y": 0.4880816029245866, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Self-Enrichment Teachers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.0330405899918561, "y": -1.2880987610484858, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Highway Maintenance Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.035633531816979, "y": -0.4693829367683771, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera Operators, Television, Video, and Film", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.5040729445567841, "y": 0.7065370271916348, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Private Detectives and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.3579826451892696, "y": 0.2499455098046511, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "File Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8251601318462432, "y": -1.421927309248119, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Derrick Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.495263346651427, "y": 0.4821774022687204, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Middle School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4041972330190037, "y": -0.153508201679537, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietetic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.2027900279704455, "y": -0.9928887282551772, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packaging and Filling Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.8344455712588192, "y": -1.7781474154853778, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cement Masons and Concrete Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -0.6456907883484053, "y": -1.8972154620453452, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 0.1525472155047861, "y": 1.156240310480108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Science Research Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.357833001150752, "y": -0.8344593439894351, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mail Clerks and Mail Machine Operators, Except Postal Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.831305637051771, "y": 0.8216689399810251, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.903586148685048, "y": 1.172968879005062, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architecture Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.6829849255522995, "y": 0.8620143111294439, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biochemists and Biophysicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.6957585989448415, "y": -0.7911618725130833, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rotary Drill Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.039521600990234, "y": -0.4880795721786199, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Railroad Conductors and Yardmasters", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.6279977976317257, "y": 1.2083940829402593, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.6336178723651176, "y": -1.8145566528632195, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletes and Sports Competitors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -1.5156404877988283, "y": -1.7171373420414275, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stonemasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.784849124549827, "y": 0.3660614560366858, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lodging Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0645099809696479, "y": 0.7803395353899619, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postmasters and Mail Superintendents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.3490846221331796, "y": 1.2940049924503183, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.7329707418306268, "y": -1.0361861997315291, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Cutting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.431197868553953, "y": -0.9387668889097376, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Vehicle Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.258792145634027, "y": 0.3286681852162, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Kindergarten Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.3522010999809421, "y": 0.0905320920962646, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.1682534016042961, "y": -0.4851274718506869, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Commercial and Industrial Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8065883038219844, "y": -0.9013736180892518, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.216428145739605, "y": 1.2349629858916569, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.3575349868723051, "y": -0.5530257793931478, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool and Die Makers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7167729479827766, "y": -0.7970660731689495, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.708627745846133, "y": 0.6957126593225469, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Curators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.3902994349745692, "y": 0.0324741189802472, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.4926879046390026, "y": 1.0942462035935132, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Hardware Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.1318236588890729, "y": -0.8895652167775194, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paper Goods Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.7393331967145719, "y": 0.8059244048987153, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Announcers and Radio Disc Jockeys", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2832544616050947, "y": -0.61895602005032, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.3397962075450541, "y": 1.265468022613632, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Non-Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.8470263264749203, "y": -0.30308128496148, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Phlebotomists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.2814149167083635, "y": -0.2164863420087762, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Morticians, Undertakers, and Funeral Arrangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.950720864558097, "y": 0.7793555019473175, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Except Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 1.0235324327245148, "y": -0.5382652777534824, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Machine Operators, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.5492638748310614, "y": 0.8807109465396868, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Specialties Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.9272564865352176, "y": 0.1574463661960811, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Practitioners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.2412894411645986, "y": 0.4477362317761678, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airfield Operations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.3578058544745672, "y": -0.8511879125143893, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.1102215023516521, "y": -1.231024821375113, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive and Watercraft Service Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.91533608373423, "y": 1.349110865238403, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Personal Financial Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.9078337914407992, "y": 1.3746957347471562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Survey Researchers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.4353281092151733, "y": 1.3225419622870052, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Astronomers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.6926076287342153, "y": -1.60495752957997, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers and Laborers, Crop, Nursery, and Greenhouse", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -1.4414645719719343, "y": 1.297941126220896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3181805863619124, "y": 0.6366706527638852, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Archivists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -2.1178775623218278, "y": 1.2339789524490126, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.339031438255265, "y": -0.5766425820166126, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Cooking Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.1547620111165768, "y": 0.1377656973431939, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9029821968790444, "y": -1.378629837771767, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graders and Sorters, Agricultural Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.530252107768302, "y": 0.7291697963724552, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Power Reactor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.7112473977081836, "y": -1.056850902027061, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Breeders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.1416328619647181, "y": -0.5461375452946373, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Amusement and Recreation Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2403621511881639, "y": 0.6228941845668642, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Appraisers, Auto Damage", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.4962195828573534, "y": 0.0078732829141382, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.6297127898630417, "y": -0.1712208036471355, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Agricultural Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.041821159923535, "y": 1.0598050331009603, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Door-to-Door Sales Workers, News and Street Vendors, and Related Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.1563745313464453, "y": 1.0165075616246086, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Transcriptionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.7657936659810389, "y": -0.050184690201879, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Mechanics, Installers, and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.8170171917173217, "y": -0.2401031446322408, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest Fire Inspectors and Prevention Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.825603154659069, "y": 1.1631285445786186, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Family and Consumer Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.1012183996439375, "y": -0.686854327592781, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Police and Sheriff's Patrol Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -2.0315493692647943, "y": 1.2959730593356074, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Work Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.9500126070376148, "y": -1.3284441321969047, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Firefighters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.5133841737460411, "y": 0.4713530343996325, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Production Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.5397937420842506, "y": -0.9043257184171848, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.3499771418862327, "y": 0.3168597839044677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronic Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.1751133363204995, "y": 1.3835520357309554, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -2.234502859592556, "y": 1.2585797885151215, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Area, Ethnic, and Cultural Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.0307483544837543, "y": 1.0863739360523583, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Travel Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.4170348398794407, "y": -0.4939837728344861, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lifeguards, Ski Patrol, and Other Recreational Protective Service Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.2511846601847043, "y": 0.9377848862130598, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Switchboard Operators, Including Answering Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.7616809491938787, "y": -0.7271996987411997, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Printing Press Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.829393248096743, "y": 0.6593034219447055, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2244066537133469, "y": -0.6593013911987389, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Etchers and Engravers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.542494518996816, "y": 1.2359470193343014, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Middle School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.303422390546166, "y": 0.6652076226005716, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Effects Artists and Animators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.7434467452373493, "y": 0.9692739563776792, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Legal Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.7795118833857506, "y": -0.7901778390704389, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.490619356336956, "y": 1.2930209590076744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.007965920450863, "y": -1.4317676436745626, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.510313007451929, "y": -0.8364274108747238, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mixing and Blending Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.9693925638889028, "y": -1.2812105269499754, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Baggage Porters and Bellhops", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.542157981149319, "y": -0.7724652371028404, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Conveyor Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2115773924288305, "y": 0.4634807668584775, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.4119883293005517, "y": -0.7596728023484637, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Restaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.9637436001218708, "y": 1.063741166871538, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interpreters and Translators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.0213769400310525, "y": 1.428817574092596, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Accountants and Auditors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.8018162111536116, "y": 0.3375244861999993, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Secondary School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.0025978082411178, "y": -1.4425920115436506, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Janitors and Cleaners, Except Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.5878393486504528, "y": -0.8974374843186743, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.3342983652234294, "y": 0.0560909216037119, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Retail Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4781211160618974, "y": 1.2438192868754565, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.0094680857194339, "y": 1.3884722029441774, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation, Benefits, and Job Analysis Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.017261433832303, "y": 0.7872277694884724, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 1.0261785206045886, "y": -0.2125502082381987, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Weighers, Measurers, Checkers, and Samplers, Recordkeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.491212452903623, "y": -0.5658182141475245, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Funeral Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 2.104487740229535, "y": 0.1938556035739225, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reservation and Transportation Ticket Agents and Travel Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.6551441048891751, "y": 1.2467713872033892, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interviewers, Except Eligibility and Loan", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.24460537513979, "y": -1.1040845072739902, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heat Treating Equipment Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.7060166036241945, "y": -1.7112331413855613, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laborers and Freight, Stock, and Material Movers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.312553366016794, "y": -1.2753063262941091, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Millwrights", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.0604357096249049, "y": -1.969049903358384, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reinforcing Iron and Rebar Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -0.0211954425738956, "y": -1.195599617439916, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paving, Surfacing, and Tamping Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.4046408042333749, "y": -0.5520417459505035, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Musical Instrument Repairers and Tuners", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.7012998338833971, "y": 0.0383783196361134, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Conservation Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.843344597993704, "y": 1.3668234672060011, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.4317398425565781, "y": 1.2064260160549705, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Securities, Commodities, and Financial Services Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.2142074841063902, "y": -0.5166165420153064, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Appliance Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8127455370190103, "y": -1.278258426622042, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Mechanical", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.0839652436131624, "y": 0.1928715701312782, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Detectives and Criminal Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.085513320787938, "y": 0.8472538094897786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.4688778344204163, "y": -0.21058214135291, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foresters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.0652880244734684, "y": 0.5412194088273821, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fashion Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.6097348416943514, "y": -0.605179551853299, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Housekeeping and Janitorial Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.3022061518374382, "y": -1.2516895236706445, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Knitting and Weaving Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.7769990599516138, "y": -1.3097474967866616, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Layers, Except Carpet, Wood, and Hard Tiles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.5151390195019657, "y": 1.2467713872033892, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.112458745665784, "y": 0.911215983261662, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Customer Service Representatives", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.4577354992478977, "y": 0.794116003586983, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Engineering Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.2624386301361847, "y": 1.022411762280475, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agents and Business Managers of Artists, Performers, and Athletes", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.6046577252228963, "y": 0.0551068881610675, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Medicine Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.6050495892236429, "y": -1.030281999075663, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dredge Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.8225645682725966, "y": 0.4654488337437663, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rehabilitation Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.3277182155559406, "y": -0.2676560810262829, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ushers, Lobby Attendants, and Ticket Takers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4359828423867974, "y": -0.1033224961046746, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinarians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4179236921718974, "y": -1.1336055105533211, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Models", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.824249414799414, "y": -1.235944988588335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Preparation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.0863152633726389, "y": 1.2782604573680088, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lawyers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.5945431108364287, "y": -0.5284249433270388, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Security Screeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.7461634106624586, "y": 1.1168789727743336, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation and Fitness Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Felten et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.3378245445497652, "y": 0.8236370068663138, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial and Industrial Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.463389018131386, "y": -0.5313770436549718, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bailiffs", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.1047929570056536, "y": -1.5459155230213084, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tapers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.4288688329142143, "y": -1.6334944994166565, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaners of Vehicles and Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 0.0639994512486199, "y": -1.7505944790913357, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Sanders and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 0.4099916757187356, "y": -1.395358406296721, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tank Car, Truck, and Ship Loaders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.3748166553039408, "y": -0.4989039400477079, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Log Graders and Scalers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.1948068060793332, "y": 1.4425940422896173, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judges, Magistrate Judges, and Magistrates", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 1.838514124045148, "y": -1.400278573509943, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Winding, Twisting, and Drawing Out Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.7266747538855354, "y": -1.235944988588335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pipelayers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.4850646824522794, "y": -1.1759189485870287, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Continuous Mining Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1267081165122968, "y": -0.2076300410249769, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dentists, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4539405695217607, "y": -0.2834006161085928, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.5458909643294669, "y": -0.5727064482460351, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Powerhouse, Substation, and Relay", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.0805537759406174, "y": -1.1572223131767856, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molding, Coremaking, and Casting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.5047140219008556, "y": 0.9771462239188342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.2651908544659347, "y": -0.8816929492363645, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locksmiths and Safe Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.0549010878820693, "y": -0.7094870967736012, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Compressor and Gas Pumping Station Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -2.063559437558738, "y": 1.3343503635987373, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Felten et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.428029598703468, "y": 1.190681480972661, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Claims and Policy Processing Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.5091934507281161, "y": -0.7636089361190411, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shipping, Receiving, and Inventory Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.3095442043451213, "y": -1.2172483531780918, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Equipment Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.5594525776157964, "y": -0.0108233524961046, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.1458552216044873, "y": -0.7311358325117772, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Fast Food", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.5530655594833603, "y": -1.7771633820427335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Terrazzo Workers and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 1.874106654568681, "y": -0.4024686626685605, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Batchmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0275386377194975, "y": 1.033236130149563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Felten et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3315311988631069, "y": -0.7606568357911081, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Multiple Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.0076408288069665, "y": -0.4506863013581342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Captains, Mates, and Pilots of Water Vessels", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4745016803652506, "y": 0.129893429802039, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthodontists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Felten et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.8305821343472589, "y": 1.3874881695015329, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Authorizers, Checkers, and Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.8207444276144482, "y": -0.6327324882473411, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.8917267046875949, "y": -0.7793534712013509, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Flight Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.399555731390285, "y": -0.4024686626685605, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motion Picture Projectionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.4012180288777832, "y": -1.1857592830134722, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sheet Metal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.7777302446432449, "y": -0.4064047964391379, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Childcare Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Felten et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.2601007592254225, "y": -1.3550130351483023, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Installation, Maintenance, and Repair Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Felten et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.989866693707687, "y": 0.6514311544035506, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Education Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Felten et al. rating": "0.7"}}], "size": 8.333333333333332, "fillColor": "rgb(2.0, 118.0, 124.0)", "strokeColor": "rgb(255.0, 255.0, 255.0)", "fillAlpha": 0.3, "strokeAlpha": 0.3, "marker": "M 0.0,-0.5 C 0.13260155,-0.5 0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C 0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 0.5,-0.13260155 0.5,0.0 C 0.5,0.13260155 0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C 0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 0.13260155,0.5 0.0,0.5 C -0.13260155,0.5 -0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 -0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C -0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 -0.5,0.13260155 -0.5,0.0 C -0.5,-0.13260155 -0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 -0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C -0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 -0.13260155,-0.5 0.0,-0.5 Z 0.0,-0.5", "isFilled": true}, {"type": "line", "color": "#034752", "zOrder": 2, "strokeWidth": 2.25, "lineStyle": "-", "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 0.890640740344428}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": 0.8714754119028515}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": 0.8523100834612751}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": 0.8331447550196986}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": 0.8139794265781224}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": 0.794814098136546}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": 0.7756487696949697}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": 0.7564834412533933}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": 0.7373181128118168}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": 0.7181527843702404}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": 0.6989874559286641}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": 0.6798221274870877}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": 0.6606567990455114}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": 0.641491470603935}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": 0.6223261421623586}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": 0.6031608137207822}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": 0.5839954852792059}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": 0.5648301568376296}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": 0.5456648283960531}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": 0.5264994999544768}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": 0.5073341715129004}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": 0.488168843071324}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": 0.46900351462974754}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": 0.4498381861881712}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": 0.4306728577465949}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": 0.41150752930501844}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": 0.39234220086344207}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": 0.37317687242186576}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": 0.35401154398028933}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": 0.33484621553871297}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": 0.31568088709713654}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": 0.29651555865556023}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": 0.27735023021398386}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": 0.25818490177240744}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": 0.23901957333083113}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": 0.2198542448892547}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": 0.20068891644767833}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": 0.1815235880061019}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": 0.16235825956452554}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": 0.14319293112294912}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": 0.12402760268137289}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": 0.1048622742397965}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": 0.0856969457982201}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": 0.0665316173566437}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": 0.04736628891506728}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": 0.028200960473490883}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": 0.009035632031914487}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.010129696409661756}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.029295024851238152}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.04846035329281455}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.06762568173439094}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.08679101017596734}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.10595633861754374}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": -0.12512166705912015}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": -0.1442869955006964}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": -0.16345232394227277}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": -0.1826176523838492}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": -0.20178298082542556}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": -0.22094830926700199}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": -0.24011363770857835}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": -0.2592789661501548}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": -0.27844429459173103}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": -0.2976096230333074}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": -0.3167749514748838}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": -0.33594027991646025}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": -0.3551056083580366}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": -0.374270936799613}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": -0.39343626524118924}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": -0.41260159368276567}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": -0.43176692212434203}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": -0.45093225056591846}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": -0.4700975790074948}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": -0.48926290744907125}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": -0.5084282358906476}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": -0.527593564332224}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": -0.5467588927738004}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": -0.5659242212153768}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": -0.5850895496569533}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": -0.6042548780985296}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": -0.6234202065401058}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": -0.6425855349816821}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": -0.6617508634232585}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": -0.6809161918648349}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": -0.7000815203064114}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": -0.7192468487479877}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": -0.7384121771895641}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": -0.7575775056311405}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": -0.7767428340727169}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": -0.7959081625142933}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": -0.8150734909558697}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": -0.834238819397446}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": -0.8534041478390225}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": -0.8725694762805989}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": -0.891734804722175}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": -0.9109001331637514}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": -0.9300654616053278}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": -0.9492307900469041}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": -0.9683961184884806}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": -0.987561446930057}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": -1.0067267753716331}]}, {"type": "polygon", "color": "rgb(3.0, 71.0, 82.0)", "alpha": 0.15, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 1.090137279663768}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 0.6875344879151741}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": 0.6713481758792933}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": 0.6555332301964285}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": 0.6410809900173976}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": 0.6266287498383668}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": 0.6096127618439771}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": 0.5922930040144667}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": 0.5749732461849565}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": 0.5587260379814545}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": 0.5430421868493068}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": 0.5273660678933003}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": 0.5120008041244802}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": 0.4977615943684081}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": 0.48157854188243093}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": 0.46615614796365235}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": 0.4510603922954012}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": 0.43478069899092703}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": 0.41850100568645304}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": 0.40222131238197895}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": 0.386331168975503}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": 0.36962902556572075}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": 0.3526626155531205}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": 0.33557122821270036}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": 0.3184596837535991}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": 0.3028432570874574}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": 0.2866205736050799}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": 0.269129822418967}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": 0.25318826048840426}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": 0.23798228514958158}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": 0.22296836653457447}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": 0.20722407643672208}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": 0.19187044876898843}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": 0.1765168211012547}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": 0.16061441591066303}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": 0.1431947236333984}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": 0.12675665061867739}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": 0.11289585541339987}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": 0.09579583237854929}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": 0.07822304310577338}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": 0.060582779654056694}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": 0.043924704862824696}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": 0.027392736068058168}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": 0.009068300963512762}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": -0.010008415821111945}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": -0.027717244844268067}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": -0.0455287454794573}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": -0.06392230827314821}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": -0.08464250929605814}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": -0.10416438065846109}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": -0.1235109364074579}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.1435726846955083}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.16403534253958782}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.18374556998659744}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": -0.2038779894774529}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": -0.22451623410509852}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": -0.24477885874963565}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": -0.2655342024994905}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": -0.2863002615747344}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": -0.3070601831257983}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": -0.3275964543902461}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": -0.3481472597734828}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": -0.36931802054105295}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": -0.39024160392623974}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": -0.41113137142028094}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": -0.4325603041512582}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": -0.4535698275351315}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": -0.4742853330721652}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": -0.4965004217997994}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": -0.5176399052018439}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": -0.5411727699629277}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": -0.5638313142376151}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": -0.5872091244615762}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": -0.6089540260968865}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": -0.6312901204926761}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": -0.6539086029761066}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": -0.676502197331074}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": -0.699098370304781}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": -0.7216790576528219}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": -0.7442597450008627}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": -0.7668404323489033}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": -0.7893201298408519}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": -0.8113924384632986}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": -0.8343089260672558}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": -0.8572134772192087}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": -0.8807452032801057}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": -0.9040093525884305}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": -0.9278029373866482}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": -0.9519640164656681}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": -0.9760713535575137}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": -1.0001529600080692}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": -1.0242345664586245}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": -1.04831617290918}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": -1.0718200220394716}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": -1.0942580659194763}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": -1.1166406068897952}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": -1.1390231478601138}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": -1.1614056888304327}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": -1.1837882298007516}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": -1.2060166627188735}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": -1.2285752039030706}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": -0.8008403544587476}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": -0.8008403544587476}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": -0.7846844963100578}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": -0.768546389737004}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": -0.75240828316395}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": -0.7362701765908962}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": -0.7203392887967487}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": -0.7038918896978844}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": -0.6879210480202009}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": -0.6727888119605677}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": -0.6576565759009345}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": -0.6425472182751849}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": -0.6274386770870906}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": -0.6123301358989961}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": -0.5972215947109016}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": -0.5819542337469518}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": -0.5658119863624986}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": -0.5496697389780455}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": -0.5335274915935923}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": -0.5181178398646878}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": -0.502854463457319}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": -0.487656424188533}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": -0.4722996377559833}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": -0.4565262432239055}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": -0.44071248315303346}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": -0.4244518493603711}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": -0.40927114959956873}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": -0.39350548712935207}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": -0.37752962957390274}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": -0.36101074640437103}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": -0.3458392862984078}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": -0.3302348290174044}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": -0.31396080712179836}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": -0.29809875796319213}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": -0.28133981718461865}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": -0.2656732860993475}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": -0.24915224516840895}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": -0.23243146584477709}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": -0.21744211517090736}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": -0.20026719340332372}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": -0.1839030414755108}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": -0.16717202400807693}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": -0.14998181796660756}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": -0.13341755434036892}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": -0.11531691143157435}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": -0.09578030147125238}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": -0.07739080611310811}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": -0.05755715363559249}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": -0.03842239124532869}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": -0.02042462834137991}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": -0.0017662992109261605}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": 0.017720500487112868}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": 0.03722093647681726}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": 0.05668074031980806}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": 0.07796800267181021}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": 0.09777780037439893}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": 0.11757688708947123}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": 0.13906854046912595}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": 0.1581864848923413}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": 0.17922087151551996}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": 0.20085273716912744}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": 0.2206883225981602}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": 0.24052500653436132}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": 0.26265898925699965}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": 0.28445813735138537}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": 0.30619579200518104}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": 0.3275255979565678}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": 0.34969149659329263}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": 0.3714947676991765}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": 0.3932433464464022}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": 0.4149755494761784}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": 0.43728930211472267}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": 0.4597006273258745}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": 0.48208019257444895}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": 0.5040994148051219}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": 0.5257777295830881}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": 0.5474251098659086}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": 0.568937717139466}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": 0.5927532353803935}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": 0.6164798316616196}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": 0.6388822538561361}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": 0.6612624899754409}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": 0.6837857678206863}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": 0.7071675307382906}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": 0.7294644822420115}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": 0.7534025823532603}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": 0.7773335447428166}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": 0.8012279811109599}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": 0.8235698067045135}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": 0.8457925187908892}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": 0.8679552347128989}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": 0.8918062183541128}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": 0.9131449841440924}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": 0.9345610564360644}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": 0.956787283923375}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": 0.9790135114106855}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": 1.0012397388979961}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": 1.0234659663853063}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": 1.045692193872617}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": 1.0679184213599275}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 1.090137279663768}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 1.090137279663768}], "closed": true}, {"type": "text", "color": "grey", "zOrder": 3, "text": "R\u00b2=0.11", "x": 0.08, "y": 0.87, "ha": "left", "va": "baseline", "rotation": 0.0, "rotationMode": "default", "background": true, "fontSizeScaling": 1, "textCoords": "paper-normalized"}], "hud": [], "originalDataAspectRatio": 0.7451612903225805, "additionalLegendItems": []} {"downloadButtonPosition": "none"}

{"title": "Comparison of automatability measures across occupations", "xAxis": {"label": "Autor et al.", "lim": [-3.4465900025433047, 3.0697599100120265], "scaleType": "linear"}, "yAxis": {"label": "Webb", "lim": [-1.7908382833004, 5.107065838575363], "scaleType": "linear"}, "showFrame": true, "objects": [{"type": "scatter", "alpha": 0.3, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -1.3879757172393794, "y": 1.2876183986663818, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hydrologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.8738669794255672, "y": 1.4662320613861084, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Inspectors, Testers, Sorters, Samplers, and Weighers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.1666628024119154, "y": 0.1982245445251464, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fine Artists, Including Painters, Sculptors, and Illustrators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.7804981301768894, "y": -0.8371097445487976, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.8795861299816146, "y": 0.8091672658920288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Construction Trades and Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.7687729425831287, "y": -1.202638864517212, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Interviewers and Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.6629131000636508, "y": 0.8830190896987915, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marketing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.12378193496383, "y": -0.2564148008823395, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.9277204053432249, "y": -1.4008084535598757, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.398356520939802, "y": -0.969524621963501, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manufactured Building and Mobile Home Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.9061688817454226, "y": 0.1849522888660431, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Child, Family, and School Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.229972685882886, "y": 1.9298851490020752, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -1.7812259575544531, "y": -0.6164747476577759, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chief Executives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0039331134124508, "y": -0.494787722826004, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Pipelayers, Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.859323689241689, "y": -0.4709172248840332, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Change Persons and Booth Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.557483831077505, "y": 1.214518904685974, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1412240429044082, "y": 2.961719274520874, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graphic Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "3.0"}}, {"x": -0.1029408398799553, "y": -0.2296561896800995, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Opticians, Dispensing", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.4607253338358603, "y": -0.4324628710746765, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "General and Operations Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.207129400606792, "y": 0.5402300953865051, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3411191413364209, "y": 0.8321566581726074, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Pilots", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 1.7633323806856949, "y": 0.6937249898910522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Subway and Streetcar Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.7317018320835897, "y": 1.4278419017791748, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security Guards", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.2438311053934494, "y": 1.296951413154602, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crane and Tower Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.1090292074789271, "y": -0.3505658507347107, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sailors and Marine Oilers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.1597849936475773, "y": 4.122325420379639, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locomotive Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "4.1"}}, {"x": -0.4002584839064506, "y": -0.973047137260437, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.5337725316665024, "y": -0.7821188569068909, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brickmasons and Blockmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2162911735904329, "y": 1.5153653621673584, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.2775952412045133, "y": 2.5283002853393555, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "2.5"}}, {"x": 1.4105844317226746, "y": 1.455442190170288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool Grinders, Filers, and Sharpeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.996340114497679, "y": 1.4786360263824463, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Healthcare Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.0353559581581828, "y": -0.0074338032864034, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Preschool Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.2406121254605465, "y": -1.200682520866394, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Painters, Paperhangers, Plasterers, and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.8204565641037875, "y": -0.8459379076957703, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Sorters, Processors, and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.067303770014071, "y": -0.2016211748123169, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Procurement Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.2588012909362202, "y": -0.3633562922477722, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roustabouts, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2291720398343169, "y": -1.2835232019424438, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hotel, Motel, and Resort Desk Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -1.2592578673812185, "y": 1.1375255584716797, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.272530239671472, "y": -0.777947187423706, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.9906848123176468, "y": -0.4799837172031402, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Community Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.6730993274418786, "y": -0.5115841031074524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bicycle Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.7660536591214124, "y": 0.3885177671909332, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interior Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.9199418254306408, "y": -0.9711437821388244, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Business Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.1984900413932157, "y": 0.4920348823070526, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painting, Coating, and Decorating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.9651727034022022, "y": 3.205718278884888, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "3.2"}}, {"x": 1.8678163958494096, "y": -1.3204567432403564, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling and Sports Book Writers and Runners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.4775046840042845, "y": 2.926727771759033, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Bleaching and Dyeing Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "2.9"}}, {"x": -0.4376365754218905, "y": -0.124774657189846, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Museum Technicians and Conservators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0188198127948211, "y": -0.9584259390830994, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemistry Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.4865439553846576, "y": 0.5418540835380554, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Forming Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Synthetic and Glass Fibers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3192931547383277, "y": 2.172159433364868, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Production and Operating Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "2.2"}}, {"x": 0.0949537063416281, "y": 0.2603830099105835, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Respiratory Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.458285251111881, "y": 0.1477905511856079, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.8988100277128837, "y": -1.2552814483642578, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shampooers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.6273322601296695, "y": 0.4975526332855224, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Door Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3180282187359726, "y": -1.339053750038147, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Demonstrators and Product Promoters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.8718361075941772, "y": 1.3607009649276731, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education and Childcare Administrators, Preschool and Daycare", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.4527867458282585, "y": -0.3105336129665375, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpet Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.1743689098151666, "y": 0.33954918384552, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Builders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.35719352361029, "y": 0.9214102625846864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Correctional Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -1.3878560374962543, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.6176510641006632, "y": -1.1560527086257937, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Slaughterers and Meat Packers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.8794611907585571, "y": -0.0814079418778419, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer and Information Systems Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0028291672137524, "y": 0.5681948065757751, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stationary Engineers and Boiler Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9905780385848506, "y": -1.2745198011398315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.7406839953693914, "y": -0.0715669766068458, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tree Trimmers and Pruners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.9380037429031493, "y": -1.4374282360076904, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judicial Law Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.8778901879268389, "y": -1.0054879188537598, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meter Readers, Utilities", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.146188611016774, "y": -1.2310255765914917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dishwashers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.8317415685275095, "y": -0.9903486967086792, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Glass Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.1745555230932532, "y": 1.359336256980896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pesticide Handlers, Sprayers, and Applicators, Vegetation", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -2.651248398474005, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forestry and Conservation Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.7", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.0558322850299701, "y": 1.1196948289871216, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Glaziers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.4950131724181174, "y": -0.3154909312725067, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Craft Artists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.26970421220172, "y": -1.1584731340408323, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Clergy", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.036151212776815, "y": -1.4289672374725342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "History Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.7819185045085033, "y": 0.2711822092533111, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Air Traffic Controllers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6262646108388754, "y": 3.0668787956237797, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pest Control Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "3.1"}}, {"x": -0.6170505642570706, "y": -0.1020994335412979, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.5201602731015502, "y": 2.225879669189453, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "2.2"}}, {"x": -2.1096742408509983, "y": 2.9285671710968018, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Webb rating": "2.9"}}, {"x": -1.6366551142657275, "y": -0.3507683873176574, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Community Health Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.5470181213201686, "y": -0.3491899967193603, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meat, Poultry, and Fish Cutters and Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.9388818956190284, "y": -0.5104534029960632, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floral Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8801617726657183, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematical Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.2491564480854882, "y": -0.3377112150192261, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Layout Workers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.136975723495231, "y": -0.5371946096420288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Production Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.6790061859797019, "y": 0.2446281462907791, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refractory Materials Repairers, Except Brickmasons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7819356456226125, "y": 1.1538985967636108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paralegals and Legal Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.5563316338766712, "y": 1.899639129638672, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Solar Photovoltaic Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 0.5764248510627038, "y": 1.498599410057068, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hoist and Winch Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.4951107921040945, "y": -0.5016852617263794, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Servers, Nonrestaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.096748042827857, "y": 0.1159393787384033, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foundry Mold and Coremakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3169447298842093, "y": -0.5758563280105591, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Licensed Practical and Licensed Vocational Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.8427647104734115, "y": -0.282840758562088, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Service Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.7979287796407275, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.4174885121922616, "y": 0.2925939559936523, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding, Forming, Pressing, and Compacting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.6001567912318234, "y": 0.4880213141441345, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Surveillance Officers and Gambling Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.332257858369244, "y": -0.0743627697229385, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.8628367773058664, "y": 3.459745168685913, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Safety Telecommunicators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "3.5"}}, {"x": -0.9253881581355786, "y": 0.1109080836176872, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adult Basic Education, Adult Secondary Education, and English as a Second Language Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.115542120743649, "y": 0.600615918636322, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security and Fire Alarm Systems Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.8478630448741451, "y": 1.089930772781372, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plating Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.6955245225744036, "y": -0.3127142190933227, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Police and Detectives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -2.107337904574303, "y": 1.6821640729904177, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Emergency Management Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Webb rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -1.459045469791104, "y": -0.054152712225914, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5133653075622094, "y": -0.8828815221786499, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hairdressers, Hairstylists, and Cosmetologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.899884285005504, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engineering Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.9096847130366288, "y": 1.4614629745483398, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Woodworking Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Except Sawing", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.9450373452170504, "y": -1.323333501815796, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nursing Instructors and Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.260815125874153, "y": -0.7367566227912903, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Diagnostic Medical Sonographers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.6058133203748001, "y": 0.4369877576828003, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Outdoor Power Equipment and Other Small Engine Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.1802755546079249, "y": 0.452518105506897, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer, Automated Teller, and Office Machine Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 2.308011656461644, "y": -1.2228686809539795, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "2.3", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.7917310476663457, "y": 2.59487533569336, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "2.6"}}, {"x": -0.8851386916400845, "y": -0.3831574916839599, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.8311679997784562, "y": -1.0616289377212524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.1859608627599854, "y": 1.3665379285812378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fabric and Apparel Patternmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.6235878556784445, "y": 1.5542209148406982, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Yard Engineers, Dinkey Operators, and Hostlers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.6608103499457694, "y": 0.0509225763380527, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.1576690232763411, "y": 1.104072093963623, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Zoologists and Wildlife Biologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.2758731672301599, "y": 1.2347958087921145, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sound Engineering Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.3103914296664506, "y": 0.839514970779419, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chefs and Head Cooks", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.1052002908318708, "y": -1.0351965427398682, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorcycle Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.3456587931753214, "y": -0.5314925909042358, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiation Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.1662019129923107, "y": -0.2383814752101898, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.4470366621020035, "y": 0.329603374004364, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronic Equipment Installers and Repairers, Motor Vehicles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.6354002347736443, "y": 1.1052827835083008, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Arbitrators, Mediators, and Conciliators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -2.330784055904513, "y": -0.4070198535919189, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Educational, Guidance, and Career Counselors and Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.793744986464031, "y": 0.4554865658283233, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Home Appliance Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.49820798587486, "y": 1.3015083074569702, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographic Process Workers and Processing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.8579685140459804, "y": 1.5894851684570312, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packers and Packagers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 1.0183809588051669, "y": -0.2789682149887085, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutters and Trimmers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.2795218700990303, "y": 0.0108952354639768, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.2623391526162582, "y": 1.2663359642028809, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statistical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.0628692390837011, "y": -0.9391167759895324, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscaping and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.3089559447421135, "y": 0.1489406377077102, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cashiers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.360155271736588, "y": 1.5240012407302856, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding, Lapping, Polishing, and Buffing Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.5396079321446071, "y": 0.0052457656711339, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Examiners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.9669829948160152, "y": 1.1418261528015137, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rolling Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.5710404730541805, "y": 1.28401780128479, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Equipment Installers and Repairers, Except Line Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.184724227600342, "y": -0.3483976423740387, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radio, Cellular, and Tower Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.1645226637058472, "y": -0.940859317779541, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe and Leather Workers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.7711931576309774, "y": 1.6107615232467651, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Assistants and Laboratory Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.3926167440556287, "y": 0.8986139893531799, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architects, Except Landscape and Naval", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.6267937654755713, "y": -0.7851523756980896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Clerks, General", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.1586119749940411, "y": -0.6805702447891235, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.504803091190655, "y": -0.824661910533905, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.008514111373503, "y": 0.1648528575897216, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Physiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -2.5673369967257145, "y": 0.9978390336036682, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Urban and Regional Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.6", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.4838150007725963, "y": -0.9093065857887268, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coil Winders, Tapers, and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.3646337058614783, "y": 0.7706374526023865, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pile Driver Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.413652326235589, "y": 4.472823143005371, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineering and Operations Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "4.5"}}, {"x": -0.7115386799945627, "y": 0.872532308101654, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cost Estimators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.5943329550635068, "y": 0.057984571903944, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Septic Tank Servicers and Sewer Pipe Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.5305181232195075, "y": -0.5092512369155884, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tellers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4865023643391553, "y": -0.5338327288627625, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising and Promotions Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.9498596825735608, "y": 0.5768417119979858, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Kindergarten through Secondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.349270017361749, "y": 3.3195033073425293, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "3.3"}}, {"x": 0.2870916936583988, "y": 1.9709841012954712, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logging Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": 0.3979925945108996, "y": 1.4627131223678589, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Microbiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.261215927667404, "y": 1.0655864477157593, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Labor Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.2959256040461369, "y": 1.3053697347640991, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.2173345606272563, "y": 0.344615638256073, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Midwives", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.3419903257028654, "y": 0.1718896031379699, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.2322879970452644, "y": 1.14995014667511, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Costume Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.0367234606969555, "y": 0.4324362576007843, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Laboratory Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.096593567122127, "y": -0.2354460507631302, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Iron and Steel Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.2426924043436363, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art, Drama, and Music Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.1027259585525155, "y": 0.2639955282211303, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.255497013586391, "y": 1.416895031929016, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Service Unit Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.1435896306415737, "y": 0.569434404373169, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airline Pilots, Copilots, and Flight Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.5207884919746754, "y": 0.2845753729343414, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.0421236179435285, "y": 3.1343705654144287, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Scientists and Specialists, Including Health", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "3.1"}}, {"x": 1.855060775139609, "y": -1.343291997909546, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Carriers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.7172717451093302, "y": -1.0055814981460571, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Word Processors and Typists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.427905954618115, "y": 2.279242038726806, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elevator and Escalator Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": 0.3883263612610775, "y": -0.8560171127319336, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.1326045094331685, "y": 1.62578284740448, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscape Architects", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.3331083471176046, "y": 0.2976422011852264, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transit and Railroad Police", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5689573020554451, "y": -0.2149727940559387, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.3988620055019044, "y": -1.1176437139511108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Labor Contractors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.878637112989117, "y": -0.6424422264099121, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Eligibility Interviewers, Government Programs", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.716245025559664, "y": -0.3896723985671997, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Metal-Refining Furnace Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.1153503650067896, "y": 0.7784073948860168, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Scientists, Except Epidemiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.7545121597708432, "y": -0.8718255758285522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engine and Other Machine Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.2055050168889151, "y": -0.2854416668415069, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Umpires, Referees, and Other Sports Officials", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.8269838306805912, "y": -1.1743179559707642, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Short Order", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.3355795054575677, "y": -0.9285557866096495, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pourers and Casters, Metal", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.6896623194547988, "y": 1.4972593784332275, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tailors, Dressmakers, and Custom Sewers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.9269442287740294, "y": 0.5064203143119812, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drilling and Boring Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2503349809478545, "y": 0.3772245049476623, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Separating, Filtering, Clarifying, Precipitating, and Still Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.805608689891823, "y": 1.5624560117721558, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forging Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.0452772118071618, "y": -0.3385097086429596, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operations Research Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.7843564994601844, "y": -0.0282154530286788, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fundraisers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.0931249019367593, "y": -0.3598070740699768, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding and Polishing Workers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.3974472910211182, "y": -0.1555326282978058, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lathe and Turning Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.275127175318862, "y": -0.5214505195617676, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Scientists and Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.1035045259606848, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Philosophy and Religion Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.6177573881765728, "y": -0.6199275255203247, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Driver/Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.860101367472801, "y": 0.1564266830682754, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5952167662256497, "y": -0.3429822325706482, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail-Track Laying and Maintenance Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.4106782716026849, "y": -1.2872755527496338, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correspondence Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.9979158190254164, "y": 0.6087693572044373, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.168257496434765, "y": -0.3832985162734985, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Control and Valve Installers and Repairers, Except Mechanical Door", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -2.3887831446158225, "y": 0.6580925583839417, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.4", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.0183989055691776, "y": 1.6947600841522217, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.8167005964033244, "y": 0.7274108529090881, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiologic Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.3756481511626501, "y": -0.7988975644111633, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Avionics Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.601366659204723, "y": -0.9020010828971864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ambulance Drivers and Attendants, Except Emergency Medical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.8997798001241091, "y": -1.1565536260604858, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Historians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.2864419155115894, "y": 0.9573086500167848, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adhesive Bonding Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.8575731168305705, "y": 0.3756090402603149, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laundry and Dry-Cleaning Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.3439734260570267, "y": -0.2479270994663238, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.043337764227231, "y": 1.315790772438049, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -2.1191467593298605, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "English Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.1456937718268784, "y": 1.023534893989563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Underwriters", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -2.2678319184750424, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.961096082230804, "y": -1.005603551864624, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Waiters and Waitresses", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3626576043666109, "y": -1.1547913551330566, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Order Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.3409863554482197, "y": -0.4563503563404083, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paperhangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.543237498245881, "y": -0.6953675150871277, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pressers, Textile, Garment, and Related Materials", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.7579204616488344, "y": 1.0153106451034546, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronics Engineers, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.9822806035794333, "y": 2.278801441192627, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Prepress Technicians and Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": 1.4989676451123788, "y": -0.5115807056427002, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brokerage Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -2.00606003700463, "y": -1.3886513710021973, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foreign Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.0654027329048016, "y": -1.0762602090835571, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fence Erectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.5333638512536465, "y": -0.6239122748374939, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Divers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.5597607197091468, "y": -0.8869561553001404, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Drafters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1702958363252753, "y": -0.2234078794717788, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chiropractors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.275963820611964, "y": -0.4997689723968506, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest and Conservation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.6229718502009335, "y": 0.1583521515130996, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drywall and Ceiling Tile Installers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.5084109052552163, "y": 0.7135089039802551, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Butchers and Meat Cutters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.5791583819927179, "y": 0.5957820415496826, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance Workers, Machinery", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.7576292009047862, "y": 0.5388038754463196, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial-Organizational Psychologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -1.873748106549436, "y": -0.5148057341575623, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Instructional Coordinators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.6283372102046054, "y": 0.50825035572052, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Metal Fabricators and Fitters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.1113836504282495, "y": -0.9639350771903992, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bill and Account Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3625311479896964, "y": -0.9189525246620178, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Couriers and Messengers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.8611705519922842, "y": 2.420750141143799, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bridge and Lock Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "2.4"}}, {"x": 0.2038056414528196, "y": -0.7491996884346008, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cabinetmakers and Bench Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.5173509320945054, "y": -0.7553990483283997, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surgical Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2121641423044445, "y": 0.6887238621711731, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crushing, Grinding, and Polishing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.4287701686383378, "y": -1.0839518308639526, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Signal and Track Switch Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -1.6814896517281743, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropology and Archeology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -1.173473636669783, "y": 0.1858296394348144, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietitians and Nutritionists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3942567266559647, "y": 0.8715807795524597, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.4391685872432179, "y": -0.6630367636680603, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fallers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.4476966830581191, "y": -0.142054945230484, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welding, Soldering, and Brazing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2733249177323729, "y": 2.021474838256836, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaning, Washing, and Metal Pickling Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.5249279594054749, "y": 0.08238285779953, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Car Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3776478305970298, "y": -0.9888576865196228, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.7206932847569244, "y": 1.87010657787323, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furnace, Kiln, Oven, Drier, and Kettle Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 0.5596459401413999, "y": -0.173828899860382, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audio and Video Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.842045453577487, "y": -0.447874367237091, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Examiners and Collectors, and Revenue Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.3938952542378198, "y": 2.862600326538086, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "2.9"}}, {"x": -0.517268926304522, "y": -0.4445480704307556, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correctional Officers and Jailers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.0319613075533194, "y": -0.5902681946754456, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plasterers and Stucco Masons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.7285894926632013, "y": 0.7937850952148438, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geoscientists, Except Hydrologists and Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.564049581303414, "y": -1.081901788711548, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.6736007874983986, "y": 0.4889840483665466, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance and Repair Workers, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.979860085336681, "y": -0.3151290416717529, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.3561213822478264, "y": 2.024324893951416, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actuaries", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -1.0744809961151065, "y": 0.0724497288465499, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Brokers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.9527003673193264, "y": 0.7323271632194519, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.7477243545871888, "y": -0.5856667757034302, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Purchasing Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.6000761800414834, "y": -0.6198521256446838, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Genetic Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.4258112577101307, "y": 0.30514657497406, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Drawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.941582977348845, "y": -0.7005224823951721, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physician Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": -0.0199662055820226, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telephone Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "2.8", "Webb rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.2105395982479372, "y": 0.5312028527259827, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting and Slicing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 2.113268072214425, "y": -0.214054137468338, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Dealers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1356029499591191, "y": 0.5188261270523071, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Institution and Cafeteria", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3487615050458227, "y": -0.6308088302612305, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Probation Officers and Correctional Treatment Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.270680593235209, "y": 1.2477128505706787, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.3911799612513187, "y": -0.1165905818343162, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Landscaping, Lawn Service, and Groundskeeping Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.5494797868144166, "y": 0.2448470145463943, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wind Turbine Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.472712350022055, "y": 4.315295219421387, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "4.3"}}, {"x": 0.7761718702554996, "y": 0.1517483592033386, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refuse and Recyclable Material Collectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7769366037314608, "y": -1.142888426780701, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.5194640396300716, "y": -1.0965399742126465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manicurists and Pedicurists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.3842542364284055, "y": 0.7202642560005188, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera and Photographic Equipment Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -2.092558237933194, "y": -0.3741219341754913, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.7413174128753748, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geography Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.5816629934821564, "y": 0.7484022378921509, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Skincare Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.1071197858238884, "y": 1.22503662109375, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.2758565602456502, "y": -0.3159935772418976, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.4599543797063599, "y": -0.1410174965858459, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Pump System Operators, Refinery Operators, and Gaugers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0582176742081917, "y": -0.6536405086517334, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Boilermakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.764086569407202, "y": 0.3108892142772674, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.6043578751229657, "y": -0.6235646605491638, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Budget Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.2744437195026044, "y": -0.8502292633056641, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Brickmasons, Blockmasons, Stonemasons, and Tile and Marble Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1623899316545318, "y": 0.4134857654571533, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Truck and Tractor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.8146553091301973, "y": 2.548095464706421, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction and Building Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "2.5"}}, {"x": 0.7877720885971908, "y": 0.7534106373786926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting, Punching, and Press Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.5678870145431338, "y": 0.7627414464950562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.8333851587986286, "y": 2.3468382358551025, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric and Space Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": -1.917086462550661, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.870607815023757, "y": 4.507232666015625, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "4.5"}}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 0.3811751306056976, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Directors, Religious Activities and Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-3.2", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.9100470331741998, "y": 1.2331578731536863, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthotists and Prosthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.549582894022315, "y": -0.239827275276184, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.3922974939376122, "y": 1.96989107131958, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Structure, Surfaces, Rigging, and Systems Assemblers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.1956972048805025, "y": 0.2160421460866928, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pump Operators, Except Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7188723580944468, "y": 0.2950997948646545, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Receptionists and Information Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.9731805213137112, "y": -1.116658329963684, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.4115537158778558, "y": -1.2440204620361328, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Barbers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.2762382986028072, "y": 0.1142607778310775, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Anesthetists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5306687829631038, "y": 0.6329968571662903, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Machinery Mechanics", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.0169977620024206, "y": 0.7286354303359985, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Technical Writers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.894622309351864, "y": 0.7690650820732117, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.2155165824501373, "y": 1.1456413269042969, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meeting, Convention, and Event Planners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.0464369491938291, "y": -0.5596664547920227, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hazardous Materials Removal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.7218942602992406, "y": 1.01254141330719, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.6023736472329735, "y": 0.3768096268177032, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Laborers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.0038309389872154, "y": -0.2423723042011261, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Installers and Repairers, Transportation Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.1514179239536149, "y": -0.1043700948357582, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.438563742232027, "y": 0.4522501528263092, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Merchandise Displayers and Window Trimmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -1.7211382988891573, "y": -0.0785006433725357, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marriage and Family Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.0400367106015421, "y": 0.6075287461280823, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Desktop Publishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -1.5306538276477482, "y": 0.7606585025787354, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Management Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0482384515239916, "y": 0.0744877085089683, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electric Motor, Power Tool, and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2959987074785453, "y": 1.036005973815918, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mobile Heavy Equipment Mechanics, Except Engines", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -1.3111711767115684, "y": -0.8671936392784119, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Trainers and Group Fitness Instructors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.5097164017692816, "y": -0.6489124298095703, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.065549841268239, "y": 0.8907629251480103, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Makeup Artists, Theatrical and Performance", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.8260723631505726, "y": 1.1067378520965576, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dispatchers, Except Police, Fire, and Ambulance", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.1464368897532982, "y": 0.8412538766860962, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Print Binding and Finishing Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0236777409365872, "y": 0.0276603139936923, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.2273720488599744, "y": -0.851708173751831, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.2612872430164695, "y": 2.3358442783355717, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": -1.0402418835199054, "y": -0.8997805714607239, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Massage Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.4516868248810886, "y": -0.5850602388381958, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletic Trainers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.1054502388754892, "y": 0.3872294425964355, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.314238342840608, "y": -1.0927003622055054, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bartenders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.0876278336010032, "y": -1.4102191925048828, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telemarketers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.6774524291926896, "y": 2.094535112380981, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Data Entry Keyers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Webb rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": -1.2124474289143454, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.0277980723573438, "y": -0.4176389575004577, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.6368033312319524, "y": -0.5372840762138367, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooling and Freezing Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.0184082093377855, "y": -1.2899117469787598, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dining Room and Cafeteria Attendants and Bartender Helpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.4357097431058516, "y": 1.8655712604522705, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Inspectors", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -0.4025694848468618, "y": -0.9741617441177368, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Floor, Ceiling, and Wall", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.6841921599322112, "y": -0.3090145885944366, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2695348951313973, "y": -0.817774772644043, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Assistants, Clerical", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.0422660961428759, "y": -0.6842256188392639, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Watch and Clock Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.3540124704030162, "y": 0.6336005926132202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forensic Science Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.5777200704469947, "y": -0.8207159638404846, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hearing Aid Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.7048764560791582, "y": -0.9937543272972108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rock Splitters, Quarry", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.1637615899672478, "y": -0.196017175912857, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Property, Real Estate, and Community Association Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.8338399312873329, "y": -0.0609257705509662, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.4282417280018922, "y": -1.1225101947784424, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 2.3664798768120976, "y": 1.7925150394439695, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Proofreaders and Copy Markers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.4", "Webb rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 0.6156410841929586, "y": 2.44266676902771, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Plant Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "2.4"}}, {"x": 0.5041814617212416, "y": 1.1507422924041748, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.2747895742280462, "y": -1.2012418508529663, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Human Service Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.4239930589522561, "y": -0.5225956439971924, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Film and Video Editors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2798001700417336, "y": 0.488168865442276, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cargo and Freight Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.574501587778538, "y": 1.0954437255859375, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical and Health Services Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.7290811173566742, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Communications Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.1842021869879643, "y": -1.2342365980148315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Counter and Rental Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 2.5187493896221773, "y": -0.0050914413295686, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Cage Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.5", "Webb rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.0276743659096343, "y": -1.2365416288375854, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Title Examiners, Abstractors, and Searchers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.863599975464569, "y": 0.4661899209022522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fish and Game Wardens", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8802520756486636, "y": 0.5741584300994873, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers, Farm, Ranch, and Aquacultural Animals", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.2048261572016251, "y": 0.6093778610229492, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.4210110569352954, "y": 0.187684416770935, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painters, Construction and Maintenance", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0932713927568725, "y": -0.9511350393295288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ship Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.8235694729289396, "y": 0.0764927938580513, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.17353522050073, "y": 1.9427112340927124, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 0.0796191480762997, "y": -0.3257933557033539, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Light Truck Drivers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.6529288275583993, "y": 1.2034814357757568, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Traffic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.3864681686870737, "y": 1.8055299520492556, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electro-Mechanical and Mechatronics Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 0.5980359105672828, "y": 4.27060079574585, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Administrative Law Judges, Adjudicators, and Hearing Officers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "4.3"}}, {"x": -0.6794706237786028, "y": 1.0021841526031494, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operating Engineers and Other Construction Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.5141610416358646, "y": -0.8956578969955444, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "New Accounts Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.1873026308664851, "y": -0.1153016164898872, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiovisual Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.816648081382791, "y": 0.994602620601654, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wellhead Pumpers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.0967578935314926, "y": 0.0712079778313636, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cardiovascular Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 1.5831949185341108, "y": 1.4037052392959597, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machinists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.1309808706579929, "y": -0.0751911476254463, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Enforcement Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2902226819176425, "y": -0.7501196265220642, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parts Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.085384831815483, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.6635636563599853, "y": 0.5133897662162781, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation and Benefits Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.059243035120383, "y": -0.9685173034667968, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food and Tobacco Roasting, Baking, and Drying Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.051413068811212, "y": 0.7835057377815247, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Upholsterers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 2.006967028695426, "y": -0.2011637389659881, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machine Feeders and Offbearers", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1460597364692063, "y": -0.4419618546962738, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furniture Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.7453540126887297, "y": -0.4262007474899292, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Set and Exhibit Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.3370913112158744, "y": -0.6782777309417725, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Choreographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2071361577794199, "y": -0.3783330023288727, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tile and Stone Setters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.239376988667188, "y": 0.3137692511081695, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Semiconductor Processing Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.3591321741120774, "y": 0.2319444417953491, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Milling and Planing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.0586105006816206, "y": 0.2718347907066345, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.8245011596794236, "y": 1.2779321670532229, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.73048476896969, "y": -0.8798584342002869, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bakers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.300758157626939, "y": -1.202905535697937, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Passenger Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.9081771274176852, "y": 0.452578991651535, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Registered Nurses", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.8791403433824152, "y": -1.093212008476257, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatric Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.8515657525789402, "y": -0.4284930825233459, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Podiatrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -1.1327084593718657, "y": -0.8158464431762695, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.1750027166854198, "y": -1.4246554374694824, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.4994005675931286, "y": -1.1718528270721436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Private Household", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.3436469011677024, "y": -1.0677754878997805, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dancers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.7336096555311683, "y": 3.5273659229278564, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "3.5"}}, {"x": -0.7596882588378406, "y": 1.1557172536849976, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mining and Geological Engineers, Including Mining Safety Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.8178909153404988, "y": 1.2794533967971802, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Extraction Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.2979090631898951, "y": -0.3248365223407745, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Body and Related Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.018218168909433, "y": 3.1565303802490234, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Riggers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "3.2"}}, {"x": -1.9062866927436664, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Law Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -1.4188227109715064, "y": 0.1959758549928665, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Natural Sciences Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.3042871214464526, "y": 2.316902637481689, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": -0.290878095326021, "y": 0.8119887709617615, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.4063919049471256, "y": 1.0741612911224363, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 0.5933234946090281, "y": -0.8624163269996643, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hosts and Hostesses, Restaurant, Lounge, and Coffee Shop", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.3611622417453817, "y": -0.0353211462497711, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Wood", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.1764881636946277, "y": -0.5795946717262268, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locker Room, Coatroom, and Dressing Room Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.1420791956188615, "y": 0.6308873295783997, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cartographers and Photogrammetrists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -2.211084482938715, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -2.1624961778599108, "y": 0.1151338592171669, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coaches and Scouts", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.241868951622614, "y": 1.2424697875976562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bioengineers and Biomedical Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.823949326841795, "y": 1.140874266624451, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveyors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.0059177475619447, "y": -1.1830182075500488, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Concierges", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.3104448357507248, "y": -1.3025166988372805, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric, Earth, Marine, and Space Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.3329546031290148, "y": 3.0619781017303467, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Optometrists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "3.1"}}, {"x": 1.26618186397543, "y": 0.0907063111662864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewing Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.4730577743534532, "y": 2.381203413009644, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Distributors and Dispatchers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "2.4"}}, {"x": -1.6915885036748526, "y": -0.6883068084716797, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Speech-Language Pathologists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0455510273001787, "y": -0.7919390797615051, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crossing Guards and Flaggers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.2632569270088317, "y": 4.793524742126465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Water and Wastewater Treatment Plant and System Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "4.8"}}, {"x": 0.8681469156656431, "y": 0.4231145083904266, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coin, Vending, and Amusement Machine Servicers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.7141046559031947, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.167345290078491, "y": -0.7419266700744629, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Embalmers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.3794237378925805, "y": -0.4373094439506531, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Repairers and Changers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.9276862719301904, "y": -0.5999838709831238, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Assistants, Except Payroll and Timekeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.3021435467775782, "y": 4.662463188171387, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "4.7"}}, {"x": -0.0831057227114354, "y": 0.0060288133099675, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Power-Line Installers and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.6333753946233884, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -2.158900354808966, "y": 3.372078418731689, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapists", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Webb rating": "3.4"}}, {"x": -1.309662260928632, "y": -0.6848747730255127, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Residential Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -1.605246646367264, "y": 0.771992564201355, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Soil and Plant Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -2.515496216126499, "y": 1.4559005498886108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm and Home Management Educators", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.5", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.7061652594245325, "y": 0.0760977566242218, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.966928402936567, "y": 0.0807331278920173, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Self-Enrichment Teachers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0330405899918561, "y": -0.1823243796825409, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Highway Maintenance Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.035633531816979, "y": 0.7424836754798889, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera Operators, Television, Video, and Film", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.5040729445567841, "y": -0.1402321904897689, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Private Detectives and Investigators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.3579826451892696, "y": -1.1052238941192627, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "File Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.8251601318462432, "y": 0.3646866977214813, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Derrick Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.495263346651427, "y": -0.2617073953151703, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Middle School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4041972330190037, "y": -0.8798580169677734, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietetic Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.2027900279704455, "y": -0.443599134683609, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packaging and Filling Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.8344455712588192, "y": -0.6466732621192932, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cement Masons and Concrete Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.6456907883484053, "y": -1.0970280170440674, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Roofers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.1525472155047861, "y": 1.0285803079605105, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Science Research Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.357833001150752, "y": 1.5551478862762451, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mail Clerks and Mail Machine Operators, Except Postal Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -1.831305637051771, "y": -0.2793347537517547, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Sales Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.903586148685048, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architecture Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.6829849255522995, "y": 0.7962645292282104, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biochemists and Biophysicists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.6957585989448415, "y": 0.2323369681835174, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rotary Drill Operators, Oil and Gas", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.039521600990234, "y": -0.1899179071187973, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Railroad Conductors and Yardmasters", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.6279977976317257, "y": -1.2237964868545532, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.6336178723651176, "y": 0.5414907932281494, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletes and Sports Competitors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -1.5156404877988283, "y": -0.6137647032737732, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stonemasons", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.784849124549827, "y": 0.0470247939229011, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lodging Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.0645099809696479, "y": -0.2784944474697113, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postmasters and Mail Superintendents", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.3490846221331796, "y": 2.088127851486206, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Analysts", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": 1.7329707418306268, "y": 1.4921356439590454, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Cutting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.431197868553953, "y": -0.2862051427364349, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Vehicle Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.258792145634027, "y": -0.0427577123045921, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Kindergarten Teachers, Except Special Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.3522010999809421, "y": 1.1144113540649414, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.1682534016042961, "y": 1.6358590126037598, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Commercial and Industrial Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -0.8065883038219844, "y": 1.1580440998077393, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -1.216428145739605, "y": -0.5742458701133728, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Relations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.3575349868723051, "y": 0.1216501295566558, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool and Die Makers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.7167729479827766, "y": 0.0279884245246648, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electricians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -1.708627745846133, "y": -0.1762772351503372, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Curators", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.3902994349745692, "y": -0.5650363564491272, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.4926879046390026, "y": 1.7155226469039917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Hardware Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 1.1318236588890729, "y": 0.6523779034614563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paper Goods Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.7393331967145719, "y": -0.549791157245636, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Broadcast Announcers and Radio Disc Jockeys", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2832544616050947, "y": -1.0680177211761477, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.3397962075450541, "y": 0.2238065600395202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Non-Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8470263264749203, "y": -1.0337166786193848, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Phlebotomists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.2814149167083635, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Morticians, Undertakers, and Funeral Arrangers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.950720864558097, "y": -1.0857956409454346, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Except Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.0235324327245148, "y": 1.2550731897354126, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Machine Operators, Except Computer", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.5492638748310614, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Specialties Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.9272564865352176, "y": -0.7608423233032227, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Practitioners", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.2412894411645986, "y": -0.8996869921684265, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airfield Operations Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.3578058544745672, "y": 1.598375678062439, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.1102215023516521, "y": -0.62262362241745, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive and Watercraft Service Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.91533608373423, "y": 1.392998218536377, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Personal Financial Advisors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.9078337914407992, "y": 0.4439289569854736, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Survey Researchers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.4353281092151733, "y": 2.5402638912200928, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Astronomers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "2.5"}}, {"x": -1.4414645719719343, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.3181805863619124, "y": -0.9003273844718933, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Archivists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -2.1178775623218278, "y": 0.9209062457084656, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.339031438255265, "y": 1.4529112577438354, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Cooking Machine Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.9029821968790444, "y": 0.8529910445213318, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graders and Sorters, Agricultural Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.530252107768302, "y": 2.032963275909424, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Power Reactor Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.7112473977081836, "y": 2.092301845550537, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Breeders", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7", "Webb rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": -0.1416328619647181, "y": 0.4615168869495392, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Amusement and Recreation Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2403621511881639, "y": 2.797250270843506, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Appraisers, Auto Damage", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2", "Webb rating": "2.8"}}, {"x": 0.4962195828573534, "y": -1.1386029720306396, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -2.041821159923535, "y": -0.905413806438446, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Door-to-Door Sales Workers, News and Street Vendors, and Related Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.1563745313464453, "y": -0.382190853357315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Transcriptionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.7657936659810389, "y": 2.0785391330718994, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Mechanics, Installers, and Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": -0.8170171917173217, "y": -0.1626845300197601, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest Fire Inspectors and Prevention Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.825603154659069, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Family and Consumer Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -2.0315493692647943, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social Work Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.5133841737460411, "y": 0.1750249415636062, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Production Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5397937420842506, "y": -1.414815068244934, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Caretakers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.1751133363204995, "y": 1.3524930477142334, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geographers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2", "Webb rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -2.234502859592556, "y": -1.4029781818389893, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Area, Ethnic, and Cultural Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.0307483544837543, "y": 0.0136143034324049, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Travel Agents", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.4170348398794407, "y": 0.4833618402481079, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lifeguards, Ski Patrol, and Other Recreational Protective Service Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.2511846601847043, "y": -0.2362626194953918, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Switchboard Operators, Including Answering Service", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7616809491938787, "y": 1.9351979494094849, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Printing Press Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 0.829393248096743, "y": -0.5511829257011414, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.2244066537133469, "y": -0.1571474522352218, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Etchers and Engravers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -1.542494518996816, "y": 0.0251334905624389, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Middle School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.303422390546166, "y": 0.1761687397956848, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Effects Artists and Animators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.7434467452373493, "y": -0.7760899662971497, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Legal Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.7795118833857506, "y": -0.4881137311458587, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.490619356336956, "y": -0.0651722624897956, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.007965920450863, "y": -0.554544985294342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Carpenters", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.510313007451929, "y": -1.1269197463989258, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mixing and Blending Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.9693925638889028, "y": -0.6009286046028137, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Baggage Porters and Bellhops", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.542157981149319, "y": 1.8810430765151975, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Conveyor Operators and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 0.2115773924288305, "y": 1.7111681699752808, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.4119883293005517, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Restaurant", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.9637436001218708, "y": -1.401847004890442, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interpreters and Translators", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.8018162111536116, "y": -0.1352046579122543, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Secondary School", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.0025978082411178, "y": -0.2964604794979095, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Janitors and Cleaners, Except Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5878393486504528, "y": -0.311039388179779, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Aides", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.3342983652234294, "y": -1.1169861555099487, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Retail Salespersons", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.4781211160618974, "y": 1.883563756942749, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Preparers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -0.0094680857194339, "y": 0.7207152843475342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation, Benefits, and Job Analysis Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.017261433832303, "y": -0.7261536121368408, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.0261785206045886, "y": 0.3830315470695495, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Weighers, Measurers, Checkers, and Samplers, Recordkeeping", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.491212452903623, "y": -1.1913776397705078, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Funeral Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 2.104487740229535, "y": 0.1321651339530944, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reservation and Transportation Ticket Agents and Travel Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.6551441048891751, "y": -0.6311540007591248, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interviewers, Except Eligibility and Loan", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.24460537513979, "y": -0.1376895457506179, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heat Treating Equipment Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.7060166036241945, "y": 0.5564082860946655, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laborers and Freight, Stock, and Material Movers, Hand", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.312553366016794, "y": -0.1421638131141662, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Millwrights", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.0604357096249049, "y": -0.8350316882133484, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Reinforcing Iron and Rebar Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0211954425738956, "y": 0.7965503334999084, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paving, Surfacing, and Tamping Equipment Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0", "Webb rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.4046408042333749, "y": 0.4776787161827087, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Musical Instrument Repairers and Tuners", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -1.843344597993704, "y": 4.752161979675293, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Scientists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8", "Webb rating": "4.8"}}, {"x": 0.2142074841063902, "y": 0.8613820672035217, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Appliance Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.8127455370190103, "y": 1.4801548719406128, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Mechanical", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.085513320787938, "y": -0.4542064964771271, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Technical and Scientific Products", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.4688778344204163, "y": 2.4421775341033936, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foresters", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "2.4"}}, {"x": -2.0652880244734684, "y": 0.1085374727845192, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fashion Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.6097348416943514, "y": 0.6146689653396606, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Housekeeping and Janitorial Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.3022061518374382, "y": 2.672346830368042, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Knitting and Weaving Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "2.7"}}, {"x": -0.7769990599516138, "y": -0.2903373539447784, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Layers, Except Carpet, Wood, and Hard Tiles", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5151390195019657, "y": -0.3791267275810241, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logisticians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.112458745665784, "y": 1.087518334388733, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Customer Service Representatives", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.4577354992478977, "y": -0.1421252638101577, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Engineering Managers", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2624386301361847, "y": -0.3402479588985443, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agents and Business Managers of Artists, Performers, and Athletes", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.6046577252228963, "y": -0.1400248706340789, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Medicine Technologists", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.6050495892236429, "y": 1.9997519254684448, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dredge Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.8225645682725966, "y": -0.0134218065068125, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rehabilitation Counselors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.3277182155559406, "y": -0.6714698076248169, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ushers, Lobby Attendants, and Ticket Takers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.4359828423867974, "y": 1.2415107488632202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinarians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.4179236921718974, "y": -1.2350106239318848, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Models", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.824249414799414, "y": -1.368141770362854, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Preparation Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.0863152633726389, "y": -0.2186144143342971, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lawyers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.5945431108364287, "y": -0.2950212061405182, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Security Screeners", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.7461634106624586, "y": -1.4772971868515017, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation and Fitness Studies Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7", "Webb rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.3378245445497652, "y": 1.7467260360717771, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial and Industrial Designers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -0.463389018131386, "y": -1.3639963865280151, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bailiffs", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.1047929570056536, "y": -0.3981973826885223, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tapers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.4288688329142143, "y": -0.7473572492599487, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaners of Vehicles and Equipment", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0639994512486199, "y": 1.5500600337982178, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floor Sanders and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.4099916757187356, "y": -0.5687038898468018, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tank Car, Truck, and Ship Loaders", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.3748166553039408, "y": 0.032688844949007, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Log Graders and Scalers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4", "Webb rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.1948068060793332, "y": -0.3214268386363983, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judges, Magistrate Judges, and Magistrates", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2", "Webb rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.838514124045148, "y": 1.5600327253341677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Winding, Twisting, and Drawing Out Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8", "Webb rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.7266747538855354, "y": -0.5624203085899353, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pipelayers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7", "Webb rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.4850646824522794, "y": 2.158082962036133, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Continuous Mining Machine Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "2.2"}}, {"x": -0.1267081165122968, "y": 0.1877222210168838, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dentists, General", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.4539405695217607, "y": -0.4564423859119415, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.5458909643294669, "y": 2.6987621784210205, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Repairers, Powerhouse, Substation, and Relay", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "2.7"}}, {"x": 1.0805537759406174, "y": 0.0693128928542137, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molding, Coremaking, and Casting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.5047140219008556, "y": 0.4645752310752868, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art Directors", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2651908544659347, "y": -1.0826770067214966, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locksmiths and Safe Repairers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.0549010878820693, "y": 1.179633617401123, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Compressor and Gas Pumping Station Operators", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1", "Webb rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -2.063559437558738, "y": -1.4424937963485718, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1", "Webb rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.5091934507281161, "y": 1.0612616539001465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shipping, Receiving, and Inventory Clerks", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5", "Webb rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.3095442043451213, "y": -0.1689421385526657, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Equipment Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.5594525776157964, "y": 0.4442035555839538, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.1458552216044873, "y": -1.1063721179962158, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Fast Food", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1", "Webb rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.5530655594833603, "y": -0.7896162271499634, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Terrazzo Workers and Finishers", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.874106654568681, "y": 0.6227110028266907, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Batchmakers", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.0275386377194975, "y": -0.8244175910949707, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0", "Webb rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.3315311988631069, "y": 1.7302827835083008, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Multiple Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3", "Webb rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -0.4745016803652506, "y": -0.4926850795745849, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthodontists", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.8207444276144482, "y": 0.0785633027553558, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Metal and Plastic", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8", "Webb rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.8917267046875949, "y": -0.93934565782547, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Flight Attendants", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9", "Webb rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.399555731390285, "y": 0.6096194386482239, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motion Picture Projectionists", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4", "Webb rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.4012180288777832, "y": 0.234823852777481, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sheet Metal Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4", "Webb rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.7777302446432449, "y": 0.4128470122814178, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Childcare Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8", "Webb rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.2601007592254225, "y": -0.1252999156713485, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Installation, Maintenance, and Repair Workers", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3", "Webb rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.989866693707687, "y": -0.4910422563552856, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health Education Specialists", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0", "Webb rating": "-0.5"}}], "size": 8.333333333333332, "fillColor": "rgb(2.0, 118.0, 124.0)", "strokeColor": "rgb(255.0, 255.0, 255.0)", "fillAlpha": 0.3, "strokeAlpha": 0.3, "marker": "M 0.0,-0.5 C 0.13260155,-0.5 0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C 0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 0.5,-0.13260155 0.5,0.0 C 0.5,0.13260155 0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C 0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 0.13260155,0.5 0.0,0.5 C -0.13260155,0.5 -0.25978993539242673,0.44731684579412084 -0.3535533905932738,0.3535533905932738 C -0.44731684579412084,0.25978993539242673 -0.5,0.13260155 -0.5,0.0 C -0.5,-0.13260155 -0.44731684579412084,-0.25978993539242673 -0.3535533905932738,-0.3535533905932738 C -0.25978993539242673,-0.44731684579412084 -0.13260155,-0.5 0.0,-0.5 Z 0.0,-0.5", "isFilled": true}, {"type": "line", "color": "#034752", "zOrder": 2, "strokeWidth": 2.25, "lineStyle": "-", "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 0.09842236038551516}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": 0.10016493579056879}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": 0.10190751119562241}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": 0.10365008660067605}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": 0.10539266200572966}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": 0.10713523741078329}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": 0.10887781281583693}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": 0.11062038822089056}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": 0.11236296362594418}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": 0.11410553903099781}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": 0.11584811443605145}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": 0.11759068984110507}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": 0.11933326524615868}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": 0.12107584065121232}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": 0.12281841605626595}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": 0.12456099146131958}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": 0.12630356686637323}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": 0.12804614227142683}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": 0.12978871767648045}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": 0.13153129308153408}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": 0.1332738684865877}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": 0.13501644389164136}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": 0.13675901929669498}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": 0.1385015947017486}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": 0.14024417010680224}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": 0.14198674551185586}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": 0.1437293209169095}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": 0.1454718963219631}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": 0.14721447172701674}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": 0.14895704713207036}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": 0.150699622537124}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": 0.15244219794217762}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": 0.15418477334723124}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": 0.15592734875228487}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": 0.1576699241573385}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": 0.15941249956239215}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": 0.16115507496744577}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": 0.1628976503724994}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": 0.16464022577755302}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": 0.16638280118260665}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": 0.16812537658766027}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": 0.1698679519927139}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": 0.17161052739776753}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": 0.17335310280282115}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": 0.17509567820787478}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": 0.17683825361292843}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": 0.17858082901798206}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": 0.18032340442303565}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": 0.1820659798280893}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": 0.18380855523314293}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": 0.18555113063819656}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": 0.18729370604325019}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": 0.1890362814483038}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": 0.19077885685335744}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": 0.19252143225841106}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": 0.1942640076634647}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": 0.19600658306851831}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": 0.19774915847357194}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": 0.1994917338786256}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": 0.20123430928367922}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": 0.20297688468873284}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": 0.20471946009378647}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": 0.2064620354988401}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": 0.20820461090389372}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": 0.20994718630894735}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": 0.21168976171400097}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": 0.2134323371190546}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": 0.21517491252410822}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": 0.21691748792916185}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": 0.21866006333421548}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": 0.2204026387392691}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.22214521414432276}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.22388778954937638}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 0.22563036495443}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 0.22737294035948363}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 0.22911551576453726}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 0.23085809116959088}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 0.2326006665746445}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 0.23434324197969814}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 0.23608581738475176}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 0.2378283927898054}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 0.239570968194859}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 0.24131354359991264}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 0.24305611900496626}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 0.2447986944100199}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 0.24654126981507354}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 0.24828384522012717}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 0.25002642062518077}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 0.2517689960302344}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 0.253511571435288}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 0.2552541468403417}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 0.2569967222453953}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 0.25873929765044895}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 0.2604818730555025}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 0.26222444846055615}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 0.2639670238656098}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 0.26570959927066345}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 0.2674521746757171}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 0.2691947500807707}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.27093732548582433}]}, {"type": "polygon", "color": "rgb(3.0, 71.0, 82.0)", "alpha": 0.15, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 0.37332219234000313}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": -0.1685520201152939}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": -0.1625320251396284}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": -0.15608281750360112}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": -0.14963360986757387}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": -0.14318440223154671}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": -0.13673519459551944}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": -0.1302859869594922}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": -0.12384566173455688}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": -0.11941335602288815}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": -0.11496292534040133}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": -0.11048250741974179}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": -0.10550730362846304}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": -0.09837110852851544}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": -0.09155781275446333}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": -0.08658909911051992}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": -0.08156271277994964}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": -0.07276879982314918}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": -0.0659317586530554}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": -0.06029062609306439}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": -0.05335459627111961}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": -0.04762744373320974}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": -0.04191041164929648}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": -0.03636752171016411}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": -0.03032861261378128}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": -0.024569724011133033}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": -0.017988626273857205}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": -0.011264547201742163}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": -0.005381608326726498}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": 0.001144332653406083}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": 0.007670273633538663}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": 0.01220422616790337}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": 0.019066181800326196}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": 0.025554314972962445}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": 0.03134723923893812}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": 0.035963248191428286}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": 0.04150194901018637}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": 0.047349333922383524}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": 0.05282897635771232}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": 0.057415032810629235}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": 0.06119361668458197}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": 0.06525711355786822}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": 0.0687739731585256}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": 0.07401666499298568}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": 0.07731207473733356}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": 0.08253731448395557}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": 0.08595075396804959}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": 0.08836502932634777}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": 0.09107201290351692}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": 0.09319729708804936}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": 0.09537022542103792}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": 0.09661514384043346}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": 0.09818794739602324}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": 0.09987431144308812}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": 0.10070865905085322}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": 0.10130840606632688}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": 0.10188536715502902}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": 0.10239469788576251}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": 0.10120935485406796}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": 0.10148107392101173}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": 0.10315462446080097}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": 0.10315861075751315}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": 0.09925176816725233}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": 0.09851802473147002}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": 0.09808974465406488}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": 0.09697763778917466}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": 0.09628453584737166}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": 0.09677486861504696}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": 0.09536918374267699}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": 0.09575335501285138}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": 0.0936351518640374}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": 0.0920360462013638}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.08962814418963407}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.08835261302804782}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 0.08615372901354766}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 0.08336741288143852}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 0.08087877006205918}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 0.07843329521205543}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 0.07682992546863546}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 0.07354415135618446}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 0.0710968706620442}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 0.06866069297029087}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 0.06682641806115605}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 0.06620847997693752}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 0.06300100626654907}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 0.05979353255616063}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 0.056509261147900156}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 0.05342465485013524}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 0.051610656689218666}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 0.04915438292695134}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 0.04669810916468402}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 0.0442587837012009}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 0.041749597165688344}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 0.03810888788870797}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 0.036081755546418084}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 0.033884056989088654}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 0.030256686972176722}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 0.02640107435851402}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 0.02254546174485132}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 0.018689849131188613}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.01471110138655911}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.5751532562373132}, {"x": 2.7735621867140567, "y": 0.5751532562373132}, {"x": 2.7137242628154774, "y": 0.5678436591132158}, {"x": 2.6538863389168976, "y": 0.5605648367783249}, {"x": 2.594048415018318, "y": 0.5532764058607761}, {"x": 2.534210491119738, "y": 0.5459737444581283}, {"x": 2.4743725672211583, "y": 0.5386710830554804}, {"x": 2.4145346433225785, "y": 0.5313684216528325}, {"x": 2.3546967194239996, "y": 0.5240657602501848}, {"x": 2.29485879552542, "y": 0.5174877761715563}, {"x": 2.23502087162684, "y": 0.509460437444889}, {"x": 2.1751829477282603, "y": 0.5021577760422412}, {"x": 2.1153450238296805, "y": 0.49485511463959336}, {"x": 2.0555070999311007, "y": 0.4875524532369455}, {"x": 1.995669176032521, "y": 0.4802497918342976}, {"x": 1.9358312521339411, "y": 0.4733653615698492}, {"x": 1.8759933282353614, "y": 0.4680410172472239}, {"x": 1.8161554043367816, "y": 0.46083767634622486}, {"x": 1.7563174804382018, "y": 0.4536343354452258}, {"x": 1.696479556539622, "y": 0.44640090569654683}, {"x": 1.6366416326410422, "y": 0.440803657311954}, {"x": 1.5768037087424625, "y": 0.43344790915491954}, {"x": 1.5169657848438836, "y": 0.4246780277350195}, {"x": 1.4571278609453038, "y": 0.4174297481198162}, {"x": 1.397289937046724, "y": 0.4101374039587392}, {"x": 1.3374520131481442, "y": 0.4031577321741282}, {"x": 1.2776140892495644, "y": 0.3981549861447123}, {"x": 1.2177761653509847, "y": 0.39258869448324635}, {"x": 1.1579382414524049, "y": 0.3882956428864257}, {"x": 1.098100317553825, "y": 0.3834197084435319}, {"x": 1.0382623936552453, "y": 0.37849633392720344}, {"x": 0.9784244697566655, "y": 0.37261160286165934}, {"x": 0.9185865458580857, "y": 0.36508715230962774}, {"x": 0.858748621959506, "y": 0.35806484058810834}, {"x": 0.7989106980609266, "y": 0.35502877350753825}, {"x": 0.7390727741623468, "y": 0.3475706256498384}, {"x": 0.6792348502637671, "y": 0.34203404112515123}, {"x": 0.6193969263651873, "y": 0.33734454716169204}, {"x": 0.5595590024666075, "y": 0.331941729832329}, {"x": 0.4997210785680277, "y": 0.32498182925499003}, {"x": 0.4398831546694484, "y": 0.3194412518506951}, {"x": 0.3800452307708686, "y": 0.3134362388567742}, {"x": 0.3202073068722888, "y": 0.30953925585549413}, {"x": 0.26036938297370904, "y": 0.3080545557267225}, {"x": 0.20053145907512926, "y": 0.3028962163830785}, {"x": 0.14069353517654948, "y": 0.2993571280717284}, {"x": 0.0808556112779697, "y": 0.2957237421842007}, {"x": 0.02101768737939036, "y": 0.2932508210873815}, {"x": -0.03882023651918942, "y": 0.2907100541135506}, {"x": -0.0986581604177692, "y": 0.2910546752538571}, {"x": -0.15849608431634898, "y": 0.2894629836359998}, {"x": -0.21833400821492877, "y": 0.28831275199234613}, {"x": -0.27817193211350855, "y": 0.28700311129899125}, {"x": -0.33800985601208833, "y": 0.2856488111332325}, {"x": -0.39784777991066766, "y": 0.28329041234196006}, {"x": -0.45768570380924745, "y": 0.28252379794718396}, {"x": -0.5175236277078272, "y": 0.2841583075954313}, {"x": -0.577361551606407, "y": 0.28417110485235164}, {"x": -0.6371994755049868, "y": 0.2841697989154525}, {"x": -0.6970373994035666, "y": 0.28351466518035895}, {"x": -0.7568753233021464, "y": 0.284104276886265}, {"x": -0.8167132472007257, "y": 0.28706803400755515}, {"x": -0.8765511710993055, "y": 0.2891039805090754}, {"x": -0.9363890949978853, "y": 0.289330292890272}, {"x": -0.996227018896465, "y": 0.2919465707269285}, {"x": -1.0560649427950448, "y": 0.29391897303000747}, {"x": -1.1159028666936246, "y": 0.2943218012873751}, {"x": -1.1757407905922042, "y": 0.2952299196651726}, {"x": -1.235578714490784, "y": 0.2956793404169804}, {"x": -1.2954166383893637, "y": 0.29668923321185064}, {"x": -1.3552545622879433, "y": 0.29991265179901344}, {"x": -1.415092486186523, "y": 0.30236953000533096}, {"x": -1.4749304100851028, "y": 0.30322596436217997}, {"x": -1.5347683339836826, "y": 0.3057329905393728}, {"x": -1.5946062578822622, "y": 0.30820886517526974}, {"x": -1.654444181780842, "y": 0.31070510679035285}, {"x": -1.7142821056794217, "y": 0.3134203786656288}, {"x": -1.7741200295780013, "y": 0.3149136132499725}, {"x": -1.833957953476581, "y": 0.31513201354208614}, {"x": -1.8937958773751609, "y": 0.31614413599608354}, {"x": -1.9536338012737406, "y": 0.31994220294998366}, {"x": -2.0134717251723204, "y": 0.3225292528164354}, {"x": -2.0733096490709, "y": 0.32431896509266533}, {"x": -2.13314757296948, "y": 0.3274837555453532}, {"x": -2.1929854968680593, "y": 0.3306394087929289}, {"x": -2.252823420766639, "y": 0.3318476521407999}, {"x": -2.312661344665219, "y": 0.33454758033591286}, {"x": -2.3724992685637987, "y": 0.3380725743464272}, {"x": -2.4323371924623785, "y": 0.34078826751951363}, {"x": -2.492175116360958, "y": 0.34302851430629616}, {"x": -2.5520130402595376, "y": 0.3465636132149514}, {"x": -2.6118509641581173, "y": 0.3498663897200444}, {"x": -2.671688888056697, "y": 0.3511000196990159}, {"x": -2.731526811955277, "y": 0.354049802955856}, {"x": -2.7913647358538567, "y": 0.3569995862126961}, {"x": -2.8512026597524365, "y": 0.35994936946953626}, {"x": -2.9110405836510163, "y": 0.3626935907802789}, {"x": -2.9708785075495956, "y": 0.36518278094187223}, {"x": -3.0307164314481754, "y": 0.3676719711034656}, {"x": -3.090554355346755, "y": 0.370161161265059}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 0.37332219234000313}, {"x": -3.150392279245335, "y": 0.37332219234000313}], "closed": true}, {"type": "text", "color": "grey", "zOrder": 3, "text": "R\u00b2=0.00", "x": 0.08, "y": 0.87, "ha": "left", "va": "baseline", "rotation": 0.0, "rotationMode": "default", "background": true, "fontSizeScaling": 1, "textCoords": "paper-normalized"}], "hud": [], "originalDataAspectRatio": 0.7451612903225805, "additionalLegendItems": []} {"downloadButtonPosition": "none"}

{"title": "Comparison of automatability measures across occupations", "xAxis": {"label": "Duckworth et al.", "lim": [-2.9844082231539497, 2.5503540951106114], "scaleType": "linear"}, "yAxis": {"label": "Autor et al.", "lim": [-3.4465900025433047, 3.0697599100120265], "scaleType": "linear"}, "showFrame": true, "objects": [{"type": "scatter", "alpha": 0.3, "zOrder": 1, "points": [{"x": -0.703264111404103, "y": -1.3879757172393794, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hydrologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.0468865595777583, "y": 0.8738669794255672, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Inspectors, Testers, Sorters, Samplers, and Weighers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.2468448983342714, "y": -0.1666628024119154, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fine Artists, Including Painters, Sculptors, and Illustrators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.4128131492590628, "y": 1.7804981301768894, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -0.39293887141217, "y": -0.8795861299816146, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Construction Trades and Extraction Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.273219440448491, "y": 0.7687729425831287, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Interviewers and Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.2988886285450896, "y": -1.6629131000636508, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marketing Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.1346048095820586, "y": -0.12378193496383, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -2.6262371076123125, "y": -1.9277204053432249, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.6168533309111613, "y": -1.398356520939802, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manufactured Building and Mobile Home Installers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -2.037588440839733, "y": -0.9061688817454226, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Child, Family, and School Social Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.373901442432928, "y": -1.229972685882886, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.5659064094734048, "y": -1.7812259575544531, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chief Executives", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -0.16763154147112, "y": -0.0039331134124508, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Pipelayers, Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 1.3803298101336252, "y": 1.859323689241689, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Change Persons and Booth Cashiers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 1.7558837173113977, "y": 1.557483831077505, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Laboratory Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -0.5527694572451863, "y": -0.1412240429044082, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Graphic Designers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2441234706415258, "y": -0.9563260208308996, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Family Medicine Physicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.644503347059094, "y": -0.1029408398799553, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Opticians, Dispensing", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.3482477770903285, "y": -1.4607253338358603, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "General and Operations Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.8387034031209629, "y": -1.112529210646494, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer and Information Research Scientists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.3481723680214542, "y": 1.207129400606792, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Equipment Preparers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.0415246816136742, "y": -0.3411191413364209, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Pilots", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.3921460972859452, "y": 1.7633323806856949, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Subway and Streetcar Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": -0.2745422755559366, "y": -0.7317018320835897, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security Guards", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.586010661477966, "y": 0.2438311053934494, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crane and Tower Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0404929045074988, "y": 0.1090292074789271, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sailors and Marine Oilers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3516237433050262, "y": 0.1597849936475773, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locomotive Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.3710831047565135, "y": 0.9465509258889518, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coating, Painting, and Spraying Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.3677346047444751, "y": -0.4002584839064506, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorboat Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.3029469438659889, "y": -0.5337725316665024, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brickmasons and Blockmasons", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.9321808127022048, "y": 0.2162911735904329, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nuclear Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.5087778064233417, "y": -1.2775952412045133, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Epidemiologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.560700829857162, "y": 1.4105844317226746, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tool Grinders, Filers, and Sharpeners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -2.130134449337492, "y": -1.996340114497679, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Healthcare Social Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": -2.2378004708678847, "y": -1.0353559581581828, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Preschool Teachers, Except Special Education", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3371275039604576, "y": 0.2406121254605465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Painters, Paperhangers, Plasterers, and Stucco Masons", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.801428006066988, "y": 1.8204565641037875, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Sorters, Processors, and Processing Machine Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "1.8"}}, {"x": 0.955222790604522, "y": 1.067303770014071, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Procurement Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.216866940362569, "y": -0.2588012909362202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roustabouts, Oil and Gas", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.120628475823059, "y": 0.2291720398343169, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hotel, Motel, and Resort Desk Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -2.104802067846961, "y": -1.2592578673812185, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Career/Technical Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.2040221768988926, "y": 1.272530239671472, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -1.4118080185502786, "y": -0.9906848123176468, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Community Service Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.054885507302651, "y": -0.6730993274418786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bicycle Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.4700422776848855, "y": -0.7660536591214124, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Interior Designers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -2.668711397468404, "y": -1.9199418254306408, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Business Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 1.8719578092751863, "y": 0.1984900413932157, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painting, Coating, and Decorating Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.8987178135620543, "y": -0.9651727034022022, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.7136489612896567, "y": 1.8678163958494096, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling and Sports Book Writers and Runners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 1.3791359439209143, "y": 1.4775046840042845, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Textile Bleaching and Dyeing Machine Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.16264327951069, "y": -0.4376365754218905, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Museum Technicians and Conservators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -2.33120055935641, "y": -1.0188198127948211, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemistry Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 1.1929440390040476, "y": 0.4865439553846576, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Forming Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Synthetic and Glass Fibers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.6071392311565762, "y": -0.3192931547383277, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Production and Operating Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.0286146759473043, "y": 0.0949537063416281, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Respiratory Therapists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2684435566458819, "y": 0.4480116316352364, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architectural and Civil Drafters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.148911827350502, "y": -1.458285251111881, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Scientists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 0.2942308019941453, "y": 0.8988100277128837, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shampooers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1854848863177358, "y": -0.6273322601296695, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Door Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9453610782707408, "y": -0.170231823568934, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Programmers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.5129216490218562, "y": 1.2097198306705703, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Billing and Posting Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.4686798627869696, "y": -0.3180282187359726, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Demonstrators and Product Promoters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.5027066113571017, "y": -0.8718361075941772, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education and Childcare Administrators, Preschool and Daycare", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.2902584518293734, "y": -0.4527867458282585, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpet Installers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.5565751695599128, "y": 1.1743689098151666, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tire Builders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": -0.6473230711421564, "y": -1.35719352361029, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Correctional Officers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -2.643282335004278, "y": -1.3878560374962543, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 0.5239006998500237, "y": 1.6176510641006632, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Slaughterers and Meat Packers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -0.1920887362305082, "y": -0.5428749853667544, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "General Internal Medicine Physicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.399588836405913, "y": -0.8794611907585571, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer and Information Systems Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.1439327971392235, "y": 0.118774713664243, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.6844563614224998, "y": 0.0028291672137524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stationary Engineers and Boiler Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.171614762894824, "y": -0.9905780385848506, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Control Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.2223620918172356, "y": -0.7406839953693914, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tree Trimmers and Pruners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.8323402544298715, "y": 0.9380037429031493, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Judicial Law Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.975936305910642, "y": 0.8778901879268389, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meter Readers, Utilities", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.162600338185487, "y": -0.5116881785612835, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Earth Drillers, Except Oil and Gas", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.1627160111007565, "y": 0.146188611016774, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dishwashers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.11086498616951, "y": 0.8317415685275095, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Glass Installers and Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.1447877612628614, "y": -0.8454763822267284, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatric Aides", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.4790755270549238, "y": -0.1745555230932532, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pesticide Handlers, Sprayers, and Applicators, Vegetation", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -2.608923856792725, "y": -2.651248398474005, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forestry and Conservation Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.7"}}, {"x": 0.8568638720508708, "y": 0.6647895434714719, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveying and Mapping Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2366386184918601, "y": 0.0558322850299701, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Glaziers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2360885305822549, "y": 0.4950131724181174, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Craft Artists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -2.6293716755261967, "y": -1.26970421220172, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Clergy", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -2.732828117778288, "y": -1.036151212776815, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "History Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.2777248192014639, "y": 0.7819185045085033, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Air Traffic Controllers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0403126539131557, "y": -0.6262646108388754, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pest Control Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2480800809665278, "y": -0.6170505642570706, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Mechanics and Service Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.0744443269178712, "y": 0.5201602731015502, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -1.3228912447938022, "y": -2.1096742408509983, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": -1.3884652963593178, "y": -1.6366551142657275, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Community Health Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": 0.8212605872153034, "y": 1.5470181213201686, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meat, Poultry, and Fish Cutters and Trimmers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.2369794470727298, "y": -0.9388818956190284, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Floral Designers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.8414084191278177, "y": 0.0066758757353878, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Software Quality Assurance Analysts and Testers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -2.541761637287628, "y": -0.8801617726657183, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematical Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.7622536496490635, "y": 0.2491564480854882, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Layout Workers, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.2980169911833424, "y": 1.136975723495231, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Production Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.1652631437762826, "y": 0.6790061859797019, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refractory Materials Repairers, Except Brickmasons", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.946527158098239, "y": 0.7819356456226125, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paralegals and Legal Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0329482528203985, "y": -0.2894094336903337, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Acupuncturists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.9418435732181752, "y": -0.5563316338766712, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Solar Photovoltaic Installers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.3536406966720705, "y": 0.5764248510627038, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hoist and Winch Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1513996247075982, "y": 0.4951107921040945, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Servers, Nonrestaurant", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.8427586256792496, "y": 1.096748042827857, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foundry Mold and Coremakers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.0479711877823379, "y": 0.3169447298842093, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Licensed Practical and Licensed Vocational Nurses", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -1.0047428715367277, "y": 0.8427647104734115, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Service Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -2.7172264040478185, "y": -1.7979287796407275, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Political Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 1.361792335852495, "y": 1.4174885121922616, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding, Forming, Pressing, and Compacting Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.3111930460454263, "y": 0.6001567912318234, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Surveillance Officers and Gambling Investigators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2028872212087956, "y": -0.332257858369244, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.7746008246257917, "y": 0.8628367773058664, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Public Safety Telecommunicators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -2.344539000191097, "y": -0.9253881581355786, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adult Basic Education, Adult Secondary Education, and English as a Second Language Instructors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.009364624326135, "y": -1.115542120743649, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Security and Fire Alarm Systems Installers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.5015067550940344, "y": 0.8478630448741451, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plating Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.655823973118674, "y": -1.6955245225744036, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Police and Detectives", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -1.532814095730903, "y": -2.107337904574303, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Emergency Management Directors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": -2.256893018825412, "y": -1.459045469791104, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.6744430225845489, "y": -0.7923693052017245, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heating, Air Conditioning, and Refrigeration Mechanics and Installers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.4174315200255791, "y": -0.5133653075622094, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hairdressers, Hairstylists, and Cosmetologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -2.5323608835489293, "y": -1.899884285005504, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engineering Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 1.520447461405228, "y": 1.9096847130366288, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Woodworking Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Except Sawing", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -2.574408626833438, "y": -0.9450373452170504, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nursing Instructors and Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.1694948798295365, "y": 1.260815125874153, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Diagnostic Medical Sonographers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.1604891393506641, "y": -0.6058133203748001, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Outdoor Power Equipment and Other Small Engine Mechanics", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1244658308357811, "y": -0.1802755546079249, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer, Automated Teller, and Office Machine Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.9413459882682331, "y": 2.308011656461644, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe Machine Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9", "Autor et al. rating": "2.3"}}, {"x": -1.1033513439531422, "y": -0.7917310476663457, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statisticians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.1680053488323742, "y": -0.2119979095391702, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surgical Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0903826535834356, "y": 1.1845001167699116, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Gambling Services Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.2270209994466562, "y": -0.8851386916400845, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.9351172929478712, "y": 0.8311679997784562, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 2.1779342284244967, "y": 0.1859608627599854, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fabric and Apparel Patternmakers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.3348088161636844, "y": -0.6235878556784445, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Yard Engineers, Dinkey Operators, and Hostlers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.7678616136078094, "y": -1.6608103499457694, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.7029852413785092, "y": -1.1576690232763411, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Zoologists and Wildlife Biologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.2401071260235256, "y": -0.2758731672301599, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sound Engineering Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.4673492459563933, "y": -0.3103914296664506, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chefs and Head Cooks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.273521999751212, "y": -0.1052002908318708, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Motorcycle Mechanics", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2153808180767137, "y": 1.3456587931753214, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiation Therapists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": -0.7390983953330813, "y": -0.1662019129923107, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.0341683322074101, "y": -0.4470366621020035, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronic Equipment Installers and Repairers, Motor Vehicles", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -2.0301446386389803, "y": -0.6354002347736443, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Arbitrators, Mediators, and Conciliators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -2.1767159539730945, "y": -2.330784055904513, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Educational, Guidance, and Career Counselors and Advisors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -0.3922193656811593, "y": -0.793744986464031, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Home Appliance Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.7863003995872202, "y": 0.49820798587486, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Photographic Process Workers and Processing Machine Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.1891247919986858, "y": 0.8579685140459804, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Packers and Packagers, Hand", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.887106686042624, "y": 1.0183809588051669, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutters and Trimmers, Hand", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.0974683708909521, "y": -1.2795218700990303, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapist Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.900993163118933, "y": 0.2623391526162582, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Statistical Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.409203674469517, "y": 1.003670446762344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fiberglass Laminators and Fabricators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.3723065544255295, "y": -0.0628692390837011, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscaping and Groundskeeping Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.0235867970376489, "y": 1.3089559447421135, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cashiers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.492699458087622, "y": 1.360155271736588, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding, Lapping, Polishing, and Buffing Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.5518129749396737, "y": -0.5396079321446071, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Examiners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.9628467291744296, "y": 0.454425854241453, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Systems Analysts", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.2956656757359215, "y": 0.9669829948160152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rolling Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.0992771637029905, "y": -0.5710404730541805, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Equipment Installers and Repairers, Except Line Installers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1631361056165061, "y": -1.184724227600342, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radio, Cellular, and Tower Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.1227204020776113, "y": -1.0806273539194895, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Neurologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 2.2039702539503323, "y": 0.1645226637058472, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Shoe and Leather Workers and Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.225039264897638, "y": 0.7711931576309774, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Assistants and Laboratory Animal Caretakers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.4819744010628344, "y": -1.3926167440556287, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Architects, Except Landscape and Naval", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": 1.147552146230877, "y": 1.6267937654755713, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Office Clerks, General", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": -2.277064713235202, "y": -1.1586119749940411, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.7406830716048846, "y": -1.504803091190655, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreation Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.7873960081536429, "y": 0.7281594872419926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Jewelers and Precious Stone and Metal Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.6445870970627177, "y": 1.4459361806357918, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Molders, Shapers, and Casters, Except Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.4429036073973532, "y": -1.008514111373503, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Physiologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.1699556894135414, "y": -2.5673369967257145, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Urban and Regional Planners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.6"}}, {"x": 0.6073499519443853, "y": -0.5481013322748092, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Excavating and Loading Machine and Dragline Operators, Surface Mining", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.4411239202290629, "y": 1.4838150007725963, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coil Winders, Tapers, and Finishers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.1812189303463847, "y": 0.3646337058614783, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pile Driver Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.1143381488429239, "y": 0.413652326235589, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineering and Operations Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.1828910216048654, "y": -0.7115386799945627, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cost Estimators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.3360795750912868, "y": -0.5943329550635068, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Septic Tank Servicers and Sewer Pipe Cleaners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0655319425515262, "y": 0.5199121450668008, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Claims Adjusters, Examiners, and Investigators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.4603533033796143, "y": 1.5305181232195075, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tellers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.3317923857960092, "y": -0.4865023643391553, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising and Promotions Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.7833572722261763, "y": -1.9498596825735608, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Administrators, Kindergarten through Secondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.96504009798446, "y": -1.349270017361749, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physicists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.1818004823308954, "y": 0.2870916936583988, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Logging Equipment Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.348087243638465, "y": 0.3979925945108996, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Microbiologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.2589299565956769, "y": -0.9289446585442722, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation, Storage, and Distribution Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -1.7408200474382716, "y": -1.261215927667404, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Labor Relations Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.6073445863659294, "y": -1.2959256040461369, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.1848561383487699, "y": -1.2173345606272563, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Midwives", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.4617316588496061, "y": -0.3419903257028654, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roofers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.583167413121328, "y": -0.3116158920602814, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Information Security Analysts", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.061706650784504, "y": -0.2322879970452644, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Costume Attendants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.5209936330821148, "y": 0.0367234606969555, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Laboratory Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.0651222108483786, "y": -0.096593567122127, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Iron and Steel Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -2.616885242852558, "y": -2.2426924043436363, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Art, Drama, and Music Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -1.1661590396937955, "y": -0.0893882922911258, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Writers and Authors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.4085660374368387, "y": -0.1027259585525155, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bus and Truck Mechanics and Diesel Engine Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2994560124669799, "y": 0.255497013586391, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Service Unit Operators, Oil and Gas", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.0642342953041333, "y": 0.1435896306415737, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Airline Pilots, Copilots, and Flight Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.0720559190126742, "y": -0.5207884919746754, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.177366000143982, "y": -1.0421236179435285, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Scientists and Specialists, Including Health", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -2.409703904962014, "y": -1.228247972750638, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "School Psychologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 1.6625597546324866, "y": 1.855060775139609, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Mail Carriers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": 1.4181395747339234, "y": 1.7172717451093302, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Word Processors and Typists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -0.4943430449631734, "y": 0.427905954618115, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Elevator and Escalator Installers and Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2485157395365199, "y": 0.3883263612610775, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.3791970736271638, "y": -1.1326045094331685, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Landscape Architects", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.4797806591274116, "y": -1.3331083471176046, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transit and Railroad Police", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.1239395143197442, "y": -0.5689573020554451, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Therapy Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.5098825880808053, "y": 0.3988620055019044, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farm Labor Contractors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.6269956525558877, "y": 0.878637112989117, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Eligibility Interviewers, Government Programs", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.1527328310774192, "y": 0.716245025559664, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Metal-Refining Furnace Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.1556775094581393, "y": -0.1153503650067896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Scientists, Except Epidemiologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.2422895564771297, "y": 0.7545121597708432, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Engine and Other Machine Assemblers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0420106626690999, "y": -1.1649855703243135, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dermatologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.4836202557061854, "y": 0.2055050168889151, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Umpires, Referees, and Other Sports Officials", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -0.093692338467903, "y": 0.8269838306805912, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Short Order", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -1.1617731512934864, "y": -1.4563566688638634, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Librarians and Media Collections Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": 1.3466121754914704, "y": 0.3355795054575677, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pourers and Casters, Metal", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 2.2987739897349497, "y": 1.6896623194547988, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tailors, Dressmakers, and Custom Sewers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 1.565961621418977, "y": 0.9269442287740294, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drilling and Boring Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.9286634920001388, "y": 0.2503349809478545, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Separating, Filtering, Clarifying, Precipitating, and Still Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 1.429052367735809, "y": 0.805608689891823, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forging Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.9063660622523873, "y": -1.0452772118071618, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operations Research Analysts", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.6099370457054695, "y": -1.7843564994601844, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fundraisers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 1.7052715669735865, "y": -0.0931249019367593, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Grinding and Polishing Workers, Hand", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.3472465105242164, "y": -0.5220682912726096, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Administrative Services Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 1.505018502741447, "y": 1.3974472910211182, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Lathe and Turning Machine Tool Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.6651682107500729, "y": -0.275127175318862, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food Scientists and Technologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.0326712023699116, "y": -0.6245158458438212, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmologists, Except Pediatric", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -2.7225711963132886, "y": -1.1035045259606848, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Philosophy and Religion Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.7882043315988058, "y": 0.6177573881765728, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Driver/Sales Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.3548373473085439, "y": 0.860101367472801, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ophthalmic Medical Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -0.7020121684394975, "y": -1.7016666738235096, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Firefighting and Prevention Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.6503514694257053, "y": 0.2536031979677634, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loading and Moving Machine Operators, Underground Mining", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.1872948975572711, "y": -0.5952167662256497, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail-Track Laying and Maintenance Equipment Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.3181482728807226, "y": 1.4106782716026849, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correspondence Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.3023433033111529, "y": -0.3718634252361831, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Financial Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.2650298339398956, "y": -0.5514297625619868, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marine Engineers and Naval Architects", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.7905491547110118, "y": -0.9979158190254164, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Scientists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.1908360562358057, "y": -0.168257496434765, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Control and Valve Installers and Repairers, Except Mechanical Door", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.587643689307551, "y": -2.3887831446158225, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Recreational Therapists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.4"}}, {"x": -0.368918026723411, "y": -0.0183989055691776, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -2.2412458966992697, "y": -1.1291664571641664, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Middle School", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.1695354610987684, "y": 0.8167005964033244, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Radiologic Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.1817054183550576, "y": -0.3756481511626501, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Avionics Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2409215936334452, "y": -0.601366659204723, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ambulance Drivers and Attendants, Except Emergency Medical Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.3420251508452046, "y": 1.0651753538796804, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welders, Cutters, Solderers, and Brazers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.9242465390964, "y": -0.8997798001241091, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Historians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.9", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.3946033438568823, "y": 1.2864419155115894, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Adhesive Bonding Machine Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.2798238028284763, "y": 1.8575731168305705, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Laundry and Dry-Cleaning Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.9"}}, {"x": -0.0033063416134053, "y": 0.3439734260570267, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Credit Counselors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.24030288527786, "y": 1.043337764227231, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -2.5338622567240234, "y": -2.1191467593298605, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "English Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": 0.1724766590864146, "y": -0.1456937718268784, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Underwriters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3420696689066105, "y": -0.302936056976872, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Transportation Inspectors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -2.653244603099937, "y": -2.2678319184750424, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.3"}}, {"x": -0.2058562199341601, "y": -1.260550163321611, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Obstetricians and Gynecologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.511314805213771, "y": 0.961096082230804, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Waiters and Waitresses", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.318346390052436, "y": 0.3626576043666109, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Order Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2350760170975867, "y": -0.3409863554482197, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Paperhangers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.775894525214811, "y": 1.543237498245881, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pressers, Textile, Garment, and Related Materials", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -0.0039737005200961, "y": -0.7579204616488344, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electronics Engineers, Except Computer", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 1.622345182175969, "y": 0.9822806035794333, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Prepress Technicians and Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 1.157798036146149, "y": 1.4989676451123788, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Brokerage Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -2.67816093181928, "y": -2.00606003700463, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Foreign Language and Literature Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.0"}}, {"x": 0.1909323682370788, "y": -0.0654027329048016, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fence Erectors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.4168141050055866, "y": -0.5333638512536465, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Commercial Divers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.0789697885283841, "y": 0.5597607197091468, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Drafters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0530173909039781, "y": -0.1702958363252753, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chiropractors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.3575749900676316, "y": -1.3104585936143174, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatrists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.8175593606035257, "y": -1.275963820611964, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest and Conservation Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.1798296252449561, "y": 0.6229718502009335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Drywall and Ceiling Tile Installers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.9420320518151852, "y": 0.5084109052552163, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Butchers and Meat Cutters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.0301736206021941, "y": 0.5791583819927179, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance Workers, Machinery", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -2.048504374423446, "y": -1.7576292009047862, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial-Organizational Psychologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -2.4096722369038948, "y": -1.873748106549436, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Instructional Coordinators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 1.5692512950702353, "y": 0.6283372102046054, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Structural Metal Fabricators and Fitters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.1424885873388584, "y": 1.1113836504282495, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bill and Account Collectors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -0.1054403554296852, "y": -0.1226380568499008, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anesthesiologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.607089861069479, "y": 0.3625311479896964, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Couriers and Messengers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.4845507504345065, "y": 0.8611705519922842, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bridge and Lock Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 1.7037371555840484, "y": 0.2038056414528196, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cabinetmakers and Bench Carpenters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": -1.0137543579788193, "y": -0.4180262180863729, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "News Analysts, Reporters, and Journalists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2138198991103129, "y": 0.5173509320945054, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surgical Technologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 1.1668832916626033, "y": 0.2121641423044445, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crushing, Grinding, and Polishing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.4567698277364611, "y": 0.3532651305851383, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Stockers and Order Fillers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -2.1973074295516635, "y": -1.3808401820098453, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Preschool", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.1882996330761322, "y": -0.4287701686383378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Signal and Track Switch Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -2.678043052247481, "y": -1.6814896517281743, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropology and Archeology Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.6284146529175972, "y": -1.173473636669783, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dietitians and Nutritionists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.1449935856638015, "y": -0.3942567266559647, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Loan Officers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.122053898003729, "y": 0.4391685872432179, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fallers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.2006300736652895, "y": 0.2415292771712032, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.4436314059819304, "y": 0.4476966830581191, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Welding, Soldering, and Brazing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.1278383693052152, "y": 0.2733249177323729, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cleaning, Washing, and Metal Pickling Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.3778462498280805, "y": -0.5249279594054749, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rail Car Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -2.1916749066981374, "y": 0.3776478305970298, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 1.296698571108416, "y": 0.7206932847569244, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furnace, Kiln, Oven, Drier, and Kettle Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.1671578337793612, "y": 0.5596459401413999, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audio and Video Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.1573230344851855, "y": 0.842045453577487, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tax Examiners and Collectors, and Revenue Agents", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.6749912044561487, "y": -1.3938952542378198, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Materials Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.6703019897005987, "y": -0.517268926304522, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Correctional Officers and Jailers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": 0.0789976584300912, "y": -0.0319613075533194, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Plasterers and Stucco Masons", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.5375808481437458, "y": -1.7285894926632013, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geoscientists, Except Hydrologists and Geographers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.224750512462694, "y": -0.564049581303414, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Electricians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.2357350142406782, "y": -0.6736007874983986, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maintenance and Repair Workers, General", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.6477413017014126, "y": 1.979860085336681, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Plant and System Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.4170901505059415, "y": -0.6481511697313108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Environmental Science and Protection Technicians, Including Health", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.9696197679012744, "y": -0.6033952757796771, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Database Architects", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.080705035950846, "y": -0.3561213822478264, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Actuaries", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.5674793985091129, "y": -1.0744809961151065, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Real Estate Brokers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.5732530508282707, "y": -0.9527003673193264, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aerospace Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.1082097926900292, "y": -0.7477243545871888, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Purchasing Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.2368697348737455, "y": -0.6000761800414834, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Genetic Counselors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.2868250719940093, "y": 1.4258112577101307, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Extruding and Drawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.063603007346989, "y": -0.941582977348845, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physician Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.4156730071465573, "y": 0.9175406008240258, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Court, Municipal, and License Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.9648326392566368, "y": 2.7735621867140567, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telephone Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "2.8"}}, {"x": 1.4944749258992505, "y": 1.2105395982479372, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting and Slicing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.6088210704439724, "y": 2.113268072214425, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Dealers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "2.1"}}, {"x": 0.0544638808907855, "y": -0.1356029499591191, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Institution and Cafeteria", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -1.5698461478187382, "y": -0.3487615050458227, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Probation Officers and Correctional Treatment Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.5227517808048713, "y": -1.270680593235209, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.1120048346310218, "y": -1.3911799612513187, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Landscaping, Lawn Service, and Groundskeeping Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -0.2838007226561892, "y": 0.5494797868144166, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wind Turbine Service Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.7873494888731263, "y": 0.472712350022055, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gas Plant Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.5432782618324024, "y": 0.7761718702554996, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Refuse and Recyclable Material Collectors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.9876383819259246, "y": 0.7769366037314608, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Secretaries and Administrative Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 0.4968517150190133, "y": 0.5194640396300716, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Manicurists and Pedicurists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.0257971916548012, "y": 0.3842542364284055, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Camera and Photographic Equipment Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -2.0429762380992504, "y": -2.092558237933194, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Training and Development Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.1"}}, {"x": -2.5995567005637263, "y": -1.7413174128753748, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geography Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.3474812011467645, "y": 0.5816629934821564, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Skincare Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1754609527810028, "y": -1.1071197858238884, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.0526944637607085, "y": -0.2758565602456502, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telecommunications Line Installers and Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.8571361904186984, "y": 0.4599543797063599, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Petroleum Pump System Operators, Refinery Operators, and Gaugers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.2345619850291924, "y": 0.4797733577769951, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Railroad Brake, Signal, and Switch Operators and Locomotive Firers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.2457903655302724, "y": 0.0582176742081917, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Boilermakers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -1.844303305266324, "y": -1.764086569407202, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Human Resources Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": -0.1260889466911172, "y": 0.6043578751229657, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Budget Analysts", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 0.2537889101602624, "y": 0.2744437195026044, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Brickmasons, Blockmasons, Stonemasons, and Tile and Marble Setters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.808740204622335, "y": -0.1623899316545318, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Truck and Tractor Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 0.0520040199750981, "y": -0.8146553091301973, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction and Building Inspectors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.3711124076315791, "y": -0.8964587515708811, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forest and Conservation Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.5237718807119005, "y": 0.7877720885971908, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cutting, Punching, and Press Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": -0.6174693193341871, "y": -0.5678870145431338, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Civil Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -1.2030330140812149, "y": -0.8333851587986286, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric and Space Scientists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -2.5083700753920217, "y": -1.917086462550661, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Biological Science Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.7627317800520613, "y": -0.870607815023757, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -2.298149445515067, "y": -3.150392279245335, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Directors, Religious Activities and Education", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-3.2"}}, {"x": 0.0051004306838344, "y": -0.9100470331741998, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orthotists and Prosthetists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.6606012357167904, "y": 0.549582894022315, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insurance Sales Agents", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": 0.3581966381529175, "y": 0.0691995314368749, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bus Drivers, Transit and Intercity", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.099092448645622, "y": -0.6563552980344222, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Farming, Fishing, and Forestry Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.2911533154558028, "y": 0.3922974939376122, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Structure, Surfaces, Rigging, and Systems Assemblers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": 0.6225937214772261, "y": -0.1956972048805025, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pump Operators, Except Wellhead Pumpers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": 1.125185949742516, "y": 0.7188723580944468, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Receptionists and Information Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.4230033336470683, "y": 0.6559732566198974, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compliance Officers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.2587917883637263, "y": 0.9731805213137112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": 0.4988286834907223, "y": 0.4115537158778558, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Barbers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.070292272589261, "y": -0.2762382986028072, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Nurse Anesthetists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.2559700437728052, "y": 0.2801289932939732, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Network and Computer Systems Administrators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.116606103763896, "y": -0.5306687829631038, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Machinery Mechanics", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.5972586966591582, "y": 1.0169977620024206, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Technical Writers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.2576003139314876, "y": -1.894622309351864, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Animal Trainers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -0.4416143440693185, "y": -1.2155165824501373, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Meeting, Convention, and Event Planners", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -0.0492848157200664, "y": 0.0464369491938291, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hazardous Materials Removal Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 1.560602845272098, "y": 1.7218942602992406, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": 0.0080754223642107, "y": -0.6023736472329735, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Laborers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0866683460247287, "y": 0.0038309389872154, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Installers and Repairers, Transportation Equipment", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.1705728751798026, "y": 0.5990875575807667, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Geological Technicians, Except Hydrologic Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.4695803771373444, "y": -0.9537474241394196, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Occupational Health and Safety Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -1.3650349396344752, "y": -1.1514179239536149, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.1595452472778691, "y": -1.438563742232027, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Merchandise Displayers and Window Trimmers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -2.1287863077952545, "y": -1.7211382988891573, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Marriage and Family Therapists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.5870702804299744, "y": 0.6741424531705897, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electrical and Electronics Drafters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 1.3581428982909962, "y": -0.0400367106015421, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Desktop Publishers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -1.3809781425997854, "y": -1.5306538276477482, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Management Analysts", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.5"}}, {"x": -0.1797835636212159, "y": -0.0482384515239916, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electric Motor, Power Tool, and Related Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": -0.2556886459549692, "y": -0.2959987074785453, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mobile Heavy Equipment Mechanics, Except Engines", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.0487510009390903, "y": -1.3111711767115684, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Exercise Trainers and Group Fitness Instructors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.6965858881825896, "y": 0.5097164017692816, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Aides", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.1718972931391926, "y": -1.065549841268239, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Makeup Artists, Theatrical and Performance", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 0.8637993315744092, "y": 0.8260723631505726, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dispatchers, Except Police, Fire, and Ambulance", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.8"}}, {"x": 1.5355923226973918, "y": 1.1464368897532982, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Print Binding and Finishing Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": -1.6600603910000598, "y": -0.7699093916046311, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Music Directors and Composers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.2258995609051106, "y": -0.0236777409365872, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Veterinary Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.3267894098957402, "y": 0.2273720488599744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.72463420762643, "y": -0.2612872430164695, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Model Makers, Wood", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.2620153821171809, "y": -1.0402418835199054, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Massage Therapists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -0.1060314374146394, "y": -0.4516868248810886, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Athletic Trainers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -0.3538578335734947, "y": 0.1054502388754892, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineering Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -0.4341561179977524, "y": -0.314238342840608, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bartenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.4801970194085776, "y": 1.0876278336010032, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Telemarketers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.316520428518349, "y": 1.6774524291926896, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Data Entry Keyers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.7"}}, {"x": -2.688644038440529, "y": -1.2124474289143454, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Criminal Justice and Law Enforcement Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.1236658608653378, "y": 0.0277980723573438, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Editors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.5746377873236459, "y": -1.2548064624972122, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fire Inspectors and Investigators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 1.0082236452209374, "y": 0.6368033312319524, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooling and Freezing Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.0887372080194467, "y": -0.0184082093377855, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dining Room and Cafeteria Attendants and Bartender Helpers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.0"}}, {"x": 0.1501108887472947, "y": 0.4357097431058516, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Inspectors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -1.1113614499336677, "y": -1.045496651541581, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Health and Safety Engineers, Except Mining Safety Engineers and Inspectors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.0645656627439272, "y": -0.4025694848468618, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Insulation Workers, Floor, Ceiling, and Wall", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.3267690607129359, "y": -0.6841921599322112, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.9492348782529744, "y": 0.2695348951313973, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Library Assistants, Clerical", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.0615743057244599, "y": 0.0422660961428759, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Watch and Clock Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": -0.2003963631226069, "y": -0.3540124704030162, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Forensic Science Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": -0.1112813791686588, "y": -0.5777200704469947, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hearing Aid Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 0.5692671316299338, "y": 0.7048764560791582, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Rock Splitters, Quarry", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -1.0269771718045064, "y": -1.1637615899672478, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Property, Real Estate, and Community Association Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": -1.018275313626945, "y": -0.8338399312873329, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mathematicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": 0.6461099309865285, "y": 1.4282417280018922, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pharmacy Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": 0.5573198731795456, "y": 2.3664798768120976, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Proofreaders and Copy Markers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "2.4"}}, {"x": 0.514763818096608, "y": 0.6156410841929586, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Plant Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.632352658323323, "y": 0.5041814617212416, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Patternmakers, Wood", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.0068831250513402, "y": 1.4246315496926814, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Orderlies", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -1.292031744233323, "y": -0.2747895742280462, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Social and Human Service Assistants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.3227550962315627, "y": -0.4239930589522561, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Film and Video Editors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 1.1445916937000815, "y": -0.2798001700417336, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cargo and Freight Agents", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.493247769751932, "y": -0.574501587778538, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Medical and Health Services Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": -2.6449241353147617, "y": -1.7290811173566742, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Communications Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.7490959038593289, "y": -1.0455712529, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Producers and Directors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.9174497967651492, "y": 0.1842021869879643, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Counter and Rental Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.171126463083087, "y": 2.5187493896221773, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Gambling Cage Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "2.5"}}, {"x": -0.8942702015683808, "y": 1.0276743659096343, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Title Examiners, Abstractors, and Searchers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -0.6342625584980368, "y": -1.863599975464569, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fish and Game Wardens", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": 0.5652800761572494, "y": -0.8802520756486636, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Farmworkers, Farm, Ranch, and Aquacultural Animals", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 1.7285711405480202, "y": -1.001681428901726, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Timing Device Assemblers and Adjusters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": 0.547670200932374, "y": 0.2048261572016251, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.2475721438040315, "y": -0.4210110569352954, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Painters, Construction and Maintenance", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.4"}}, {"x": 0.2239599236095198, "y": 0.0932713927568725, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Ship Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.2802350995882681, "y": -0.8235694729289396, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sales Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.176304879505349, "y": -1.17353522050073, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Physical Therapists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.5266330739566093, "y": 0.0796191480762997, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Light Truck Drivers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": 0.3292530068626986, "y": 0.6529288275583993, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Traffic Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": -0.1299147782969472, "y": 0.3864681686870737, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Electro-Mechanical and Mechatronics Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -2.041401742974442, "y": 0.5980359105672828, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Administrative Law Judges, Adjudicators, and Hearing Officers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": -0.1085833910473886, "y": -0.6794706237786028, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Operating Engineers and Other Construction Equipment Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 1.1303084801685592, "y": 1.5141610416358646, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "New Accounts Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": 0.0120132310379012, "y": -1.1873026308664851, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Audiovisual Equipment Installers and Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.4801909601549012, "y": -0.816648081382791, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Wellhead Pumpers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.0459941329299251, "y": 0.2544325896028706, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dental Hygienists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.1666970403450055, "y": 1.0967578935314926, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cardiovascular Technologists and Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.2622247112602716, "y": 1.5831949185341108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machinists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.2393192126268669, "y": -0.2477792555226949, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Aircraft Cargo Handling Supervisors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.2"}}, {"x": -0.1020536542191781, "y": -0.1309808706579929, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parking Enforcement Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.2006143371252591, "y": 1.5616692176061004, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Fast Food and Counter Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.6"}}, {"x": 0.9841193288261854, "y": -0.2902226819176425, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Parts Salespersons", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -2.6552829380353216, "y": -1.085384831815483, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Education Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": -0.1766677373015863, "y": 1.4668247961780096, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Roof Bolters, Mining", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.5"}}, {"x": -1.7848479563582245, "y": -0.6635636563599853, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Compensation and Benefits Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": 0.0143352821557936, "y": -0.2913852991570329, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Carpenters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -1.3908082194129945, "y": -1.7476282021598943, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Anthropologists and Archeologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 1.1724090113545582, "y": 1.059243035120383, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Food and Tobacco Roasting, Baking, and Drying Machine Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.1"}}, {"x": 1.949131511062806, "y": -0.051413068811212, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Upholsterers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.9", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": 1.381540513537896, "y": 2.006967028695426, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Machine Feeders and Offbearers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "2.0"}}, {"x": -0.3408140358296199, "y": -0.5665656501121378, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Service Technicians and Mechanics", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.6"}}, {"x": 1.647598314963139, "y": -0.1460597364692063, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Furniture Finishers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -0.4270094292994817, "y": -1.7453540126887297, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Set and Exhibit Designers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -2.2101240344559305, "y": -1.3370913112158744, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Choreographers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.2719471067841131, "y": 0.2071361577794199, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Tile and Stone Setters", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 1.3618987960982238, "y": 1.239376988667188, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Semiconductor Processing Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.4", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 1.621582500896366, "y": 1.3591321741120774, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Milling and Planing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Metal and Plastic", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.5411154359535115, "y": -0.0586105006816206, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mechanical Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.1"}}, {"x": -2.195998097173527, "y": -1.5617164997234505, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Special Education Teachers, Secondary School", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.6"}}, {"x": -2.04550256521286, "y": -1.8245011596794236, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sociologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.8"}}, {"x": 1.0702985181922842, "y": 0.73048476896969, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bakers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.7"}}, {"x": 0.3957731906355917, "y": 0.300758157626939, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Passenger Attendants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": -0.2551387083003237, "y": -0.9081771274176852, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Registered Nurses", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.3697698747565776, "y": -0.8791403433824152, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Psychiatric Technicians", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.0410367154226354, "y": -0.8515657525789402, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Podiatrists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": 0.4854689916985475, "y": -1.1327084593718657, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Advertising Sales Agents", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.1"}}, {"x": 1.492220708118864, "y": 1.1750027166854198, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Postal Service Clerks", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.2"}}, {"x": 0.0810902616263389, "y": 0.2968565731359099, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Computer Network Support Specialists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.3"}}, {"x": 0.1300774547234769, "y": -0.4994005675931286, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cooks, Private Household", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.5"}}, {"x": -1.4997030647542, "y": 1.3436469011677024, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Dancers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.5", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 1.0690877883366476, "y": -0.7336096555311683, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Equipment Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.7"}}, {"x": -0.409770603151762, "y": -0.7596882588378406, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Mining and Geological Engineers, Including Mining Safety Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.3088473078642967, "y": -0.9271927119522156, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Pediatricians, General", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.3", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.9"}}, {"x": -0.1224342010910847, "y": -0.8178909153404988, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Helpers--Extraction Workers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -0.015447657450331, "y": -0.2979090631898951, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Automotive Body and Related Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 0.180596735769221, "y": 1.018218168909433, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Riggers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "1.0"}}, {"x": -2.698655254601816, "y": -1.9062866927436664, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Law Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.9"}}, {"x": -1.1917058624793486, "y": -1.4188227109715064, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Natural Sciences Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.4"}}, {"x": -1.1327248980797748, "y": -1.3042871214464526, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Construction Managers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.1", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": -0.4497029891534363, "y": -0.290878095326021, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Industrial Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.028990704130639, "y": 0.4063919049471256, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Chemical Equipment Operators and Tenders", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "0.4"}}, {"x": -0.3908402485447847, "y": 0.5933234946090281, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Hosts and Hostesses, Restaurant, Lounge, and Coffee Shop", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "0.6"}}, {"x": 1.6323207594989937, "y": 1.3611622417453817, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sawing Machine Setters, Operators, and Tenders, Wood", "Duckworth et al. rating": "1.6", "Autor et al. rating": "1.4"}}, {"x": -0.0642997585748182, "y": 0.1764881636946277, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Locker Room, Coatroom, and Dressing Room Attendants", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.2"}}, {"x": 0.8257327289408259, "y": 0.1420791956188615, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Cartographers and Photogrammetrists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "0.1"}}, {"x": -2.658488563305613, "y": -2.211084482938715, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Agricultural Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -1.0402216521849754, "y": -2.1624961778599108, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coaches and Scouts", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.0", "Autor et al. rating": "-2.2"}}, {"x": -0.4931632511131985, "y": -1.241868951622614, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Bioengineers and Biomedical Engineers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.2"}}, {"x": 0.6730354555433129, "y": -0.823949326841795, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Surveyors", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.8"}}, {"x": -1.250563477288417, "y": 0.9243229638670988, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Musicians and Singers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-1.3", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": 0.3743405837221412, "y": -1.0059177475619447, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Concierges", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.0"}}, {"x": -2.52346534123174, "y": -1.3104448357507248, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Atmospheric, Earth, Marine, and Space Sciences Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.5", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.3"}}, {"x": 0.1603009623436161, "y": -0.3329546031290148, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Optometrists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": 1.9766521371103685, "y": 1.26618186397543, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Sewing Machine Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "2.0", "Autor et al. rating": "1.3"}}, {"x": 0.8739946726062857, "y": 0.4730577743534532, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Power Distributors and Dispatchers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.9", "Autor et al. rating": "0.5"}}, {"x": -0.4443285654657969, "y": -1.6915885036748526, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Speech-Language Pathologists", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.4", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": -0.1402187606525747, "y": 0.0455510273001787, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Crossing Guards and Flaggers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.1", "Autor et al. rating": "0.0"}}, {"x": 0.8196898409011085, "y": -0.2632569270088317, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Water and Wastewater Treatment Plant and System Operators", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.8", "Autor et al. rating": "-0.3"}}, {"x": -0.1525808491208962, "y": 0.8681469156656431, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Coin, Vending, and Amusement Machine Servicers and Repairers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-0.2", "Autor et al. rating": "0.9"}}, {"x": -2.7153684094286428, "y": -1.7141046559031947, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Economics Teachers, Postsecondary", "Duckworth et al. rating": "-2.7", "Autor et al. rating": "-1.7"}}, {"x": 0.032387304151781, "y": -0.167345290078491, "tooltipData": {"Occupation</span>": "Embalmers", "Duckworth et al. rating": "0.0", "